ADVERTISEMENT

Poll: Chicken Sandwich Wars

Sandwich

  • Popeyes

    Votes: 41 30.1%
  • KFC

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Churches

    Votes: 3 2.2%
  • McDonalds

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Chick Fil A

    Votes: 75 55.1%
  • BK

    Votes: 3 2.2%
  • Wendys

    Votes: 10 7.4%
  • Sonic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 3 2.2%

  • Total voters
    136
A

anon_ddojbbh8q7xrt

Guest
Burger King and Sonic now have real breaded fried chicken sandwiches. Popeyes started the wars but which is the best?
 
No love for Shake Shack’s Korean-style fried chicken sandwich?
 
I like Chik Fil A, but I think that Popeye's spicy chicken sandwich is better.
hqg-2426.gif
 
Am I the only one who has never had any of these?

Want to try the Popeye's though. Had CFA a couple times...good but nothing all that special. Used to have the McD's version a lot back in the 90's but it's been a decade at least for them. Don't believe I've tried any of the others more than 1-2 times.

Just not much of a chicken sandwich person. Love fried chicken, just not in sandwiches.
 
Chick fil a is grossly overrated.
popeyes is the king as long as you go very light on the spicy Mayo.

Correct.

In Popeyes versus CFA it’s a matter of sauce versus everything else. CFA does have way better sauces as their CFA sauce and Polynesian sauces are both better than anything Popeyes offers (but not as good as Guthrie’s sauce which was cloned/stolen by Zaxby’s, Zaccados, Raising Cane’s and PDQ amongst others). But the actual chicken itself as well as the bun are miles better at Popeyes than CFA. CFA chicken is always mushy with soft and wet breading, I’ve never been a fan of their actual chicken. It’s only good if you drown it in sauce.

And good news! At least in Florida, you can buy CFA sauces in Publix. So you can get the best of both worlds by ordering the much better Popeyes sandwich and then dowsing it in CFA or Polynesian sauce.

Pressreleaseheader.jpg
 
Correct.

In Popeyes versus CFA it’s a matter of sauce versus everything else. CFA does have way better sauces as their CFA sauce and Polynesian sauces are both better than anything Popeyes offers (but not as good as Guthrie’s sauce which was cloned/stolen by Zaxby’s, Zaccados, Raising Cane’s and PDQ amongst others). But the actual chicken itself as well as the bun are miles better at Popeyes than CFA. CFA chicken is always mushy with soft and wet breading, I’ve never been a fan of their actual chicken. It’s only good if you drown it in sauce.

And good news! At least in Florida, you can buy CFA sauces in Publix. So you can get the best of both worlds by ordering the much better Popeyes sandwich and then dowsing it in CFA or Polynesian sauce.

Pressreleaseheader.jpg

Sweet and Spicy Sriracha sauce > *
 
BK uses fake meat. Barf.

The winner is Popeyes. Why does this thread exist? We all know this is true.

i agree their chicken is better, larger and I really like the crisp. However CFA has better spices while Popeyes uses sauce to create their spicy sandwich.
 
i agree their chicken is better, larger and I really like the crisp. However CFA has better spices while Popeyes uses sauce to create their spicy sandwich.
But you know and I know the chicken piece size on the ole popeyes is like 2x cfa. I think that's a better value proposition and it's _cheaper_.
 
In terms of chicken not on a bun, churches beats all these others.
 
Chick-Fil-A makes a great grilled chicken breast
and you can add the honey mustard for a delicious
sandwich.
 
Maybe I just got a bad one but I was not impressed with Popeyes. Of course it could have been the 40 minute wait for the 3 people ahead of me instead of the 15 minute wait for the 60 people ahead of me at CFA.
I like the buffalo sauce at CFA.
 
Correct.

In Popeyes versus CFA it’s a matter of sauce versus everything else. CFA does have way better sauces as their CFA sauce and Polynesian sauces are both better than anything Popeyes offers (but not as good as Guthrie’s sauce which was cloned/stolen by Zaxby’s, Zaccados, Raising Cane’s and PDQ amongst others). But the actual chicken itself as well as the bun are miles better at Popeyes than CFA. CFA chicken is always mushy with soft and wet breading, I’ve never been a fan of their actual chicken. It’s only good if you drown it in sauce.

And good news! At least in Florida, you can buy CFA sauces in Publix. So you can get the best of both worlds by ordering the much better Popeyes sandwich and then dowsing it in CFA or Polynesian sauce.

Pressreleaseheader.jpg
Popeyes is often considered the best for its crispy, flavorful chicken and seasoned coating, setting the standard for the breaded fried chicken sandwich wars.
 
Popeye's is the best but the service is crap. I think they intentionally hire the slowest workers they can find.
 
Follow this one simple trick and never be disappointed in Popeyes again. Only works when you're flying solo and assuming you have no allergies to Popeyes' menu. What you do is you order the cheapest thing from the menu at the drive through. Then you're happy if you get it. Or thrilled if you get someone's more expensive order
 
  • Haha
Reactions: torbee
Popeyes in Davenport is still the single worst fast food restaurant in America

I wonder how the Moline one is with their proximity to a well establish trailer park. It could be pretty fire.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bro D
I wonder how the Moline one is with their proximity to a well establish trailer park. It could be pretty fire.
Legendarily bad. It has a 1.7 rating on Yelp, lol. About as popular as UnitedHealthcare.

Some review excerpts:

  • Photo of Jon M.
    Jon M.
    Milwaukee, WI
    0

    Mar 19, 2024
    never have product. when they're not fighting with each other they're very rude to customers. was actually told that they wouldn't even take orders from lobby due to six cars in drive thru. I truly love Popeyes but this Moline location needs to be shut down for extensive training on customer service as well as proper ordering of product. if the staff and the franchise owner can't get their act together then they should just close down. By far the worst Popeyes I've ever had the displeasure of going to. I forgot about items that were purchased not even getting into the bag.

  • Photo of Nikita M.
    Nikita M.
    Silvis, IL
    0


    Aug 30, 2024
    Service is terrible!!! I pulled into the drive thru at 7pm on a Friday night and noticed there was an empty parking lot and nobody in the drive thru. I was greeted with "I'm gonna need a minute." I waited for at least 5 minutes and then the guy gets back on the speaker and said "I'm ready for your order but I'm only accepting exact change, credit or debit and if so I'll take your order." Seriously?! What a pleasant way to greet customers. I ordered a 12pc meal and he then he says " it's going to be a long wait because we just had a big group." When I asked how long of a wait he said 25-30 mins. Literally all they make here is chicken... and you don't have chicken prepared for a Friday night?! I'm glad I took my business elsewhere because I'm seeing bad reviews about the food too. They might as well just close this place down because what a joke!

    • Photo of Tina C.
      Tina C.
      Moline, IL



      Aug 31, 2024
      If I could give 0 stars I would. horrible service. employees too busy outside making tik toks, food is always horrible. I thought maybe after not coming here for a year it might be better but nope. never again.
      24x24_helpful_bulb_v2.yji-927d56e36e3a11c12e58.svg

      Helpful 0

      24x24_thanks_v2.yji-1fec900fe14a2fa15c10.svg

      Thanks 0

      24x24_love_this_v2.yji-e4b17143e9d097f34029.svg

      Love this 1

      24x24_oh_no_v2.yji-d19e61e9dc84c2e954c1.svg

      Oh no 0

    • Photo of Timothy S.
      Timothy S.
      Moline, IL
      =

      Aug 11, 2023

      Updated review
      Terrible, Terrible, Terrible

      Food ok. Service TERRIBLE, ambiance meh. Terrible, rude, unfriendly, lazy staff working here.
  • Photo of Chad J.
    Chad J.
    Kewanee, IL


    Feb 21, 2023
    Straight F'n trash!!!!!!!
    Shut this place down! Never coming back to this location.
    I've had Popeyes all around the world. So disappointed, they couldn't even get it right on Marti Gras.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: Moral and Bro D
Legendarily bad. It has a 1.7 rating on Yelp, lol. About as popular as UnitedHealthcare.

Some review excerpts:

  • Photo of Jon M.
    Jon M.
    Milwaukee, WI
    0

    Mar 19, 2024
    never have product. when they're not fighting with each other they're very rude to customers. was actually told that they wouldn't even take orders from lobby due to six cars in drive thru. I truly love Popeyes but this Moline location needs to be shut down for extensive training on customer service as well as proper ordering of product. if the staff and the franchise owner can't get their act together then they should just close down. By far the worst Popeyes I've ever had the displeasure of going to. I forgot about items that were purchased not even getting into the bag.

  • Photo of Nikita M.
    Nikita M.
    Silvis, IL
    0


    Aug 30, 2024
    Service is terrible!!! I pulled into the drive thru at 7pm on a Friday night and noticed there was an empty parking lot and nobody in the drive thru. I was greeted with "I'm gonna need a minute." I waited for at least 5 minutes and then the guy gets back on the speaker and said "I'm ready for your order but I'm only accepting exact change, credit or debit and if so I'll take your order." Seriously?! What a pleasant way to greet customers. I ordered a 12pc meal and he then he says " it's going to be a long wait because we just had a big group." When I asked how long of a wait he said 25-30 mins. Literally all they make here is chicken... and you don't have chicken prepared for a Friday night?! I'm glad I took my business elsewhere because I'm seeing bad reviews about the food too. They might as well just close this place down because what a joke!

    • Photo of Tina C.
      Tina C.
      Moline, IL



      Aug 31, 2024
      If I could give 0 stars I would. horrible service. employees too busy outside making tik toks, food is always horrible. I thought maybe after not coming here for a year it might be better but nope. never again.
      24x24_helpful_bulb_v2.yji-927d56e36e3a11c12e58.svg

      Helpful 0

      24x24_thanks_v2.yji-1fec900fe14a2fa15c10.svg

      Thanks 0

      24x24_love_this_v2.yji-e4b17143e9d097f34029.svg

      Love this 1

      24x24_oh_no_v2.yji-d19e61e9dc84c2e954c1.svg

      Oh no 0

    • Photo of Timothy S.
      Timothy S.
      Moline, IL
      =

      Aug 11, 2023

      Updated review
      Terrible, Terrible, Terrible

      Food ok. Service TERRIBLE, ambiance meh. Terrible, rude, unfriendly, lazy staff working here.
  • Photo of Chad J.
    Chad J.
    Kewanee, IL


    Feb 21, 2023
    Straight F'n trash!!!!!!!
    Shut this place down! Never coming back to this location.
    I've had Popeyes all around the world. So disappointed, they couldn't even get it right on Marti Gras.
Lol. I love reading reviews of shitty places. Assumed it's just as bad! Can't believe it's still open w a Chick Fil A next door
 
  • Like
Reactions: Moral
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT