ADVERTISEMENT

NIL means it’s not your daddy’s college game.

billanole

HR Legend
Mar 5, 2005
16,163
19,173
113
I knew, back in the day, that when Bobby Bowden signed the first $1 million contract, things were headed for a change. Some change is good, some regulation is good. It is currently wide open, best I can tell.



Despite being marinated in cash, however, college football is still technically an amateur sport.

The players on whose backs the multi-billion-dollar industry operates are not financially compensated by the universities for which they play.

They receive scholarships to cover tuition, housing and food, as well as monthly stipends for expenses. Some scholarships are not guaranteed, however, and they all can be revoked for non-athletic reasons. And while healthcare is provided for those enrolled in school, it does not continue after collegiate careers end - even if the injuries sustained on the field linger.

College athletes who violated rules were subject to severe punishment.

In 2010, for instance, five Ohio State football players - including the star quarterback - were suspended and had their names erased from the college record books for trading sport memorabilia for free tattoos at a local Ohio parlour.

It is an imbalance that has struck many college football observers as inherently unfair.

Consider the following reasoning:

"Nowhere else in America can businesses get away with agreeing not to pay their workers a fair market rate on the theory that their product is defined by not paying their workers a fair market rate.

"Enormous sums of money flow to seemingly everyone except the student athletes. College presidents, athletic directors, coaches, conference commissioners, and NCAA executives take in six- and seven-figure salaries. Colleges build lavish new facilities. But the student athletes who generate the revenues, many of whom are African American and from lower-income backgrounds, end up with little or nothing."

Those words were written by Justice Brett Kavanaugh in an opinion concurring with a landmark 2021 Supreme Court decision striking down limits on compensation for student athletes.
 
NIL and an open transfer portal has changed college sports forever. The days of “parity” have ever been abolished. Amateur athletics have historically been at loggerheads with capitalism...and if you open your eyes and honestly observe what is happening, you know what I am saying. Giving immature kids access to millions of dollars is never a good solution. When your 20 years old, you think that’s nuts....when your 45 you know I am correct.
Money is not the cure to all evils. Pay attention.
 
NIL and an open transfer portal has changed college sports forever. The days of “parity” have ever been abolished. Amateur athletics have historically been at loggerheads with capitalism...and if you open your eyes and honestly observe what is happening, you know what I am saying. Giving immature kids access to millions of dollars is never a good solution. When your 20 years old, you think that’s nuts....when your 45 you know I am correct.
Money is not the cure to all evils. Pay attention.
Parity has not existed in college sports for a very long time old man. Wake up lol.
 
The illusion of parity is over. There never was parity… only those who used money to get ahead and those who didn’t. The results on the field vastly favored those who had money. Always have and always will.
 
NIL and an open transfer portal has changed college sports forever. The days of “parity” have ever been abolished. Amateur athletics have historically been at loggerheads with capitalism...and if you open your eyes and honestly observe what is happening, you know what I am saying. Giving immature kids access to millions of dollars is never a good solution. When your 20 years old, you think that’s nuts....when your 45 you know I am correct.
Money is not the cure to all evils. Pay attention.
Good lord. There was a reason the big dogs hated NIL, now everyone can pay players. And the portal has made it so the tier one teams backups can transfer out and get opportunities to start elsewhere.
 
Over time it’s going to make college football a less interesting product because all the money and talent will be consolidated in about a dozen programs. It’ll be just like the NFL but worse because there’s no salary cap and no draft so the biggest programs will be the only ones that stay relevant.

The system needs an overhaul with regulation but not expecting it any time soon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkdave007
Good lord. There was a reason the big dogs hated NIL, now everyone can pay players. And the portal has made it so the tier one teams backups can transfer out and get opportunities to start elsewhere.
At what price?
What exactly is the purpose of COLLEGE athletics? If you want professional sports , let the sports leagues pay for them….why have colleges beat the expense and sell their souls?
Maybe the NFL needs to pay for their developmental league just like baseball and basketball?
 
Over time it’s going to make college football a less interesting product because all the money and talent will be consolidated in about a dozen programs. It’ll be just like the NFL but worse because there’s no salary cap and no draft so the biggest programs will be the only ones that stay relevant.

The system needs an overhaul with regulation but not expecting it any time soon.
Maybe, seeing what one coach has done to a program in Boulder that was in hibernation for 20 years might provide some hope
 
  • Like
Reactions: InsaneHawkJJP
At what price?
What exactly is the purpose of COLLEGE athletics? If you want professional sports , let the sports leagues pay for them….why have colleges beat the expense and sell their souls?
Maybe the NFL needs to pay for their developmental league just like baseball and basketball?
The Athletic had an interesting article yesterday about how they see football breaking off to create a super league featuring the top 28 programs. The league would consist of mostly B1G and SEC schools with ND, Clemson, FSU, Okie St included. All remaining teams and all other sports would compete in more traditional regional type conferences/division. The thought was you could see this transition between 2032-34.
 
The Athletic had an interesting article yesterday about how they see football breaking off to create a super league featuring the top 28 programs. The league would consist of mostly B1G and SEC schools with ND, Clemson, FSU, Okie St included. All remaining teams and all other sports would compete in more traditional regional type conferences/division. The thought was you could see this transition between 2032-34.

Why wait?

We gonna pretend school matters for another 10 years? Pay them, make them employees working for subsidiary corporations.
 
At what price?
What exactly is the purpose of COLLEGE athletics? If you want professional sports , let the sports leagues pay for them….why have colleges beat the expense and sell their souls?
Maybe the NFL needs to pay for their developmental league just like baseball and basketball?
So when players risked injuries, long term health issues, and in some cases worse for a scholarship while the universities and NCAA made billions of them it was all good? But now that players can earn some cash off the talents they provide all hell is breaking loose? You aren't particularly bright, but we all already knew that.
 
So when players risked injuries, long term health issues, and in some cases worse for a scholarship while the universities and NCAA made billions of them it was all good? But now that players can earn some cash off the talents they provide all hell is breaking loose? You aren't particularly bright, but we all already knew that.
your first sentence can apply to construction workers, coal miners, oil drillers or any job in a dangerous field.

The "purpose" of NIL was so that players can earn money by others using their name, image and likeness. Nothing to do with their talent...everyone knew that was farce from the beginning and that we'd end up right where we are today. Paying 7 figures to a high school kid who hasn't proven anything in the arena. But you know what? the schools aren't paying that, so they'll continue to make their millions of revenue...but no one ever looks at what the other side of the balance sheet those revenues pay for.
 
your first sentence can apply to construction workers, coal miners, oil drillers or any job in a dangerous field.

The "purpose" of NIL was so that players can earn money by others using their name, image and likeness. Nothing to do with their talent...everyone knew that was farce from the beginning and that we'd end up right where we are today. Paying 7 figures to a high school kid who hasn't proven anything in the arena. But you know what? the schools aren't paying that, so they'll continue to make their millions of revenue...but no one ever looks at what the other side of the balance sheet those revenues pay for.
Holy shit, I stopped reading after your first sentence where you tried to compare people who are paid actual money for their risk to unpaid college kids.
 
Why wait?

We gonna pretend school matters for another 10 years? Pay them, make them employees working for subsidiary corporations.
Sounds like the framework is likely being shaped and will be ready when the time is right and that that timeframe was pointed to due to conference contract renewals and maybe playoff contract/deal.
 
NIL and an open transfer portal has changed college sports forever. The days of “parity” have ever been abolished. Amateur athletics have historically been at loggerheads with capitalism...and if you open your eyes and honestly observe what is happening, you know what I am saying. Giving immature kids access to millions of dollars is never a good solution. When your 20 years old, you think that’s nuts....when your 45 you know I am correct.
Money is not the cure to all evils. Pay attention.
Joel, when coaches started becoming millionaires while kids couldn’t accept money to buy momma a ticket to come see them play, the system reached eminent collapse. Assistant coaches are now approaching or earning million dollar contracts. What does an athletic director make at Iowa and how many assistant ADs are on staff?
The kids are bringing that money to Iowa.k
I know several guys with lingering injuries due to “big time college sports” who never had a chance to cash in, but pay the price daily.
There is no simple answer, but the model in place in recent decades became untenable. I was one who defended the amateur model fiercely, like you, but that is no longer workable.
“Giving immature kids access to millions of dollars…” is risky, but what is the difference in NIL money vs. getting drafted into “the league“ money?
Let the wrestler or soccer player cash in a bit while the opportunity is there. Soon enough their career in sports will end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SolarHawk
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT