This makes her a no-go from my perspective. Need someone in shape and ready to play, and this scenario does not match that criteria. Add to it the time it takes to learn the R&R offense (playing as a team) and you just risk a lot of wasted time getting everyone playing together.
The one big advantage they will bring into next season, is an experienced team that has played together now. No summer filled with injury rehabs without levelling up. They need months together playing team ball.
That doesn't mean no transfers; it does mean those transfers need to be in Iowa City this summer.
*Will be difficult enough getting Deal up to speed.
*Primary need: points and experienced ball handling.
Nothing you've said I haven't thought about. That's fine if you don't think she is capable of handling it and/or the coaches shouldn't even entertain it. Which may or may not be true. I just need more answers before I can go down that road.
She does come with some bug-a-boos and hence why I stated she could possibly come at a discount because of them.
Now you have some assumptions that I have no way to currently verify. Those are:
1) As far as I know, she could be running mountains and can come into camp/training/practice in better shape than anyone else on the roster.
2) According to a recent article, we tried to sign her before she went to BYU. I have no idea what offenses she's been exposed to or not. She may have R&R in her past. Maybe she also has an exceptional IQ to boot and why we were trying to sign her.
If the above is true, then it can be debated on how much risk to take on her because her biggest problem is how fast does she arrive at training to play with others. That is not for me to decide. That's for the coaches to decide how valuable she was back then when we recruited her and what her potential today is based on factors we might not know nothing about.
If she isn't staying in shape and has no prior exposure to the R&R, then she probably has ZERO chance of coming on board and I would totally agree with that. Since we don't know, we can't automatically assume what she is doing and how much she knows.
Think this affords us a chance to pick a cheaper backup as an extra scorer that has the possibility to start. Since we don't know who will all end up in the portal yet. If I had to pick a player or player type in the portal now, that would be Kailey Woolston of BYU. She can play multiple spots #2 - #4 and she is a scorer at 3 levels. This would allow for a possible starter and/or backup in the other 2 to 3 positions. Since we have 2 roster spots open, we could buy some insurance at the #2 - #4 spots with her or a player like her.
Thus, it's why I stated, "Since we don't know who will all end up in the portal yet. If I had to pick a player or player type in the portal now, that would be Kailey Woolston of BYU. She can play multiple spots #2 - #4 and she is a scorer at 3 levels. This would allow for a possible starter and/or backup in the other 2 to 3 positions. Since we have 2 roster spots open, we could buy some insurance at the #2 - #4 spots with her or a player like her."
I used Kailey Woolston as an example player type who was in the portal now just in case she can't meet the coaches criteria of already being in shape, having some exposure to R&R in her background and can be in practice by a certain date. I also used her as an example because she is a scorer and can play multiple spots. She was used as an example player type to get if she doesn't meet the requirements of the coaches. I'm not going to assume I know all the answers of why the coaches wanted her in the first place before she went to BYU.
We had at least 3 players doing various types of injury rehabs coming into this season during summer and fall. So you're going to say one player is now going to disrupt the team? This does happen to teams and it's nothing new to work a new player into a team over time. My point is if Woolston is staying in shape and knows R&R that she could be a backup/bench at first until she got more time with the team. If the coaches feel she has a high IQ with R&R, then she might it pick up it quickly to become a backup and over time eventually start if it pans out that way. The player needs to be optimal for the end of season, BTT and the big dance, not necessarily for the first month, Again, the coaches know this about her and I'm not going to assume she is automatically out for things I know nothing about.
Again, you're making assumptions about Deal. Deal has played on multiple circuits throughout her high school career with several coaches. She has had a minimum of 3 high school coaches alone. Depending on her additional AAU/EYBL teams she may have had several more coaches to the list. There might be a good chance she has had some R&R taught to her already. She has exceptional IQ from listening to Jan.
For some people, the R&R isn't that hard to pickup if you understand the basic dynamic concepts of what your team is working towards. For others, it can be a nightmare for those who just understand set linear plays step-by-step. Again, I have no idea what Woolston and Deal have been exposed to or not with R&R. I'm also just not assuming that it's terribly hard for them to pick it up either.
I have no problem with you not liking the circumstances revolving around Kailey Woolston's mission. On the surface, it does appear she is a non-starter. I get that. However, just not willing to go that far to totally dismiss her without knowing more facts. Figure we recruited her for a reason and the coaches need to dig into her situation to see if there is a way that it could work out first. If not, then go find a who's got next player type like her in the portal. Eventually there may be someone better than Woolston in the portal and no need to get involved with her if it's more of a risk than a benefit.
The other insurance spot is a PG. Don't have anyone that I can think of in the portal yet. This PG needs ball handing and passer skills first and be a scorer as a bonus or at least to be a threat to score keeping a defense honest. Again, if the price is right, then adding another piece to make you sleep easier at night to break presses should be looked at as a depth upgrade.
Lastly my post was about getting the remaining primary pieces with scoring points and experienced ball handling with passer skills to break presses. Think we're talking the same thing here about skills most needed now if we can get them and hopefully at a reasonable NIL price.