ADVERTISEMENT

Hundreds of thousands of gallons of manure spill into a pair of northwest Iowa creeks, DNR officials report

cigaretteman

HB King
May 29, 2001
79,354
62,362
113
Several hundred thousand gallons of manure spilled into a Lyon County creek Wednesday and, in a separate incident on the same day, another 10,000 gallons of manure also spilled into a Kossuth County creek that flows into the Des Moines River.

In Rock Rapids, Bernie Baker of Rock Bottom Dairy reported spilling "several hundred thousand gallons of manure" after "an irrigation unit became stuck," according to an Iowa Department of Natural Resources news release Wednesday evening.

The manure flowed through fields, which included cover crops or pasture, before it eventually flowed northwest of Rock Rapids and into Mud Creek, according to the DNR. When DNR staff arrived at the creek at about 3:20 p.m., "many dead fish," including bullheads, minnows and chubs, were found on the scene.



Due to the creek's slow flow rates, the manure-laden water is moving slowly downstream, according to the release, and the DNR recommends those who depend on the creek as a water source, such as livestock producers, should monitor conditions for the next few days.

DNR staff helped stop the spill and plan to continue to monitor the clean-up and assess how many fish were killed, according to the release.


Separately Wednesday afternoon, the DNR responded to a spill of 10,000 gallons of manure into Kossuth County's Lotts Creek, which is about two miles northeast of West Bend.

► More:Agricultural runoff puts Iowa's Raccoon River on list of 10 most endangered nationally, group says

As Precision Pumping, a commercial manure application company, was applying manure in the area through an umbilical rig, a hose detached from its pump and "flopped" into the creek, spilling thousands of gallons of manure into the creek before the pump could be shut down, according to the DNR.

A large number of dead fish were discovered as a result of the Kossuth County spill, as well.

DNR officials said recovering the manure, which was flowing downstream, would be "impractical" due to the creek's high banks, wide channel and swift flow. About 10 miles downstream of the spill, Lotts Creek flows into the East Fork of the Des Moines River.

"While not insignificant, the spill is not expected to impact downstream water supplies," DNR officials wrote in the release, adding that the department's environmental specialists are testing water samples.

According to the release, the DNR is considering "appropriate enforcement action," but did not specify what those actions might entail.

Cindy Martens of the DNR, the media contact for the Lyon County spill, said that Rock Bottom Dairy will receive a violation with referral and penalty. The media contact for the Kossuth County incident could not immediately be reached for comment.

Manure spillage comes at the heel of new report warning Iowa of pollutants in Racoon River​

In an annual report published by American Rivers, an environmental advocacy nonprofit based in D.C., the group listed Iowa's Racoon River as among the top 10 most endangered rivers for the first time due to runoff from livestock facilities, such as manure, and farm fields.

“We’re sounding the alarm because pollution in the Raccoon River is putting drinking water supplies and public health at risk,” said Olivia Dorothy, American Rivers' Upper Mississippi River Basin director.

The Racoon River ranked ninth on American Rivers' list, which claimed that manure runoff "contributes to a clean-water crisis."

High nitrate levels remain an issue for water quality in Iowa, as well as other pollutants such as microcystins, which are toxins from blue-green algae blooms.

Community activists have spoken out against the amount of manure flowing into Iowa's water system, as well.

How a plan for the 3rd-tallest skyscraper in Iowa

 
Someone alert Chuck Grassley. We can let those little brown kids wade around in the manure slurry and help to clean up the mess. That way the little rascals aren't free loaders, they will be learning about exploitive labor practices in America.
 
To put the Kossuth County spill into prospective the guy hauling pig manure with a tank thru the field is probably using a 10,000 gallon tank.

My biggest concern would be say manure weighs 6 pounds a gallon. That guy is weighing 110,000+ going down the road loaded. A semi is regulated at 80,000 pounds.
 
Picture of the man last seen in the area.
BiffTannenBackToTheFuture1985.jpg
 
This one is more appealing...

https://northiowatoday.com/2021/04/14/dnr-traces-mason-city-spill-to-milk-shake-ingredient/

"Employees at Martin-Brower said they had hosed a spilled milk shake ingredient into a storm water intake Monday morning. After traveling underground through the storm water system, the pollutant surfaced into the tributary on the southwest side of town.

The affected area is a couple of hundred yards long, and lies alongside a popular walking and biking path."
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
To the original story...a $10,000 fine and a forced monitoring plan will be close to the penalty enforced.

Just imagine living in an area around these large operations and having to worry about well contamination.
 
To put the Kossuth County spill into prospective the guy hauling pig manure with a tank thru the field is probably using a 10,000 gallon tank.

My biggest concern would be say manure weighs 6 pounds a gallon. That guy is weighing 110,000+ going down the road loaded. A semi is regulated at 80,000 pounds.
WOB?
 
Oh. It's just manure. Manure's not that bad. I don't even mind the word 'manure.' You know, it's, it's 'nure,' which is good. And a 'ma' in front of it. MA-NURE. When you consider the other choices, 'manure' is actually pretty refreshing.

It’s either use manure or synthetic. Manure is cheaper and way better for the soil. I don’t want an anhydrous plant exploding near my town again.

 
To put the Kossuth County spill into prospective the guy hauling pig manure with a tank thru the field is probably using a 10,000 gallon tank.

My biggest concern would be say manure weighs 6 pounds a gallon. That guy is weighing 110,000+ going down the road loaded. A semi is regulated at 80,000 pounds.
A 9500 gallon manure hauler has 4 axels with oversized tires and is pulled by a tractor. Comparing it to a semi trailer is apples and oranges.

 
  • Love
Reactions: jamesvanderwulf
To put the Kossuth County spill into prospective the guy hauling pig manure with a tank thru the field is probably using a 10,000 gallon tank.

My biggest concern would be say manure weighs 6 pounds a gallon. That guy is weighing 110,000+ going down the road loaded. A semi is regulated at 80,000 pounds.

Commonly used tanks are more like 2000 to 6000 gallons I believe. And, many of them never hit the highway. They load up the waste and knife it in to their nearby fields.
 
Several hundred thousand gallons of manure spilled into a Lyon County creek Wednesday and, in a separate incident on the same day, another 10,000 gallons of manure also spilled into a Kossuth County creek that flows into the Des Moines River.

In Rock Rapids, Bernie Baker of Rock Bottom Dairy reported spilling "several hundred thousand gallons of manure" after "an irrigation unit became stuck," according to an Iowa Department of Natural Resources news release Wednesday evening.

The manure flowed through fields, which included cover crops or pasture, before it eventually flowed northwest of Rock Rapids and into Mud Creek, according to the DNR. When DNR staff arrived at the creek at about 3:20 p.m., "many dead fish," including bullheads, minnows and chubs, were found on the scene.



Due to the creek's slow flow rates, the manure-laden water is moving slowly downstream, according to the release, and the DNR recommends those who depend on the creek as a water source, such as livestock producers, should monitor conditions for the next few days.

DNR staff helped stop the spill and plan to continue to monitor the clean-up and assess how many fish were killed, according to the release.


Separately Wednesday afternoon, the DNR responded to a spill of 10,000 gallons of manure into Kossuth County's Lotts Creek, which is about two miles northeast of West Bend.

► More:Agricultural runoff puts Iowa's Raccoon River on list of 10 most endangered nationally, group says

As Precision Pumping, a commercial manure application company, was applying manure in the area through an umbilical rig, a hose detached from its pump and "flopped" into the creek, spilling thousands of gallons of manure into the creek before the pump could be shut down, according to the DNR.

A large number of dead fish were discovered as a result of the Kossuth County spill, as well.

DNR officials said recovering the manure, which was flowing downstream, would be "impractical" due to the creek's high banks, wide channel and swift flow. About 10 miles downstream of the spill, Lotts Creek flows into the East Fork of the Des Moines River.

"While not insignificant, the spill is not expected to impact downstream water supplies," DNR officials wrote in the release, adding that the department's environmental specialists are testing water samples.

According to the release, the DNR is considering "appropriate enforcement action," but did not specify what those actions might entail.

Cindy Martens of the DNR, the media contact for the Lyon County spill, said that Rock Bottom Dairy will receive a violation with referral and penalty. The media contact for the Kossuth County incident could not immediately be reached for comment.

Manure spillage comes at the heel of new report warning Iowa of pollutants in Racoon River​

In an annual report published by American Rivers, an environmental advocacy nonprofit based in D.C., the group listed Iowa's Racoon River as among the top 10 most endangered rivers for the first time due to runoff from livestock facilities, such as manure, and farm fields.

“We’re sounding the alarm because pollution in the Raccoon River is putting drinking water supplies and public health at risk,” said Olivia Dorothy, American Rivers' Upper Mississippi River Basin director.

The Racoon River ranked ninth on American Rivers' list, which claimed that manure runoff "contributes to a clean-water crisis."

High nitrate levels remain an issue for water quality in Iowa, as well as other pollutants such as microcystins, which are toxins from blue-green algae blooms.

Community activists have spoken out against the amount of manure flowing into Iowa's water system, as well.

How a plan for the 3rd-tallest skyscraper in Iowa

Awesome the Raccoon River is psyched
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
Commonly used tanks are more like 2000 to 6000 gallons I believe. And, many of them never hit the highway. They load up the waste and knife it in to their nearby fields.

Here in NW Iowa average is probably 6,000. I’ve seen plenty of haulers using 10,000 gallon tanks this spring.

They take the nearest possible route. If the field is next to the barn you haul thru a field. If you need to take 2 miles of gravel you do it. If the barn is on a paved road you use the paved road.
 
You wouldn’t eat fish out of okoboji?
Honestly I probably spoke to soon on that as I don't know the lay of the land. But with pesticide, insecticide and livestock fecal matter runoff, makes me think no. Most lakes are fed by streams, rivers or runoff, and it seems nearly impossible to escape water contamination.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
How was so much spilled before a pump could be shut off? And what kind of container holds that much liquid manure?
 
How was so much spilled before a pump could be shut off? And what kind of container holds that much liquid manure?

Yeah, I'm really not buying this story at all. This reads more like they got caught dumping a truck in the creek when it was too wet to apply and this was their cover story to the DNR.

1) you aren't even supposed to land apply near a creek. There are set backs.
2) it's a matter of hitting the kill switch on the pump, seconds, not minutes.
3) just happened to flop right into the creek huh? what are the chances of that...


"As Precision Pumping, a commercial manure application company, was applying manure in the area through an umbilical rig, a hose detached from its pump and "flopped" into the creek, spilling thousands of gallons of manure into the creek before the pump could be shut down, according to the DNR."
 
Last edited:
For the life of me I cannot figure out how we are so concerned about an influx of immigrants when some of the most entrenched Americans such as farmers with their generations of wealth accumulation, abuse of the public’s natural resources, and dependence on public support and infrastructure seem to be the some of the biggest, dirtiest and most disruptive assholes. If America’s population was a hand of 5 card draw, I would be asking for several new cards.
 
Honestly I probably spoke to soon on that as I don't know the lay of the land. But with pesticide, insecticide and livestock fecal matter runoff, makes me think no. Most lakes are fed by streams, rivers or runoff, and it seems nearly impossible to escape water contamination.

Gotcha. Okoboji is feed by springs. The DNR has bought up a significant portion of the watershed. Beautiful area.
 
Coincidently, yesterday "American Rivers" released its most polluted rivers in the USA and the Raccoon River, which provides water to DSM and approx. 500k customers in the area, was listed as the nation's #9 most polluted river.
So far "crickets" from the Iowa Legislature, who opposed a City of DSM Waterworks law suit vs. 3 counties that fed pollution into the Raccoon River, a couple of years ago. What, other than a lawsuit and a fine, will these farmers understand? They have an obligation to help keep Iowa's rivers and ground water potable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: torbee
Coincidently, yesterday "American Rivers" released its most polluted rivers in the USA and the Raccoon River, which provides water to DSM and approx. 500k customers in the area, was listed as the nation's #9 most polluted river.
So far "crickets" from the Iowa Legislature, who opposed a City of DSM Waterworks law suit vs. 3 counties that fed pollution into the Raccoon River, a couple of years ago. What, other than a lawsuit and a fine, will these farmers understand? They have an obligation to help keep Iowa's rivers and ground water potable.
Yeah, that was posted the other day: https://iowa.forums.rivals.com/thre...most-endangered-nationally-group-says.354734/
 
Not a big fan of

However, I'm sure his IQ dwarfs that of @MitchLL...
In my working years, I worked with ag producers in feed/seed for nearly 30 years. I know more than you think about how things work.

Don't try and bullshit me or attempt to publicly humiliate me. To top it off, I was born and raised on a farm.

Iowa is an ag State and as such, it caters to farmers. Then... we have politicians that cater to agriculture in promoting unnecessary subsidies. Farmers crying about estate taxes and the costs of production while driving a $75,000 F-250 and vacationing in AZ for three months. Oh, and they inherited their farm from grandpa.

But there is a sizeable percentage that work their asses off and are good citizens.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT