Seems like there is some revisionist history going on in this thread. There was certainly some doubt about how good Nickal would be. He was ranked in the second half of the top 10 and there were even people that considered him a risk because he was from Texas.
Same for Ed Ruth, people forget he was a zero time PA state champ headed to Blair his senior year who didn't establish himself as a top 10 recruit until he knocked off Chris Philips at Ironman. Even guys like Nolf and Retherford were not considered can't miss prospects like Lee, Snyder or Taylor.
Bottom line, for every guy mentioned above, there was another wrestler considered just as good coming out of high school that didn't accomplish much of anything so anyone saying they had all these guys pegged back then are full of it.
Ed Ruth WAS a top 5 recruit. Being a late bloomer doesn’t mean you are a “can miss”. Burroughs and Caesar can back that up. However, what is even more telling is that Ruth was at least ranked that high even though he was late to the party. That shows just how good he was at the end of High School.
Barely ANYONE is a true can’t miss out of High School. Even David Taylor wasn’t a lock as late as the end of his redshirt year. However, lifestyle along with talent is a great indicator. Nolf showed it to anyone that paid attention and the fact that Nickal basically owned Hall, even though he was older, showed a LOT.
As for other guys rated as high at the same time:
1.Snyder went 2,1,1,1 and won a few gold medals as well
2.Marsteller’s “lifestyle” was a giant ? But, he did find a way to AA top 4 2xs.
3.Brill was done in by injury.
4.Nolf
5.Nevills solid AA marred by some injuries.
6.Micah Jordan 3x AA and Finalist.
7.Nickal
8.McKenna 3 top 3 finishes
Of those, other than Snyder, by the time the 1st walked into a DI room, who was considered at their level? Marsteller’s issues were public. Brill was broken. 285’s are almost always bigger question marks and he was a PSU guy anyway.
Micah is the only one and his mat wrestling should have been viewed as suspect coming into DI.