ADVERTISEMENT

CRANDIC to Study Passenger Rail Between Iowa City and Cedar Rapids

cigaretteman

HB King
May 29, 2001
79,435
62,542
113
Creating passenger rail from Iowa City to Cedar Rapids will get another look.

The Cedar Rapids and Iowa City Railway, or CRANDIC, with financial support from several public agencies has commissioned a new feasibility study for service between Iowa City and The Eastern Iowa Airport.

“This was studied 20 years ago and 10 years ago,” said Jeffery Woods, CRANDIC manager of marketing and business development. “This is part of the natural progression. The latest iteration in the process.”

CRANDIC earlier this week gave the green light to HDR of Omaha to begin the first phase of a conceptual feasibility study. The $40,000 study should take about 12 weeks to complete and will focus on general information about cost, ridership, equipment and regulations.

If results merit it, phases two and three would proceed with details about riders, routes, stops and frequency, Woods said.

Rail advocates for years have been urging the utilization of light rail to enhance mobility, reduce emissions, decongest traffic and provide a cheaper alternative to widening Interstate 380 to six lanes, which could cost some $170 million.

The last passenger rail study, in 2006, found the cost too high and ridership demand too low.

The study estimated service from The Eastern Iowa Airport to Iowa City would cost $21.4 million with annual operations around $5 million. It envisioned 837 daily boardings, which would grow to 1,991 by 2030.

“I think the study is a good idea,” Cedar Rapids Mayor Ron Corbett said. “The dynamics of the region is constantly changing. What may not have worked 10 years ago might work today.”

Woods said several factors have changed, including a growing population and a different political climate. There’s more pressure to reduce carbon footprints and expand transportation options, he said.

Johnson County population grew 18 percent, from 117,459 to 139,155, and Linn County has grown by 10 percent, or from 196,706 to 216,111, between 2003 and 2013, the most recent 10 year span available from the U.S. Census Bureau.

I-380 traffic in North Liberty, roughly halfway between the airport and Iowa City, grew 42 percent, from 34,500 to 49,300 vehicles a day, between 2002 and 2010, the last time it was measured by the Iowa Department of Transportation. Traffic on I-80 in Coralville grew 17 percent, from 45,700 to 53,400, in that period.

CRANDIC once offered light-rail service, but that was discontinued in 1953, Woods said. But because the track already exists, it eliminates some important hurdles to restarting it.

The CRANDIC track runs through Iowa City, Coralville, North Liberty, Swisher and into Cedar Rapids. Freight traffic is 24/7 north of the airport, making it an expensive proposition, Woods said. The track in study area sees only about 100 rail cars a year.

The Iowa DOT has shown some signs of openness to passenger rail. The agency is contributing $15,000 toward the study, and has invested in several other recent studies looking to address congestion and commuting in Eastern Iowa. Passenger rail was identified as part of a multipronged solution, along with park and rides, van pools and intercity transit.

“With all the other things going on, we thought it would be a good idea to see if this is possible,” said Amanda Martin, Iowa DOT freight and passenger policy coordinator.

At a Johnson County Supervisors meeting last week, all five officials spoke favorably about passenger rail.

The county, Iowa City, Coralville, North Liberty and the University of Iowa each will pay $2,500 for the study. CRANDIC is paying $12,500.

http://thegazette.com/subject/news/...th-new-study-looks-at-passenger-rail-20150630
 
200_s.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: WORTHYWISH
This is always going to be on somebody's list because it's so obvious. The tracks are already there. Rail service between Iowa City and Cedar Rapids was once extremely popular. The old "Vomit Comet" ran 16 trains between the cities every day and ridership peaked at over 500,000 in 1945. The trains reached 90 mph. Patronage fell off dramatically as cars and highways became a better option post-war. In 1952, Crandic was down to 9 passenger runs a day and a ridership under 200,000. The next year was the last year for regular passenger service.

I can see the reason for studying it again, because I live in the Corridor and the population explosion here is really pretty spectacular. So is the traffic on I-380; it seems like half the people in Cedar Rapids work in Iowa City, and half the people in Iowa City work in Cedar Rapids.

But people like independence and convenience. Once you get to the city, you have to get from the station to wherever you're going. You can't come and go whenever you wish. I doubt if anything comes of it, but it's worth a study. Certainly not a boondoggle like the Iowa City-Chicago Amtrak joke.
 
Why would it be so hard to have bus service? Both CR and IC already have transit buses and they could link up at the airport once an hour. It doesn't seen that complicated....but trains are cool I guess?
 
I don't see how this would ever get off the ground. Where would people disembark from the train in Cedar Rapids? At the airport and then take a bus another 10-15 miles? Downtown and then take a bus 5-10 miles? Somewhere near Collins Road and then walk to Rockwell or AEGON? Maybe they could all rent Segways. They probably aren't considering high speed rail or a bullet train, so factoring in the time waiting for your train to arrive, grinding its way up the CRANDIC tracks and then waiting again to get on a bus...it just doesn't sound that appealing.

I could understand dropping off a few boxcars of people at UIHC every day, but the return trip seems infeasible to me. If people really hated the drive on 380 that much, they would just live in the town they work in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChrisVarick
I'm pretty sure there hasn't been any traffic on that stretch for several years. In fact, there is a big yellow hunk of cast iron bolted to the track just south of Golfview. Looks like a stopper to me. They do sometimes store empty cars on the stretch just north of North Liberty and used to store a few between Zeller and Penn. When they did run trains through here about 15 years ago they were pretty slow.
 
I don't see how this would ever get off the ground. Where would people disembark from the train in Cedar Rapids? At the airport and then take a bus another 10-15 miles? Downtown and then take a bus 5-10 miles? Somewhere near Collins Road and then walk to Rockwell or AEGON? Maybe they could all rent Segways. They probably aren't considering high speed rail or a bullet train, so factoring in the time waiting for your train to arrive, grinding its way up the CRANDIC tracks and then waiting again to get on a bus...it just doesn't sound that appealing.

I could understand dropping off a few boxcars of people at UIHC every day, but the return trip seems infeasible to me. If people really hated the drive on 380 that much, they would just live in the town they work in.

Agreed. I don't think we are anywhere close to having enough population density to have mass transit of this sort be viable. That being said...I have no problem if people want to run a study to validate that....so long as the study is even handed and it isn't just front for a potential pork grab where the taxpayers end up footing the bill for some lightly used monstrosity.
 
These types of projects MIGHT work if it were more of a "Park & Ride" system. But that has to connect to the CBD of each city in this case, and that's probably not going to happen.

I have wondered if Des Moines could do a Park & Ride light rail along 235 from the western suburbs into downtown, but there isn't space along that route.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT