Judge rules lawsuit may continue over Supreme Beef feedlot near Bloody Run Creek

cigaretteman

HR King
May 29, 2001
70,617
50,135
113
A Polk County judge has ruled environmental groups may continue with a lawsuit against the Iowa Department of Natural Resources over the approval of an 11,600-head cattle feedlot in the watershed of a popular trout stream in northeast Iowa.


District Court Judge Michael Huppert on Monday denied the state’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit the Sierra Club of Iowa filed in September against the DNR and Supreme Beef, the operator of the feedlot near Monona.


“Sierra Club has asserted sufficient facts for both legal standing and injury in fact,” Huppert wrote.


Advertisment

The lawsuit says the DNR’s approval of Supreme Beef’s nutrient management plan last spring was based on faulty data provided by the company and that the facility will produce far more manure than is claimed.


The feedlot is in karst terrain, which has porous soil that allows contaminants to rapidly flow to groundwater or nearby creeks and lakes. Any manure spills or overapplication of manure to nearby farm fields may endanger Bloody Run Creek, a trout stream considered an “Outstanding Iowa Water,” the suit states.


Sierra Club is asking the DNR to reverse its decision on the feedlot.


“It is clear the DNR is trying every procedural trick to avoid a hearing on the merits of this case,” Sierra Club attorney Wally Taylor said in a prepared statement. “But that is not working. DNR will have to explain why it violated its own rules in approving the nutrient management plan for Supreme Beef.”


Huppert also ruled Trout Unlimited may intervene in support of the Sierra Club in the lawsuit. The state had tried to bar the group’s involvement.


The Iowa Chapter of Trout Unlimited has purchased land to expand the Bloody Run Wildlife Management Area to provide more access to the trout stream. The group fears excess nitrogen and phosphorus from manure will damage naturally-reproducing brown trout as well as stocked brook and rainbow trout in Bloody Run.
The DNR and Supreme Beef have 10 days to file an answer to Huppert’s rulings.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Moral

Moral

HR Legend
Sep 29, 2017
24,182
74,213
113
It would be a travesty to allow this feed lot anywhere near Bloody Run. Really says a lot about Iowa that thier own DNR is trying to force something like this through.