Democrats have long found the flip phone Chuck Schumer still insists on using as an endearing quirk that illustrates how committed he is to his way of talking to all sorts of allies, all the time.
After how he handled the spending fight, many inside and outside the Capitol are starting to see that phone as a metaphor for a leader who's out of date and refusing to change as politics changes radically around him.
"This is not the first time that members of the caucus expressed frustration that he wasn't as inclusive as he could have been on decision making or strategy, but the stakes of this particular vote were huge," said one Senate Democrat, who like others, is still wary of going public with attacks on the leader.
Click to shrink...
CNN's conversations with three-dozen Democratic senators, members of the House, top aides and other prominent leaders detail a cratering of support, with many starting to feel that he can't be the party's future and shouldn't be their present.
"If he doesn't lose it between now and then, he won't be leader in two years," said another Democratic senator, who added, looking ahead to the next expected Congressional showdown, "he can't be trusted alone to negotiate the debt limit."
Click to shrink...
Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders — an independent who caucuses with the Democrats — called the situation "an absolute failure of Democratic leadership." In a video he blasted out to his own supporters, freshman California Sen. Adam Schiff called it "a bad day for our country – and for the Democratic Party."
"Schumer tried to be too smart," said another Democratic senator, "but he ended up looking indecisive."
Click to shrink...
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries was not just frustrated by what played out, but annoyed that Schumer—who otherwise calls multiple times a day to check in on everything from strategy to tweets—barely talked to him about any of this over the last few weeks, according to several House Democratic sources.
And when Schumer announced his own yes vote, it was not just within a day of floating an alternative strategy—he even surprised one of his closest allies, according to multiple senators: Washington Sen. Patty Murray, the ranking member on the Appropriations Committee and far from a standard resistance figure. She ended up voting no.
And one part that stuck out to me:
House Democrats were bewildered themselves by the suggestion that Schumer was doing them any favors. Several joined the nearly unanimous Democratic vote against the Republican budget bill not because they wanted a shutdown, but because they thought they were giving the Senate more leverage. Others were convinced that they needed to be part of a unified Democratic effort.
Several close to Jeffries himself, meanwhile, scoff at Schumer's suggesting that House Democrats didn't think Johnson would pass the bill, arguing the senator doesn't get how much obedience to Trump has come to define Republicans in Congress. They think Schumer never understood Jeffries's strategy was to push for the fight since he was convinced Democrats could win, and worried about the policy and political consequences of putting a rubber stamp on the Republican bill.
At a panel of union leaders at their retreat, Connecticut Rep. Rosa DeLauro asked them to call Schumer to remind him that they supported a "No" vote. Several did. Schumer told those he spoke with he still felt confident he was right.
Later in that same strategy session, another House Democrat vented more broadly: "What's Chuck Schumer thinking?"
Another voice shouted back from the crowd, "Of himself!"
Many members started to clap and cheer, according to two people in the room.