Barta, in attempt to slow down the NIL deals, is advocating for the NCAA to repeal the one-time transfer rule that it installed 13 months ago

[BlackNGoldBleeder]

Gary is out of touch ... as usual.

View embedded media

He is. NIL is here to stay. If Gary can’t handle the change, he needs to get out. Further widening the recruiting gap for Iowa because he’s stubborn and nostalgic is unacceptable.

Iowa is about to get left behind. Kick rocks, Gary.

 

[BlackNGoldBleeder]

Coaches can also be fired any time. Once scholarships can get dropped any time for subpar performance, then that's comparable....

You don’t think kids ever get forced out?

 

[nbanflfactory]

You don’t think kids ever get forced out?

Encouraged to leave or literally forced out, as in fired like a coach?

Fired...no.

 

[sober_teacher]

Coaches can also be fired any time. Once scholarships can get dropped any time for subpar performance, then that's comparable....

Look at all the guys from Iowa who went into the portal and came out without a scholarship. How do you think the year end meetings for the players go. If you are in your 3rd or 4th year and not playing you sort of get encouraged to leave and if you don’t they will try and make you quit.

You don’t think kids ever get forced out?

Remember “Creaning?”

I’m not sure if it’s for all p5 schools or not, but at least for some conferences I think it’s still a yearly deal for scholarships. And regardless, coach Ed can do all BUT outright cut players by their actions. Players want to play. If coaches make it clear via depth chart, end of season evals, etc., that player X is not going to play there, they’re going to leave.

I noticed that you neatly deflected my initial question tho. If coaches can accept a job elsewhere without penalty, why should players have to sit out a year if they want to transfer?

 

[nbanflfactory]

Remember “Creaning?”

I’m not sure if it’s for all p5 schools or not, but at least for some conferences I think it’s still a yearly deal for scholarships. And regardless, coach Ed can do all BUT outright cut players by their actions. Players want to play. If coaches make it clear via depth chart, end of season evals, etc., that player X is not going to play there, they’re going to leave.

I noticed that you neatly deflected my initial question tho. If coaches can accept a job elsewhere without penalty, why should players have to sit out a year if they want to transfer?

Scholarships are annual I believe, but I don't know of a single b1g school that actually pulls them for not being good enough. I know harbaugh has told 5th year players to take a hike, but that's it iirc

I told you before, once players can be fired then I'd be fine with that. Don't like my opinion? Good for you ...

 

[BlackNGoldBleeder]

Encouraged to leave or literally forced out, as in fired like a coach?

Fired...no.

Yes, the former. The results are ostensibly the same.

 

[nbanflfactory]

Yes, the former. The results are ostensibly the same.

If you quit a job because your hours are cut it's not the same as being fired. Same with this case.

 

[JabroniBlvd]

He was still cut from the team.

There are 130 head coaches and over 11,000 athletes. Dumb argument

 

[sober_teacher]

Scholarships are annual I believe, but I don't know of a single b1g school that actually pulls them for not being good enough. I know harbaugh has told 5th year players to take a hike, but that's it iirc

I told you before, once players can be fired then I'd be fine with that. Don't like my opinion? Good for you ...

Again, if coaches can leave without penalties, why cant players?

 

[MepoDawg#]

Again, if coaches can leave without penalties, why cant players?

Coaches have buyouts.

 

[sober_teacher]

Coaches have buyouts.

Which are paid for by the school hiring the new coach.

 

[nbanflfactory]

Again, if coaches can leave without penalties, why cant players?

I told you twice, I'm not going to a third time

 

[sober_teacher]

I told you twice, I'm not going to a third time

No, you’re refusing to answer the question.

 

[cidhawkeye]

He was still not allowed to play.

He was still not required to practice

FIFY

 

[bumpstock]

Iowa needs to change their state laws pertaining to NIL quickly:

Fissures already appearing after NCAA's attempted crackdown on NIL from boosters, collectives

Enforcing its updated rules will be a tall task for the NCAA

www.cbssports.com

Border states (MO, IL) are locking up their rights to control NIL. NCAA is no longer a "National" association.