ADVERTISEMENT

Ex-federal judge and prominent conservative: ‘There is no Republican Party’

cigaretteman

HB King
May 29, 2001
78,171
60,037
113
  • share




  • more



CNN
CNN

Follow

Ex-federal judge and prominent conservative: ‘There is no Republican Party’​

Story by By Shawna Mizelle, CNN •1h



J. Michael Luttig, a conservative retired federal judge and key adviser to former Vice President Mike Pence, declared on Wednesday that “there is no Republican Party” and said former President Donald Trump is even more dangerous than he was in the aftermath of the 2020 election.
“American democracy simply cannot function without two equally healthy and equally strong political parties. So today, in my view, there is no Republican Party to counter the Democratic Party in the country,” Luttig, who advised Pence on how to handle the January 6, 2021, election certification vote, told CNN’s Poppy Harlow on “CNN This Morning.” “And for that reason, American democracy is in grave peril.”
Luttig, who holds bona fide conservative credentials with longstanding ties to the Supreme Court, has become increasingly outspoken in sharing his criticisms of the GOP, calling the party “spineless” in June over its continued support of Trump.
“A political party is a collection and assemblage of individuals who share a set of beliefs and principles and policy views about the United States of America. Today, there is no such shared set of beliefs and values and principles or even policy views as within the Republican Party for America,” he said on Wednesday.
Luttig also sought to shoot down possible legal defenses that Trump could mount to address the federal charges to which he has pleaded not guilty. The former judge said that by charging Trump with criminal offenses of conduct, not speech, special counsel Jack Smith ensures that there could not be a First Amendment defense from Trump’s legal team.


Asked by Harlow if Trump could use the premise that the former president actually thought he’d won the election, Luttig also struck down that defense notion “because the evidence is overwhelming that the former president knew full well that he had lost the election. And the standard will be, could a reasonable person have believed otherwise in the face of the overwhelming evidence to the contrary.”



The former judge on the 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals was a key witness at the January 6 committee hearings last year and throughout his career he was known as one of the top “feeder judges” on the court of appeals level, sending 45 of his 47 clerks to clerk for justices on the high court.
Trump ally and attorney John Eastman, who drafted the point-by-point memo claiming Pence could stop the certification on January 6, was also a clerk for Luttig. Pence relied on Luttig’s guidance when he decided to defy Trump and certify the results of the election on January 6.
While testifying last year before the House Select Committee tasked with investigating January 6, Luttig called Trump “a clear and present danger to American democracy.”
Doubling down on that assertion Wednesday morning, Luttig said he views Trump as a danger even “more so today” than when he testified due to the former president’s continuous push to falsely claim the election was stolen from him.
 
There is no question that the current GOP is not a healthy party.
Donald Trump is a cancer on democracy. There needs to be action
by the Republican party to repudiate his candidacy for President.
Hopefully, he will soon be convicted on some of the criminal charges
he is facing by a jury.
 
There is no question that the current GOP is not a healthy party.
Donald Trump is a cancer on democracy. There needs to be action
by the Republican party to repudiate his candidacy for President.
Hopefully, he will soon be convicted on some of the criminal charges
he is facing by a jury.
Maybe those jurors will be “special electors”...
 
  • share




  • more



CNN
CNN
Follow

Ex-federal judge and prominent conservative: ‘There is no Republican Party’​

Story by By Shawna Mizelle, CNN •1h



J. Michael Luttig, a conservative retired federal judge and key adviser to former Vice President Mike Pence, declared on Wednesday that “there is no Republican Party” and said former President Donald Trump is even more dangerous than he was in the aftermath of the 2020 election.
“American democracy simply cannot function without two equally healthy and equally strong political parties. So today, in my view, there is no Republican Party to counter the Democratic Party in the country,” Luttig, who advised Pence on how to handle the January 6, 2021, election certification vote, told CNN’s Poppy Harlow on “CNN This Morning.” “And for that reason, American democracy is in grave peril.”
Luttig, who holds bona fide conservative credentials with longstanding ties to the Supreme Court, has become increasingly outspoken in sharing his criticisms of the GOP, calling the party “spineless” in June over its continued support of Trump.
“A political party is a collection and assemblage of individuals who share a set of beliefs and principles and policy views about the United States of America. Today, there is no such shared set of beliefs and values and principles or even policy views as within the Republican Party for America,” he said on Wednesday.
Luttig also sought to shoot down possible legal defenses that Trump could mount to address the federal charges to which he has pleaded not guilty. The former judge said that by charging Trump with criminal offenses of conduct, not speech, special counsel Jack Smith ensures that there could not be a First Amendment defense from Trump’s legal team.


Asked by Harlow if Trump could use the premise that the former president actually thought he’d won the election, Luttig also struck down that defense notion “because the evidence is overwhelming that the former president knew full well that he had lost the election. And the standard will be, could a reasonable person have believed otherwise in the face of the overwhelming evidence to the contrary.”



The former judge on the 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals was a key witness at the January 6 committee hearings last year and throughout his career he was known as one of the top “feeder judges” on the court of appeals level, sending 45 of his 47 clerks to clerk for justices on the high court.
Trump ally and attorney John Eastman, who drafted the point-by-point memo claiming Pence could stop the certification on January 6, was also a clerk for Luttig. Pence relied on Luttig’s guidance when he decided to defy Trump and certify the results of the election on January 6.
While testifying last year before the House Select Committee tasked with investigating January 6, Luttig called Trump “a clear and present danger to American democracy.”
Doubling down on that assertion Wednesday morning, Luttig said he views Trump as a danger even “more so today” than when he testified due to the former president’s continuous push to falsely claim the election was stolen from him.
The democrats are no longer what they were prior to Obama either. It’s what parties and people do. They move some positions over time. The republicans used to the party of war as an example. That’s now the dems
 
There is no question that the current GOP is not a healthy party.
Donald Trump is a cancer on democracy. There needs to be action
by the Republican party to repudiate his candidacy for President.
Hopefully, he will soon be convicted on some of the criminal charges
he is facing by a jury.
They are him
 
"When lawyers from the New York Attorney General’s office recently questioned former President Donald Trump about his businesses, he “took the Fifth” more than 440 times, repeatedly asserting “same answer.” The Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution states that no person “shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself.” Most people know that when you invoke your Fifth Amendment right to silence and refuse to answer questions, no one can use it against you in a criminal case".

Now, the Orange Turd has 91 criminal charges pending, and who knows how many civil deals. He pled the 5th, which implies if he did answer, he would incriminate himself, so how else can it be interpreted than he is in trouble facing criminal prosecution?

The problem the Congressional Republicans have with this being an election targeted exercise is the investigations and prosecutions were underway before he announced his candidacy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torg and VodkaSam

I just don't see this working without a direct criminal conviction of or at least related to insurrection. I would love to see him disqualified. But if I'm zooming out and looking at that statement with unbiased eyes I would say that given that there is nothing clearly stating what constitutes insurrection or who would make such determinations, it would require a criminal conviction of the like to be in effect.

Maybe some of his charges are insurrection adjacent enough to disqualify him. But he has to be convicted first.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT