ADVERTISEMENT

11-year-old charged with murder of 8-year-old who was shot after arguing about puppies

cigaretteman

HB King
May 29, 2001
79,436
62,545
113
An argument between two children over puppies turned tragic Saturday when an 11-year-old boy killed his 8-year-old neighbor with a shotgun, according to authorities in Jefferson County, Tenn.

The 11-year-old has been charged with first-degree murder in the girl’s death, Jefferson County Sheriff Bud McCoig told The Washington Post. Authorities aren’t releasing the names of either child, but Latasha Dyer told ABC affiliate WATE that her daughter, McKayla, was killed.

“She was a precious little girl,” Dyer said through tears in an on-air interview with WATE. “She was a mommy’s girl. No matter how bad of a mood you were in, she could always make you smile.”


Each of the children had a puppy, the sheriff said. The 11-year-old “wanted to see the 8-year-old’s, and she said no, and then he went and retrieved a gun,” McCoig said.

The boy fired the 12-gauge shotgun from inside of his house, striking the girl as she stood in her yard, according to the sheriff. The gun, which was stored in a closet without locks, belonged to the boy’s father, McCoig said.

When first responders and police arrived on the scene Saturday night, they found the girl “lying on the ground with a gunshot to the chest,” McCoig said. She was taken to an area hospital, where she died from her injuries.

[Young people are far more likely to die by guns than in cars]

On Monday, a judge ordered the boy to be held in a juvenile facility pending his next court hearing, on Oct. 28; the case could later be transferred to adult court, McCoig said.

Saturday’s killing, which came just two days after a mass school shooting in rural Oregon, has rocked the small community of White Pine, Tenn. Both children attended White Pine School, which teaches students from kindergarten through eighth grade, principal Bill Walker said.

“We remember her smile and her beautiful face,” Walker told reporters Monday. “Our normal has changed.”

[Where in America do gun owners live?]

Dyer told Knoxville’s WATE TV that she had previously approached the school principal about the 11-year-old bullying her daughter.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...r-arguing-about-puppies/?tid=trending_strip_1
 
If he fired from across any distance and killed her, it had to be a slug.


also; can't help but think of this.....

pic-dump-2-14.jpg
 
A non assault, or non slug round in a shot gun is not going to kill anybody, unless the end of the barrel is inches to a few feet from the target. If anybody has assault rounds, or slugs for their shotguns, they should not be stored near the gun. Even if you want to use it for home protection, I would probably still have a non lethal round as my first in the mag, maybe even the second. Depending upon the type of shotgun, the third round could always be the lethal load.
 
If you're charged in adult court do you go to adult prison? Lawyers of HROT, what's likely in store for the 11 year old?
 
If you're charged in adult court do you go to adult prison? Lawyers of HROT, what's likely in store for the 11 year old?

Based on the 15 year old charges with manslaughter for killing a transgender person in Law and Order last week, they stay in a juvenile detention center until 18 and then transfer to prison.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
Apparently Billy Madison's speech about the puppy wouldn't have made us all dumber for hearing, if that teacher would have taken a minute to listen.....

The Puppy That Lost His Way

 
The girl apparently was uneasy as the 11-year-old boy pointed a 12-gauge shotgun out the open window of the mobile home.

“She told him, ‘You need to put that away before somebody gets shot,’ ” said Chasity Arwood, manager of the White Pine mobile home park.

Within minutes, 8-year-old MaKayla Dyer lay motionless on the grass with a single gunshot wound to her chest.

“He had pointed it at my son’s bedroom window. He pointed it at the other girl and then shot MaKayla,” Arwood said. “I don’t know if the boy knew it was loaded.”

MaKayla was taken from the scene of the 7:30 p.m. Saturday shooting to the Morristown-Hamblen Healthcare System emergency room, where she was pronounced dead.

Jefferson County Sheriff G. W. “Bud” McCoig said the 11-year-old boy was charged with delinquency by first-degree murder in what investigators deemed an “intentional shooting.” The sheriff has not identified the boy because of his age, but Arwood identified the boy as Benny Tiller, who she said lived in the mobile home with his parents and five siblings.

He appeared at 11:30 a.m. Monday before Jefferson County Juvenile Court Judge Dennis “Will” Roach II for a detention hearing.

See also: White Pine boy, 11, not the youngest to face charges in an East Tenn. slaying
Barry Fain, Jefferson County youth services officer, told members of the media gathered at the courthouse that the judge would not allow coverage of the detention hearing. State law allows coverage of court proceedings for juvenile suspects 14 and older accused of certain violent crimes, including murder. The judge turned down a News Sentinel request to grant an exception.

Fain said the 4th Judicial District public defender’s office was appointed to represent the boy.

No one responded Monday to repeated calls to the public defender’s office, to District Attorney General Jimmy Dunn or to McCoig seeking information on the outcome of the detention hearing.

Prosecutors have not said whether they will seek to have the boy tried as an adult.

Jess Calloway, 46, was in his house next door to the Tiller family’s mobile home when he heard the shotgun blast and screams.

“We heard the shot, and I ran over there to check on her while my wife called 911,” Calloway said. “I checked her vitals, and I couldn’t find any. The mother was holding her.”

Pandemonium ensued, with people yelling and screaming toward the Tillers’ mobile home, he said.

Arwood said the Tillers and the Dyers had moved into the mobile home park along Robin Road a couple of months ago. The Tillers’ children ranged in age from 13 to 4, she said.

“They were never no problem, but they never let those children out,” Arwood said. “The only time I saw them was when they were running to the (school) bus stop.”

The shotgun blast and screams brought Arwood running from her home, where she and relatives had gathered to watch the kickoff of the University of Tennessee-Arkansas football game.

“I was trying to hold the mama back,” Arwood said.

As people screamed at the occupants of the Tiller mobile home, the children’s mother opened the back door, asked what was happening and “slammed the door shut and locked it,” Arwood said.

“She never asked how the girl was,” Arwood said.

Latasha Dyer, MaKayla’s mother, began pounding in anger on the now-closed window from which the shotgun had been fired, Arwood said. The mother’s fists shattered the glass, causing bleeding wounds that Arwood nursed with a towel.

McKayla was an outgoing, laughing child who earlier Saturday had been bouncing through the neighborhood with one of her two puppies wrapped in a blanket, Arwood recalled.

Arwood said MaKayla, her 11-year-old sister, Kattie Dyer, and another 11-year-old girl were standing outside the Tillers’ home’s window talking to the boy just before the shooting. Not a single harsh word was exchanged, she said.

“They were laughing and giggling,” Arwood said.

The discussion turned to MaKayla’s puppies. Apparently the boy asked MaKayla to get one of the dogs. MaKayla, Arwood said, started to say she would go get one of the puppies, but the shotgun blast cut her words short.

The boy threw the shotgun and a pellet gun out the window and closed it, Arwood said. MaKayla’s sister, Kattie, caught the shotgun in the air as he tossed it out the window, Arwood said.

The state Department of Children’s Services also is investigating the shooting. Carrie Weir, a DCS spokeswoman, said she could not comment on the case or divulge whether any children had been taken into state custody.

All the children involved in the shooting attend White Pine Elementary School. Bill Walker, principal of the school, said a school counselor called him about 10:30 p.m. Saturday with news of the shooting. Walker had just left the Tennessee-Arkansas game.

“She was a wonderful young lady who enjoyed being in school,” Walker said of MaKayla.

Walker said he learned more of the shooting Sunday when the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office called him. The principal said he called a meeting Sunday of all school employees, from the cafeteria workers to administrators. The 90-minute, tearful meeting, he said, involved preparations for greeting children Monday at school and arranging for counselors to be available.

http://www.knoxnews.com/news/watchful-eye/boy-11-accused-in-girls-death-appears-in-court_15418066
 
Leave it to the resident Libs to turn this into a joke-making circle-jerk.
And there's the difference between a lib and a con. Libs will only joke about arming kids to fight crime. Cons actually want to make it a reality.
 
And there's the difference between a lib and a con. Libs will only joke about arming kids to fight crime. Cons actually want to make it a reality.
Yes, I'm sure that's exactly what cons want.

Glad to see my point about making jokes in light of an 8-year-old girl's death sunk in for ya.
 
Yes, I'm sure that's exactly what cons want.

Glad to see my point about making jokes in light of an 8-year-old girl's death sunk in for ya.
Yesterday I heard conservative posters talking about giving every 10 year old a gun. So, yes, it does appear to be exactly what you guys want.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT