ADVERTISEMENT

Lesson on Islam Shuts Down Virginia School District

cigaretteman

HB King
May 29, 2001
79,435
62,542
113
Islamophobia is alive and well in Virginia, apparently:

A Virginia school district closed its schools on Friday amid an angry backlash from parents over an assignment that asked high school students to copy Arabic calligraphy as part of a lesson on world religions.

Students in a geography class at Riverheads High School in Staunton, Va., had been asked to try their hands at copying a passage known as the shehada, or declaration of faith in Islam, which translates to, “There is no God but God, and Muhammad is the messenger of God.”

The work sheet distributed to students said the assignment was meant to show them the “artistic complexity of calligraphy,” according to images of the page broadcast on local TV stations. But some parents accused the teacher of trying to convert their children to Islam, inciting an angry outcry in the largely rural district nestled in the Shenandoah Valley.

The complaints were further fueled by reports in some local media outlets that female students had been asked to try on a hijab, or Islamic head scarf, and pose for pictures as part of the classroom lesson.

The Augusta County School District did not directly address the content of the lesson in a statement posted online on Thursday night, but said it would close all of its schools on Friday and cancel extracurricular activities through the weekend after “receiving voluminous phone calls and electronic mail locally and from outside the area” over the assignment.

Speaking to CBS, Randall Fisher, the Augusta County Sheriff, described the messages sent to the school district in response to the assignment as “profane” and “hateful.”

The district said that the number of phone calls and emails “significantly increased in volume” on Thursday as media coverage of the controversy increased. After consulting with Sheriff Fisher, the school board decided to cancel class across the entire district “based on concerns regarding the tone and content of those communications,” it said.

The outcry in Augusta County comes against the backdrop of a steady drumbeat of anti-Muslim rhetoric by politicians and a nationwide wave of hate crimes targeting Muslims, including physical assaults and acts of vandalism and arson at mosques and Muslim-owned businesses, in the wake of the terrorist attacks in Paris and San Bernardino, Calif.

The school district said on Thursday that the deluge of messages it received contained “no specific threat of harm to students, schools and school offices.” It said it decided to cancel class and extracurricular activities out of an abundance of caution.

As part of those precautionary measures, the sheriff’s office said on Thursday that it would increase the number of patrols near school facilities in response to the messages.

Eric Bond, the superintendent of Augusta County School District, Max W. Lowe, the principal of Riverheads High School, and Cheryl LaPorte, identified in local media as the teacher who assigned the calligraphy exercise, did not respond to requests for comment on Thursday.

Despite the outcry, the district said it would continue to educate students about the world’s religious diversity as required by state education guidelines but that “a different, nonreligious sample of Arabic calligraphy will be used in the future.”

“As we have emphasized, no lesson was designed to promote a religious viewpoint or change any student’s religious belief,” it said.

Some parents do not believe that to be true, however. Kimberly Herndon, a parent who has been an outspoken critic of the geography assignment, claimed on Facebook that the students “were instructed to denounce our Lord by copying this creed of Islam.”

“This evil has been cloaked in the form of multiculturalism,” she wrote, adding in a separate post that the students had been asked to write words that were “an abomination to their faith.”

“This creed is connected to jihad in that it is the chant that is shouted while beheading those of Christian faith,” Ms. Herndon wrote.

Laurel Truxell, a student in the class, told an NBC affiliate in Charlottesville, Va., that in addition to the calligraphy exercise students were also asked to try on a hijab, or Islamic head scarf, and pose for pictures.

She refused to put on the hijab at first but “the teacher pushed and pushed and pushed so I did it,” she said. Her parents called the school to object after Laurel was told a picture of her wearing the head scarf would be submitted to the yearbook, she said.

“I just felt uncomfortable learning about it in a world geography class,” she told the television network. “You shouldn’t teach religion in school unless you’re in a religious class.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/19/u...istrict.html&eventName=Watching-article-click
 
Stupid question...what does Arabic calligraphy have to do with Geography?

A Virginia school district closed its schools on Friday amid an angry backlash from parents over an assignment that asked high school students to copy Arabic calligraphy as part of a lesson on world religions.

Despite the outcry, the district said it would continue to educate students about the world’s religious diversity as required by state education guidelines but that “a different, nonreligious sample of Arabic calligraphy will be used in the future.”

“As we have emphasized, no lesson was designed to promote a religious viewpoint or change any student’s religious belief,” it said.
 
A Virginia school district closed its schools on Friday amid an angry backlash from parents over an assignment that asked high school students to copy Arabic calligraphy as part of a lesson on world religions.

Despite the outcry, the district said it would continue to educate students about the world’s religious diversity as required by state education guidelines but that “a different, nonreligious sample of Arabic calligraphy will be used in the future.”

“As we have emphasized, no lesson was designed to promote a religious viewpoint or change any student’s religious belief,” it said.
Okay, didn't read it was about world religions...guess that makes sense. Thought it was geography...
 
This article got it wrong. What the students were instructed to write was,"There is no god but Allah, and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah."

I wonder why parents would be upset with that (sarcasm).
 
The school district said there was no threat, why was school shut down?


Ciggy's word of the month: Islamophobia
 
So much Republican hate in this country.

Islamophobia is alive and well in Virginia, apparently:

A Virginia school district closed its schools on Friday amid an angry backlash from parents over an assignment that asked high school students to copy Arabic calligraphy as part of a lesson on world religions.

Students in a geography class at Riverheads High School in Staunton, Va., had been asked to try their hands at copying a passage known as the shehada, or declaration of faith in Islam, which translates to, “There is no God but God, and Muhammad is the messenger of God.”

The work sheet distributed to students said the assignment was meant to show them the “artistic complexity of calligraphy,” according to images of the page broadcast on local TV stations. But some parents accused the teacher of trying to convert their children to Islam, inciting an angry outcry in the largely rural district nestled in the Shenandoah Valley.

The complaints were further fueled by reports in some local media outlets that female students had been asked to try on a hijab, or Islamic head scarf, and pose for pictures as part of the classroom lesson.

The Augusta County School District did not directly address the content of the lesson in a statement posted online on Thursday night, but said it would close all of its schools on Friday and cancel extracurricular activities through the weekend after “receiving voluminous phone calls and electronic mail locally and from outside the area” over the assignment.

Speaking to CBS, Randall Fisher, the Augusta County Sheriff, described the messages sent to the school district in response to the assignment as “profane” and “hateful.”

The district said that the number of phone calls and emails “significantly increased in volume” on Thursday as media coverage of the controversy increased. After consulting with Sheriff Fisher, the school board decided to cancel class across the entire district “based on concerns regarding the tone and content of those communications,” it said.

The outcry in Augusta County comes against the backdrop of a steady drumbeat of anti-Muslim rhetoric by politicians and a nationwide wave of hate crimes targeting Muslims, including physical assaults and acts of vandalism and arson at mosques and Muslim-owned businesses, in the wake of the terrorist attacks in Paris and San Bernardino, Calif.

The school district said on Thursday that the deluge of messages it received contained “no specific threat of harm to students, schools and school offices.” It said it decided to cancel class and extracurricular activities out of an abundance of caution.

As part of those precautionary measures, the sheriff’s office said on Thursday that it would increase the number of patrols near school facilities in response to the messages.

Eric Bond, the superintendent of Augusta County School District, Max W. Lowe, the principal of Riverheads High School, and Cheryl LaPorte, identified in local media as the teacher who assigned the calligraphy exercise, did not respond to requests for comment on Thursday.

Despite the outcry, the district said it would continue to educate students about the world’s religious diversity as required by state education guidelines but that “a different, nonreligious sample of Arabic calligraphy will be used in the future.”

“As we have emphasized, no lesson was designed to promote a religious viewpoint or change any student’s religious belief,” it said.

Some parents do not believe that to be true, however. Kimberly Herndon, a parent who has been an outspoken critic of the geography assignment, claimed on Facebook that the students “were instructed to denounce our Lord by copying this creed of Islam.”

“This evil has been cloaked in the form of multiculturalism,” she wrote, adding in a separate post that the students had been asked to write words that were “an abomination to their faith.”

“This creed is connected to jihad in that it is the chant that is shouted while beheading those of Christian faith,” Ms. Herndon wrote.

Laurel Truxell, a student in the class, told an NBC affiliate in Charlottesville, Va., that in addition to the calligraphy exercise students were also asked to try on a hijab, or Islamic head scarf, and pose for pictures.

She refused to put on the hijab at first but “the teacher pushed and pushed and pushed so I did it,” she said. Her parents called the school to object after Laurel was told a picture of her wearing the head scarf would be submitted to the yearbook, she said.

“I just felt uncomfortable learning about it in a world geography class,” she told the television network. “You shouldn’t teach religion in school unless you’re in a religious class.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/19/us/lesson-on-islam-shuts-down-virginia-school-district.html?module=WatchingPortal&region=c-column-middle-span-region&pgType=Homepage&action=click&mediaId=wide&state=standard&contentPlacement=1&version=internal&contentCollection=www.nytimes.com&contentId=http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/19/us/lesson-on-islam-shuts-down-virginia-school-district.html&eventName=Watching-article-click
 
This was pretty predictable. How this teacher didn't think there would be opposition to this is surprising.

No mater which side of the argument you are on from the far left with JScott or with the parents thinking this was some plot to get their kids to change religions this is a sad commentary on our country.
 
It's difficult to imagine any public school teacher being dumb enough to assign such a loaded passage for every kid to copy. I'm thinking he asked somebody who knew arabic for a calligraphy sample and this "buddy" trolled him. I'm not sure the parents overreacted but shutting down schools might be a bit much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mattski
It's difficult to imagine any public school teacher being dumb enough to assign such a loaded passage for every kid to copy. I'm thinking he asked somebody who knew arabic for a calligraphy sample and this "buddy" trolled him. I'm not sure the parents overreacted but shutting down schools might be a bit much.
Your first thought I agree with.

The lesson was pulled from a workbook on world religions.
 
I'll echo what I said in the thread about people flying off the handle over guys who look like they are from the ME looking for a dam. Gee, maybe they want to go fishing in the lake behind the dam.
This country is sitting on a tinderbox, and stupid people are trying to ignite it for partisan gain. I briefly studied Islam and ME cultures decades ago in school. It's important to understand other cultures. If a kid sitting in China, India, or Saudi Arabia is in a class that is studying other cultures does a work sheet on the US, and Christianity what passages from the Bible do you think they'd copy? What conversation might they have, or maybe they all try on a replica of the Pope's hat. Maybe they put on yarmulke if they are discussing Judaism.
So much stupid in this country, and so much surrendering to fear.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
If a kid sitting in China, India, or Saudi Arabia is in a class that is studying other cultures does a work sheet on the US, and Christianity what passages from the Bible do you think they'd copy? What conversation might they have, or maybe they all try on a replica of the Pope's hat. Maybe they put on yarmulke if they are discussing Judaism.
So much stupid in this country, and so much surrendering to fear.

Dude! They don't allow that in China and Saudi Arabia!
 
Probably should have went with a phrase like "Hello my name is _____." Either way, these parents are absolutely crazy, I'm not a parent but I think my thoughts would go something like this.

Me: "What are you doing?"
Kid: "Trying to replicate this Arabic phrase"
Me: "Neat, that looks pretty difficult, what's it mean?"
Kid: “There is no God but God, and Muhammad is the messenger of God.”
Me: "hmm, interesting"
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
I'll echo what I said in the thread about people flying off the handle over guys who look like they are from the ME looking for a dam. Gee, maybe they want to go fishing in the lake behind the dam.
This country is sitting on a tinderbox, and stupid people are trying to ignite it for partisan gain. I briefly studied Islam and ME cultures decades ago in school. It's important to understand other cultures. If a kid sitting in China, India, or Saudi Arabia is in a class that is studying other cultures does a work sheet on the US, and Christianity what passages from the Bible do you think they'd copy? What conversation might they have, or maybe they all try on a replica of the Pope's hat. Maybe they put on yarmulke if they are discussing Judaism.
So much stupid in this country, and so much surrendering to fear.

Only when you count the Christians, Muslims, Jews. That's what is so funny about religions fighting. The paranoia grows and spins out of control until they all hate each other enough to start a war. Religion and most people are dumb.
 
I can't wait for the culture wars to fully take hold. We are getting bits and pieces now but eventually these sparks are going to turn into a full on inferno.
 
  • Like
Reactions: THE_DEVIL
Probably should have went with a phrase like "Hello my name is _____." Either way, these parents are absolutely crazy, I'm not a parent but I think my thoughts would go something like this.

Me: "What are you doing?"
Kid: "Trying to replicate this Arabic phrase"
Me: "Neat, that looks pretty difficult, what's it mean?"
Kid: “There is no God but God, and Muhammad is the messenger of God.”
Me: "hmm, interesting"

That wasn't the phrase. It was, there is no God but Allah and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah." Which is peculiar.
 
That wasn't the phrase. It was, there is no God but Allah and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah." Which is peculiar.

I thought I copied it straight from the original post, but it doesn't change my reaction which is essentially what you pointed out: peculiar but interesting.
 
I teach human geography... the parents/kids wondering why they are learning about religions are idiots. The teacher who chose this particular piece of calligraphy made a poor decision, and will hopefully learn from their mistakes. Thankfully I've never received a call from an irate parent when teaching about religions, but I am always extra careful not to step on toes or do anything that might give the impression I'm advocating for one religion or another.
 
I thought I copied it straight from the original post, but it doesn't change my reaction which is essentially what you pointed out: peculiar but interesting.
The article in the original post had it wrong. I am not much of a religious person but I have a problem with the use of this phrase in a school setting for multiple reasons.
 
I teach human geography... the parents/kids wondering why they are learning about religions are idiots. The teacher who chose this particular piece of calligraphy made a poor decision, and will hopefully learn from their mistakes. Thankfully I've never received a call from an irate parent when teaching about religions, but I am always extra careful not to step on toes or do anything that might give the impression I'm advocating for one religion or another.

It is an incredibly poor decision and shows incredible stupidity. The level of stupidity that begs the question 'does this person have the judgement to be teaching children?'.
 
It is an incredibly poor decision and shows incredible stupidity. The level of stupidity that begs the question 'does this person have the judgement to be teach children?'.
I agree. Keep all religion out of school unless it's being taught in an academic sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: unIowa
It is an incredibly poor decision and shows incredible stupidity. The level of stupidity that begs the question 'does this person have the judgement to be teaching children?'.

My guess is it wasn't so much stupidity as laziness. The teacher probably just grabbed the activity out of some workbook. But having students copy that phrase is just as irresponsible as having students reciting the Hail Mary would be. Even more so if it was a graded activity.
 
How is Mohammad the equivalent of Superman?

- no laser beam eyes
- can't fly
- not super strong
- not fast

Did he have good hair?

Right. Mohammad might be more like Lex and the Muslim interpretation of God (or old testament Christianity) would be Zod.
 
Doesn't it seem just a little odd to ask kids to draw a language before you teach them the language? That's not how real arabic calligraphy makers do it, so the lesson is sort of bogus from the start. It reminds me of all the people who get chinese characters tattooed on themselves.
 
Doesn't it seem just a little odd to ask kids to draw a language before you teach them the language? That's not how real arabic calligraphy makers do it, so the lesson is sort of bogus from the start. It reminds me of all the people who get chinese characters tattooed on themselves.

Depends on the purpose of the lesson.
 
It is an incredibly poor decision and shows incredible stupidity. The level of stupidity that begs the question 'does this person have the judgement to be teaching children?'.

Seriously? I mean, how overdramatic can you possibly be?
 
It's difficult to imagine any public school teacher being dumb enough to assign such a loaded passage for every kid to copy. I'm thinking he asked somebody who knew arabic for a calligraphy sample and this "buddy" trolled him. I'm not sure the parents overreacted but shutting down schools might be a bit m

Years ago in HS Latin class we learned the Latin form of the Catholic "Hail Mary, full of grace, etc." which are the words to the Ave Maria song. But we didn't learn it as a song, just the words. The teacher wasn't Catholic, I guess she just wanted us to learn some Latin that was still used. No protestant parents protested as far as I knew.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
This article got it wrong. What the students were instructed to write was,"There is no god but Allah, and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah."

I wonder why parents would be upset with that (sarcasm).

This is hilarious.
 
Seriously? I mean, how overdramatic can you possibly be?

How is pointing out incompetence being overdramatic? Let me guess, you are one of the regressive left. If so, Congrats on losing all of your convictions.
 
I'm glad so many parents have given up on their quest to demand prayer be put back in schools. Maybe that is one good thing that will come out of all this, the realization that if your religion gets in so does everyone else's.

"god" i hope that is the case BUT it won't be.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT