ADVERTISEMENT

Iowa City takes first look at $66 million apartment building near ped mall

cigaretteman

HB King
May 29, 2001
79,461
62,627
113
90e56d42-7631-45b3-9332-82e79d811f43-Tailwind_ped3.PNG

A diagram of how the apartment complex would look from Weather Dance Plaza. (Photo: Special to the Press-Citizen)

If the reaction of members of the Iowa City Council's Economic Development Committee is any indication, a proposal for a 9-story, 170-unit apartment building adjacent to the downtown pedestrian mall is on the right track.

"I don’t like this project; I love it," said Councilor Rockne Cole after a presentation before the committee Wednesday.

The proposal comes from developer The Tailwind Group of Mankato, Minnesota. They began the application for a $9 million tax increment financing deal to complete the $66 million project.

While no decisions were made, Wednesday was an opportunity for the developers and councilors to set expectations for the project.

"We are trying to get some daylight on the project so, they (City Council) can begin to think about the developer's proposal," said Wendy Ford, economic development coordinator for Iowa City.

For Councilors Cole and Susan Mims as well as Mayor Jim Throgmorton the project was a proof of concept that the standards council set for TIF while high were workable for area developers.

ADVERTISING
"I think we are getting a lot of public benefit for a great project even given the height," Mims said.

In order to qualify for TIF, the city will conduct a full gap analysis to determine whether $9 million is the necessary number to bring the project to fruition.

The project calls for redeveloping the south side of the 100 block of East College Street. The proposal involves the College Block building (Martini's at 125-127 E. College), the Crescent Building (Union Bar and Revival at 121 and 117 E. College St.) and Dooley Block (Graze, Field House Bar and the former Givanni's Restaurant at 115, 111, and 109 E. College St.).

084f7389-976d-418e-ad48-8577f3cece0d-Tailwind_ped1.PNG

A view of the College Block, Crescent Block and Dooley Block facades behind which the apartment building would be build. (Photo: Special to the Press-Citizen)

Tailwind's intention is to preserve the historic facades facing College Street. Behind those buildings, separated by a walkway, the developer would attach the 9-story apartment complex. The 170 units would include studios, one and two-bedroom apartments and a floor set aside for penthouse, totaling 186 beds with two additional floors of off-street parking.

Kyle Smith of Tailwind said that sizes would range from 350 to 880 square feet. Smith said these sizes would help them meet demand in parts of the market that weren't being supplied elsewhere.

The development proposes providing 54 spaces of parking which is less than the 80 spaces required by city regulations. In her memo to the committee, Ford noted that the parking requirement could be reduced by the Board of Adjustment or through a fee-in-lieu.

2b14be3e-56f3-483a-b2f5-8e815377b8a1-Tailwind_ped2.PNG

A diagram of the proposed new building south behind the pedestrian mall. (Photo: Special to the Press-Citizen)

The building is planned adjacent to the 9-story Graduate Hotel. But despite the apparent similarity, the nine stories are in excess of the four to six stories stipulated in the Downtown and Riverfront Crossing Master Plan's building heights section. However, developers argue there are "exceptional public benefits" to the project, including:

  • The developer agreed to work with the city to designate the Crescent Building and Dooley Block as a Local Historic Landmarks which would prevent future demolition. The College Block building is already a Local Historic Landmark. In addition, they will rehab using U.S. Secretary of the Interior standards, which use best-practice approaches to preserve cultural heritage.
  • The developer agreed to pursue LEED Platinum certification — exceeding the TIF Policy's LEED Silver standard.
  • They will open the third floor of the Crescent Building above Union Bar as programmable space for shopping, offices, sales counters and restrooms.
  • The developer plans to add a full restaurant in the Dooley Block building.



The large project would be Tailwind's second in town including its student housing project, The Quarters at Iowa City.

Thus far, Ford said the developer has been more than willing to work with the city to meet expectations.

"They want to work within the bounds created by the policies we have set forward," Ford said. "They are eager to get the proposed project in front of the public to get feedback."

https://www.press-citizen.com/story...-apartment-building-near-ped-mall/2140304001/
 
So, they are going to jam in a bunch of apartments behind those existing buildings and eliminate the alley?
 
I remember when Iowa City had a nice homey feel to it.....memories...like the corner of my mind....
 
So the Mill would toast, as would the parking. There are a bunch of dumpsters behind those bars, where do those go? How about delivery of product?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThorneStockton
So the Mill would toast, as would the parking. There are a bunch of dumpsters behind those bars, where do those go? How about delivery of product?
I can't really tell? It seems that by saying they are preserving the facades of the original buildings they are saying they are chopping them up? The bottom of the diagram shows the present alleyway, right? That strip of garden down the middle will be a joke if I am now looking at it correctly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
I remember when Iowa City had a nice homey feel to it.....memories...like the corner of my mind....
Hell,
I can't really tell? It seems that by saying they are preserving the facades of the original buildings they are saying they are chopping them up? The bottom of the diagram shows the present alleyway, right? That strip of garden down the middle will be a joke if I am now looking at it correctly.
Yeah, it sounds like the existing bars and businesses are gone, with the facade and likely a business on the main floor. Kind of like what happened when the cottage bakery got bought out for the high rise and they gave them the retail space on the inside and a wad of cash.
 
$388,235 per unit. Wow.

But what will these units rent for and how long is the useful life? I admittedly have no clue what that location can command in terms of monthly rent, and maybe something like $2000 per month still doesn't get you great returns... maybe that's also a completely wrong assumption on rent.
 
No, the alley stays. It's all north of the alley. There is underground parking that enters off the alley in the corner apartments where the Hawkeye State bank used to be, can't eliminate that. The old buildings stay with a walkway ( garden ) between the old and new, as does the Mill and the lot ( for now ).
 
No, the alley stays. It's all north of the alley. There is underground parking that enters off the alley in the corner apartments where the Hawkeye State bank used to be, can't eliminate that. The old buildings stay with a walkway ( garden ) between the old and new, as does the Mill and the lot ( for now ).

So they'll be cutting the backs off of those building to the north and just keeping the facades?
 
I don't get how this works? Are they tearing down The Mill? Or are they tearing down the Union, Martinis, and the buildings next to it? Or are they trying to squeeze it in in between everything?
 
But what will these units rent for and how long is the useful life? I admittedly have no clue what that location can command in terms of monthly rent, and maybe something like $2000 per month still doesn't get you great returns... maybe that's also a completely wrong assumption on rent.
170 units and 186 beds including a Penthouse. So, primarily one bedroom units. Likely the Penthouse will have three. Do the math. $2000 a month in IC for a one bedroom? Rent for the retail space will be expensive. Parking spots will be expensive.
 
So, does The Mill stay?
Is is taking that little corner parking lot by Starbucks, west of The Mill and running across the front of Burlington?
 
So they'll be cutting the backs off of those building to the north and just keeping the facades?
That's not the way I read it.
The developer agreed to work with the city to designate the Crescent Building and Dooley Block as a Local Historic Landmarks which would prevent future demolition.
  • They will open the third floor of the Crescent Building above Union Bar as programmable space for shopping, offices, sales counters and restrooms.
 
I can't figure out how that would fit in that space.

In general, I am not opposed to that type of development and the proximity to campus makes it potentially very useful to those that want to live close to campus. BUT...I don't like seeing the tax breaks and/or relaxing the parking requirements.

The rules should be applied to all property owners evenly IMO.
 
I'm told they are tearing down the strip of buildings that house places like Union, Martini's, Graze etc. Fronts (Facade) would remain to give it the same feel, but apartments would be the contents with some businesses on street level facing Ped Mall.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
Wow, if that's the case, I'm surprised the Council would be in favor of demolishing what seem to be historic downtown buildings.

...but, they are not in great shape inside...
 
I'm told they are tearing down the strip of buildings that house places like Union, Martini's, Graze etc. Fronts (Facade) would remain to give it the same feel, but apartments would be the contents with some businesses on street level facing Ped Mall.
Don't think so. Again look at the blueprint showing a walkway ( garden space ) between the old buildings and the proposed. The old buildings are already on the Local Historic List. They can't tear them down I don't think.
 
  • Like
Reactions: torbee
I'm told they are tearing down the strip of buildings that house places like Union, Martini's, Graze etc. Fronts (Facade) would remain to give it the same feel, but apartments would be the contents with some businesses on street level facing Ped Mall.
Oh man! Haven't stepped into the Union in over 20 years but damn do I have some fun memories there in the 90s... RIP in peace Union
200.gif
 
Yeah, there's no way to fit that in north of the existing alley with those buildings still extending that far south. They have to be tearing the backs off of those buildings.
Based on the drawing it looks to me like they are bisecting the rectangle equidistant from college street and the alley. So bye bye Joseph's, opera house, but it looks like Union, and others are either staying, or being rebuilt.
 
Yeah, there's no way to fit that in north of the existing alley with those buildings still extending that far south. They have to be tearing the backs off of those buildings.
From the artists rendering it looks like the buildings will only be 2-3 stories tall and fit the current facades on the mall.
 
Based on the drawing it looks to me like they are bisecting the rectangle equidistant from college street and the alley. So bye bye Joseph's, opera house, but it looks like Union, and others are either staying, or being rebuilt.
Not touching anything on Clinton St. From the Arial view you can clearly see where the footprint will be. The back half of the existing buildings will be redeveloped up to the alley.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
Who the F will pay 2000 a month for a 1 bedroom in downtown IC? Its not San Fran. If the developer is getting TIF, its outrageous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UNIHAWK88
But what will these units rent for and how long is the useful life? I admittedly have no clue what that location can command in terms of monthly rent, and maybe something like $2000 per month still doesn't get you great returns... maybe that's also a completely wrong assumption on rent.

I am not familiar with the market either, but they would have to be getting $2.50+ PSF (on the extremely low side) rents to justify that cost. It works better at $3.00/SF which is insane for anywhere not named NYC, SF, Miami, LA, Chicago, DC, Denver.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT