Spread of Catholic hospitals limits reproductive care across the U.S.

cigaretteman

HR King
May 29, 2001
73,000
52,664
113
The Supreme Court decision overturning the constitutional right to abortion is revealing the growing influence of Catholic health systems and their restrictions on reproductive services including birth control and abortion — even in the diminishing number of states where the procedure remains legal.
Catholic systems now control about 1 in 7 U.S. hospital beds, requiring religious doctrine to guide treatment, often to the surprise of patients. Their ascendancy has broad implications for the evolving national battle over reproductive rights beyond abortion, as bans against it take hold in more than a dozen Republican-led states.
The Catholic health-care facilities follow directives from the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops that prohibit treatment it deems “immoral”: sterilization including vasectomies, postpartum tubal ligations and contraception, as well as abortion. Those policies can limit treatment options for obstetric care during miscarriages and ectopic pregnancies, particularly in the presence of a fetal heartbeat.
“The directives are not just a collection of dos and don’ts,” said John F. Brehany, executive vice president of the National Catholic Bioethics Center and a longtime consultant to the conference of bishops. “They are a distillation of the moral teachings of the Catholic church as they apply to modern health care.” As such, he said, any facility that identifies as Catholic must abide by them.
The role of Catholic doctrine in U.S. health care has expanded during a years-long push to acquire smaller institutions — a reflection of consolidation in the hospital industry, as financially challenged community hospitals and independent physicians join bigger systems to gain access to electronic health records and other economies of scale. Acquisition by a Catholic health system has, at times, kept a town’s only hospital from closing.
Confusion post-Roe spurs delays, denials for some lifesaving pregnancy care
Four of the nation’s 10 largest health systems are now Catholic, according to a 2020 report by the liberal health advocacy organization Community Catalyst. The 10 largest Catholic health systems control 394 short-term, acute-care hospitals, a 50 percent increase over the past two decades. In Alaska, Iowa, South Dakota, Washington and Wisconsin, 40 percent or more of hospital beds are in Catholic facilities.
What post-Roe America could mean for your birth control
3:48
With Roe v. Wade overturned, the legality of abortion has been left to the states. Some worry that access to certain types of contraception could be next. (Video: Julie Yoon, Hadley Green, Sarah Hashemi/The Washington Post)
“It’s all about market share,” said Lois Uttley, a senior adviser to the hospital equity and accountability project at Community Catalyst. Uttley, who has been tracking hospital mergers and acquisitions since the 1990s, said that with fewer choices, patients today face more difficulty obtaining reproductive services.
In Schenectady, N.Y., Ellis Medicine is in talks with the multistate Catholic giant Trinity Health. Last month, in Quad Cities, Iowa, Genesis Health System signed a letter of intent to enter a partnership with MercyOne, also part of Trinity Health. And this semester, Oberlin College had to find a new provider to prescribe contraceptives after outsourcing student health services to a Catholic system that would not provide them.
In rural northeast Connecticut, residents are protesting the prospect of their 128-year-old hospital becoming part of a Catholic system and the potential impact on reproductive services.
“It would be very troubling to see cutbacks in a state like Connecticut,” said Ian McDonald, a stonemason who opposes the proposed deal between Day Kimball Healthcare in Putnam and Massachusetts-based Covenant Health.
Kyle Kramer, chief executive of Day Kimball Healthcare, said the proposed affiliation with Covenant Health would rescue the financially challenged 104-bed hospital.
“Obviously it has connotations,” Kramer said of the proposed move to faith-based ownership. The Catholic directives would “provide guidance,” he said in an interview, while insisting that “the services that we have provided in the past are the same services that we will continue to provide in the future.”
Kramer did not answer questions in a follow-up email about how contraception and elective sterilizations could continue to be provided under Catholic doctrine if their primary purpose is for birth control. Nor did he specify how emergency obstetric care that could result in terminating a pregnancy might be affected.
Covenant Health spokeswoman Karen Sullivan said in an email that as part of the regulatory process, the Catholic health system is drafting a public response to questions by the state’s Oct. 23 deadline. The system, she said, is committed to “ensuring that the Ethical and Religious Directives are applied thoughtfully and with empathy, compassion and respect for every person we serve.”
Catholic hospitals and providers are accredited and held to the same standards as their secular equivalents, according to the Catholic Health Association of the United States, which lobbies on behalf of Catholic hospitals.
But reproductive rights advocates say there has been a steady erosion of services in both Republican- and Democratic-led states because of the growing dominance of Catholic hospitals.
Physicians face confusion and fear in post-Roe world
Many patients are unaware of the restrictions because hospital administrators typically don’t outline the services they do not offer, said Sister Simone Campbell, a lawyer who until recently led the liberal-leaning NETWORK Lobby for Catholic Social Justice.
“Many hospitals have dealt with this by being pretty quiet. Dobbs has made it more of a question,” Campbell said, referring to the case that led to the Supreme Court’s overturning of Roe v. Wade.
Catholic facilities may not “promote or condone” contraception, according to the directives — a stance that is not widely shared by the public. Just 4 percent of U.S. adults think contraception is immoral, according to a 2016 Pew Research Center poll. Among Catholics who attend weekly Mass, only 13 percent say contraception is morally wrong, and 45 percent find it acceptable.
The directives, developed in the late 1940s by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, were updated in 2018, largely to ensure that Catholic doctrine prevails after mergers and acquisitions, according to Amy Chen, a lawyer with the National Health Law Program. They limit options for referring patients to secular facilities, saying employees must not “manage, carry out, assist in carrying out, make its facilities available for, make referrals for, or benefit from the revenue generated by immoral procedures.”
Interpretation of the directives varies among hospital ethics committees. But decisions ultimately rest with the local bishop, who is to be kept informed, the directives say, if “a Catholic health care institution might be wrongly cooperating with immoral procedures.”
“Bishops have a great deal of authority in their dioceses,” Brehany said. “A bishop should ensure that a Catholic organization is abiding by the directives.”
Abortion is now banned in these states. See where laws have changed.


 

cigaretteman

HR King
May 29, 2001
73,000
52,664
113
A 2018 survey published in the journal Contraception found that more than one-third of women who go to Catholic hospitals for reproductive care are not aware of the facilities’ religious affiliation. The study, conducted by researchers at the University of Chicago and the University of California at San Francisco, called for increased transparency among hospitals to raise awareness that patients’ options may be limited at institutions with religious ties.
“Even people who had a very wanted pregnancy are at the mercy of policies not driven by their personal values or by the best interests of their health,” said Debra Stulberg, the chair of family medicine at the University of Chicago and one of the researchers in the 2018 survey.
April King, 40, said she wanted to have her tubes tied immediately after giving birth to her second child in December 2020. The Los Angeles talent agent had suffered three miscarriages and knew her family was complete.
Then she learned she could not get a tubal ligation at Providence Saint John’s Health Center in Santa Monica, where she planned to deliver.
“I was just surprised that [the hospital] could decide that for us,” said King, who ultimately elected to go ahead with her delivery at Providence Saint John’s because of the care she had received there in the past.
Doctors, too, face surprises — and can even be reported to hospital ethics committees for following standards of care.
In Washington state, where 41 percent of beds are Catholic-run, legislators passed a law last year to prevent hospitals from interfering with a doctor’s ability to provide medically necessary care to a pregnant patient whose health or life is at risk.
Annie Iriye, a retired OB/GYN who used to work for a Catholic hospital in Olympia, Wash., testified in support of the bill. In a recent interview, Iriye described wanting to administer medication to hasten a woman’s delivery to stave off infection after her water broke at 18 weeks, before fetal viability. Even though the woman was in active labor, Iriye said other staffers refused to follow her direction as the attending physician because a heartbeat had been detected.
By the time the woman delivered, she had a fever and needed antibiotics. Staffers reported Iriye to the hospital ethics committee.
“I was flabbergasted,” Iriye said. “It’s like, ‘Oh, come on guys. Can’t we just practice medicine and give good care?’ ”
Are you a provider or patient who has experienced disruptions to reproductive health care? Get in touch.
Patients say there appears to be little consistency in how hospital staffers interpret religious directives, with doctors sometimes having to make decisions on the fly.
Whitney Marshall, 29, learned only after waking up from exploratory surgery for endometriosis in 2019 at Ascension Crittenton in Rochester Hills, Mich., that her IUD had not been replaced. Marshall, who uses the device to reduce the pain associated with the condition, had to undergo a second procedure in her gynecologist’s office to have the IUD reinserted. The spokesman for Ascension Crittenton did not respond to requests for comment about the case.
“Some women cannot afford surgeries” to treat endometriosis, Marshall said. “So their only form of recourse is to try to regulate their hormones by using contraceptives.”
Catholic hospitals’ tradition of serving women and children in the neediest neighborhoods is “rooted in our reverence for life,” said Brian Reardon, spokesman for the Catholic Health Association. But the lack of choice has been felt keenly in rural and low-income communities where patients cannot easily transfer to secular institutions, reproductive rights advocates say.
Hospitals operating under Catholic restrictions are “the sole community providers of short-term acute hospital care” in more than 52 communities across the country — up from 30 in 2013, according to Community Catalyst.
Residents of northeastern Connecticut protest outside Day Kimball Healthcare in Putnam in July over its plan to affiliate with Covenant Health. (Susan Haigh/AP)
In Putnam, Connecticut, residents have relied on Day Kimball Healthcare, the town’s only hospital, for more than a century.
Kramer, the chief executive, said the hospital has been exploring partnerships with larger systems over the past decade to ensure its long-term survival.
The proposed arrangement with Covenant Health requires the approval of Connecticut’s Office of Health Strategy, which has been examining how services might be affected.
The need to preserve access to reproductive health services can bring an end to negotiations. In 2012, the investor in a proposed joint venture with two hospitals in Waterbury, Conn., one of which was Catholic, pulled out after reproductive health advocates and the local archbishop raised opposing concerns about creating a “hospital within a hospital” to provide reproductive services — a workaround that had been successful elsewhere.
Access to reproductive services has shrunk recently around Day Kimball after the 2020 closure of Planned Parenthood in nearby Danielson.
Abortion bans complicate access to drugs for cancer, arthritis, even ulcers
Like many hospitals, Day Kimball does not provide elective abortions, according to documents filed with the state. But it has provided other care prohibited by Catholic directives, including elective sterilizations.
Those services are key to preventing unwanted pregnancies, said Lee Wesler, an internist who has been affiliated with Day Kimball for a decade.
“Any unwanted pregnancy is a potential abortion,” Wesler said.
Members of the group Save Day Kimball Healthcare said that in conversations, Kramer and other representatives of the hospital have sought to be reassuring. “They say, ‘Everything will be fine,’ ” said Margaret Martin, a retired social worker and member of the group.
Kramer, who said he intends to stay on if the Covenant deal goes through, repeated those assurances to The Washington Post. “What we have been we will still be,” he said, while declining to describe how contraceptives could be offered for the sole purpose of birth control.
In a Q&A posted in September on the Day Kimball website, Kramer suggests that other justifications could be found for using “tools” such as oral contraceptives, including “to maintain health and wellness, to address a medical condition, prevent disease, and mitigate cancer risk.”
Bruce Shay, a member of the Save Day Kimball Healthcare steering committee, says he worries doctors may leave if they have to abide by the directives — or might evade them by making “a sketchy diagnosis.”
Nandini Seshadri has seen that happen.
The 40-year-old Latham, N.Y. resident received a copper IUD after delivering her first child at a secular hospital that Trinity is in the process of acquiring. She was denied the device after giving birth to her second child at a Catholic hospital now affiliated with Trinity.
“I remember laughing and saying, ‘What? Seriously?’ ” Seshadri recalled. “I didn’t know that Catholic hospitals still did that.”
She was even more surprised when her nurse-midwife offered her a hormonal IUD instead, on the grounds that she needed it to stabilize her menstrual cycle.
“I didn’t have that problem,” Seshadri said. To give her the contraception, she said, the nurse “was essentially falsifying my medical record.”
 

Aardvark86

HR All-American
Jan 23, 2018
3,181
3,302
113
Honestly, this is a rather silly article.

Most of the particular kind of "care" that you're talking about is not, as a general matter, required to be provided in a hospital setting. And freestanding outpatient clinics or surgi-centers are simply not that hard to set up. So blame local lawmakers if you must (and for that matter, other local docs who personally don't want to be ethically or socially associated with some procedures), but this one isn't in fact the Catholics' fault.

To be sure, when small facilities find themselves in need of a larger partner through a sale or alliance, the choice of a larger Catholic partner comes with strings attached, which the seller is free to agree to, or not. Stated differently, "my facility, my choice." But as the article notes, sometimes agreeing to those conditions preserves local access to hospital care for other, life-threatening conditions. And sometimes you find another partner and take a little less, which is fine too.
 

LuteHawk

HR Legend
Nov 30, 2011
28,377
19,024
113
In the Peoria, Illinois metro area the two biggest employers:

1. OSF (Order of St. Francis) Healthcare....13,500 employees
2. Caterpillar Inc.....12,000 employees

This Roman Catholic Health Care system dominates the area
in terms of up to date facilities, number of hospital beds, and
reputation as an excellent employer with good wages.
 

abby97

HR All-American
Sep 16, 2010
4,487
4,085
113
I'm not sure why this article was written? In a free country, the Catholic Church has every right to open as many hospitals as they see fit. If other organizations want to open hospitals, they are free to do so as well.
 
Feb 9, 2013
21,139
59,249
113
I'm not sure why this article was written? In a free country, the Catholic Church has every right to open as many hospitals as they see fit. If other organizations want to open hospitals, they are free to do so as well.
I think just raising awareness and making an observation about availability of care.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3boysmom

Hoosierhawkeye

HR Legend
Sep 16, 2008
48,237
41,018
113
40
I think just raising awareness and making an observation about availability of care.

I find it odd that it said a third of women who go to these hospitals are unaware of their affiliation.

Here is a tip. . . if Saint is in the name. It's probably a Catholic hospital. If it's named after a Roman Catholic order like the Franciscans . . . it's probably a Catholic hospital. If it's named something like Mercy, Faith, Hope . . . good chance it's a Catholic hospital.

I mean the example they give the woman went to a hospital called Providence St. John's. And Catholics are famously not cool with birth control. Come on how much more obvious could it be?
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldmom

JRHawk2003

HR Legend
Jul 9, 2003
46,005
16,991
113
Montrose
Spread? These things are nothing new and the two in our area, Mercy CR and IC are not doing great. Mercy IC in particular.
 
Feb 9, 2013
21,139
59,249
113
I find it odd that it said a third of women who go to these hospitals are unaware of their affiliation.

Here is a tip. . . if Saint is in the name. It's probably a Catholic hospital. If it's named after a Roman Catholic order like the Franciscans . . . it's probably a Catholic hospital. If it's named something like Mercy, Faith, Hope . . . good chance it's a Catholic hospital.

I mean the example they give the woman went to a hospital called Providence St. John's. And Catholics are famously not cool with birth control. Come on how much more obvious could it be?
I agree, but then again, 70+ million people voted to re-elect Trump. So…
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman

Titanhawk2

HR Legend
Jul 14, 2011
12,533
5,706
113
"In the United States, hospitals typically operate privately"

That means predominantly religious based - not an effing spread. I guess just the realization of the ignorant
 

goldmom

HR Legend
Mar 29, 2002
21,204
24,836
113
I won’t swear to it but I don’t believe Catholic hospitals ever offered pregnancy terminations. So not sure things are different now.
 

Aardvark86

HR All-American
Jan 23, 2018
3,181
3,302
113
I find it odd that it said a third of women who go to these hospitals are unaware of their affiliation.

Here is a tip. . . if Saint is in the name. It's probably a Catholic hospital. If it's named after a Roman Catholic order like the Franciscans . . . it's probably a Catholic hospital. If it's named something like Mercy, Faith, Hope . . . good chance it's a Catholic hospital.

I mean the example they give the woman went to a hospital called Providence St. John's. And Catholics are famously not cool with birth control. Come on how much more obvious could it be?
In fairness, there are plenty of hospitals that are affiliated but in less obvious ways.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3boysmom

3boysmom

HR Legend
Gold Member
Dec 21, 2001
16,432
33,978
113
Omaha, NE
www.chooseyouradventuretravels.com
Here in Omaha there are CHI Lakeside and CHI Midlands that are Catholic but if you didn't know that CHI stood for Catholic Health Initiative you wouldn't know from the name that they were Catholic hospitals. I would bet a fair number wouldn't know from CHI Immanuel or even Bergan that it was Catholic. Then there are many more that don't realize that they can't get a tubal during their c-section at a Catholic hospital.