ADVERTISEMENT

Slander Piece on Iowa in the Daily Nebraskan

That was a poorly reasoned and written piece, but its not slander. Its a opinion piece instead...everyone is entitled to an opinion no matter how bad they are at analysing football.
 
Last edited:
He has given the B1G West to jNW already based on 5 games worth of stats.
 
Not to mention that if it was defamatory, the charge would be libel and not slander since the statements were printed and published. Slander only applies to verbal or spoken defamatory statements.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ping72 and ichawk24
I like how he basically gave up on the other 5 teams in the division, just like, "nope their season is over". Sounds reasonable to me, LC.

Personally I wouldn't mind if it was just a two-team race heading into the 6th week of the season.

But if you were a Wisconsin or Nebraska fan, that wasn't busy being bitter.....you'd probably be like "eff that guy."

I'll give him credit though. He's putting himself out on the ledge with this opinion, especially being a writer for Nebraska.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Floyd_Of_Rosedale
I'd say that it goes without saying that Northwestern is going to be the toughest remaining foe on Iowa's schedule. That fact is essentially self-evident. That's not to say that other teams aren't capable of exploiting particular match-ups against Iowa and potentially beating the Hawks. However, Northwestern has both the best current resume AND they're playing the best TEAM ball (of Iowa's remaining foes).

However, sadly the writer of the opinion piece was rather limited in how they've annotated the data. Raw numbers, in themselves, says nothing about context ... nor does it do anything to facilitate understanding.

It is definitely fair to say that BOTH Iowa and Northwestern are more run-oriented teams. Iowa is so oriented simply because it is the Hawk's preferred identity. Iowa wants to be tough and physical ... and a running game is all about being tough and physical. Northwestern is so oriented BOTH because Fitzy wants Northwestern to be tough and physical (and they ARE this year) AND because that is how they are built personnel-wise this year.

So what would be the toughest match-up for a run-first team? Obviously a strong run D, right? That only makes sense!

However, look at the top "resume" teams played by Northwestern:

Duke: #30 run D (as measured by yards per game)
Stanford: #35 run D
Minnesota: #66 run D

Here are the top "resume" teams played by Iowa:

Pittsburgh: #4 run D
Wisconsin: #14 run D
Iowa State: #58 run D

The ability of a team like Iowa or Northwestern to run the ball is crucial as it relates to possessing the ball. Furthermore, it helps to keep the defense rested AND it complements the scoring D. The more you possess the ball, the fewer opportunities your opponent will have to score.

While Northwestern's scoring D stats through 5 games are exceptionally impressive. Iowa's are nothing to sneeze at either. Furthermore, as Iowa fans well know, around 24 points scored on the Hawk D are directly attributable to turnovers (including the punt-block) that put the D in very tough positions. I'm not just talking about turnovers that gave the opposing O a short field - we all know that those turnovers gave the opposition the ball deep within the red-zone! An additional 14 points were scored by Illinois State against Iowa's 2nd and 3rd teamers. Obviously the aforementioned points skew the stats of Iowa's scoring D. Without them, the Hawks would have just given up 39 points on the season. Not as far from the mark of Northwestern's scoring D as the article's author would try to lead us to believe.

While I don't expect Iowa to beat Northwestern - I think that they're very capable of doing so. Just considering match-ups, both Iowa and Northwestern are tough match-ups for each other. However, I'm still under the impression that CJ Beathard has that extra X-factor that could potentially give the Hawks the edge in that game.
 
I'd say that it goes without saying that Northwestern is going to be the toughest remaining foe on Iowa's schedule. That fact is essentially self-evident. That's not to say that other teams aren't capable of exploiting particular match-ups against Iowa and potentially beating the Hawks. However, Northwestern has both the best current resume AND they're playing the best TEAM ball (of Iowa's remaining foes).

However, sadly the writer of the opinion piece was rather limited in how they've annotated the data. Raw numbers, in themselves, says nothing about context ... nor does it do anything to facilitate understanding.

It is definitely fair to say that BOTH Iowa and Northwestern are more run-oriented teams. Iowa is so oriented simply because it is the Hawk's preferred identity. Iowa wants to be tough and physical ... and a running game is all about being tough and physical. Northwestern is so oriented BOTH because Fitzy wants Northwestern to be tough and physical (and they ARE this year) AND because that is how they are built personnel-wise this year.

So what would be the toughest match-up for a run-first team? Obviously a strong run D, right? That only makes sense!

However, look at the top "resume" teams played by Northwestern:

Duke: #30 run D (as measured by yards per game)
Stanford: #35 run D
Minnesota: #66 run D

Here are the top "resume" teams played by Iowa:

Pittsburgh: #4 run D
Wisconsin: #14 run D
Iowa State: #58 run D

The ability of a team like Iowa or Northwestern to run the ball is crucial as it relates to possessing the ball. Furthermore, it helps to keep the defense rested AND it complements the scoring D. The more you possess the ball, the fewer opportunities your opponent will have to score.

While Northwestern's scoring D stats through 5 games are exceptionally impressive. Iowa's are nothing to sneeze at either. Furthermore, as Iowa fans well know, around 24 points scored on the Hawk D are directly attributable to turnovers (including the punt-block) that put the D in very tough positions. I'm not just talking about turnovers that gave the opposing O a short field - we all know that those turnovers gave the opposition the ball deep within the red-zone! An additional 14 points were scored by Illinois State against Iowa's 2nd and 3rd teamers. Obviously the aforementioned points skew the stats of Iowa's scoring D. Without them, the Hawks would have just given up 39 points on the season. Not as far from the mark of Northwestern's scoring D as the article's author would try to lead us to believe.

While I don't expect Iowa to beat Northwestern - I think that they're very capable of doing so. Just considering match-ups, both Iowa and Northwestern are tough match-ups for each other. However, I'm still under the impression that CJ Beathard has that extra X-factor that could potentially give the Hawks the edge in that game.

Iowa will do well against NW run game and they don't pass much. While NW D is very good . Iowa will score at least 17. I don't see NW putting those points on the board,
 
At the bottom of the article you can click where it says "counter point" and read the argument for Iowa winning the west.

LOL!

Well, for a slanderous piece about a rival conference team in a student newspaper, it turns out that this article was fairly well-balanced (as far as slanderous pieces go, anyway).
 
I agree with most no slander. Just opinion and that's fine. Article has several good points.
 
They did beat Stanford, and destroyed Minnesota. This weekend will be their 2nd biggest test of the season. It will be telling.


I think jNW loses this weekend. I would rather have them win however. Don't want to head up to Evanston after they lose. Will make them that much more difficult to beat. just sayin...
 
One game into the conference schedule and this guy is writing teams off. Nobody is out of it yet. Nobody has it wrapped up. OOC record doesn't mean a thing.
 
Jeez, chill out. Not only was that completely free of any slander, it was a fairly reasonable analysis. It didn't even knock the Hawks, let alone slander them.

Geez, no kidding. I actually think the writer makes a good point. Only thing I would argue is that it is way to early to eliminate anyone.
 
They did beat Stanford, and destroyed Minnesota. This weekend will be their 2nd biggest test of the season. It will be telling.
Minnesota has a pretty good pass D - I think that their secondary is quite good. However, they're not extremely strong against the run ... they're decent, but really not strong in that regard. Thus, that match-up (NW run-O vs Minny run-D) played to Northwestern's advantage.

Also, as we all know, the Gopher O is pretty abysmally bad. In large part, that is attributable to a dinged OL and a QB that really cannot beat you with his arm. The Gophers only narrowly got victories over Colorado State and Ohio ... both games they easily could have lost. They're razor's width from being a 1-4 team ... and, in that scenario, their lone victory would have been a 10-7 victory over Kent State!

My point being ... I'm not certain that defeating Minnesota in its current state is all that much of a feather in Northwestern's cap.
 
I agree with him that NU will win the West. However, I hope the counter point guy is right and the Hawks win the west.
 
I love when writers say a team "controls their own destiny" after one game in conference play. That's like saying the 2017 Denver Broncos control their destiny, they just need to win out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DutchyFunStar
hurr-durr-derp-face-duh-ladies-lurrv-derp-tricks.jpg
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT