ADVERTISEMENT

wouldja poll

What would you do?

  • Kick her to the curb

    Votes: 15 75.0%
  • Buy her the necklace

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Let time heal and move on

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Exercise all that Crime TV knowledge

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • It all depends on her hot to crazy ratio

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    20

alaskanseminole

HR Legend
Oct 20, 2002
20,864
29,237
113

Woman faces backlash over reaction to boyfriend’s handmade Valentine’s Day gift: ‘You should be ashamed’​

[I can't find any pics of the woman]

A woman is furious with her boyfriend for not spending enough money on her on Valentine’s Day.

She took to Reddit’s “Am I the A******? (AITA)” forum for help. Her boyfriend has two sons from a previous relationship. He usually gets her jewelry on gifting occasions, but this year, he handmade her a wooden frame with a family photo in it. Now, she’s upset because she wanted a necklace.

“I have been with my boyfriend, who’s a single dad with two boys, for two years,” she wrote. “He has a decent job with decent income and is into woodworking as a hobby. For Valentine’s Days, birthdays and every other celebration, he’d gift me mostly jewelry, and I get him his favorite gadgets or sports gear.

“For this Valentine’s Day, I got him sneakers. I found out today that his gift for me was a wooden framed photo of him, me and the kids. I gotta say, I wasn’t thrilled with it. When I told my boyfriend my honest opinion (I didn’t wanna open my mouth, but he pushed me), he couldn’t believe this was my reaction.”

She told him that the frame wasn’t expensive enough, but he didn’t understand what the problem was.

“I pointed out that he has money for a $200 necklace at least,” she explained. “But he said I was out of line to imply he was being cheap when all he was doing was making me a special gift. And [he] also had the kids help with it and put so much thought and effort into it because they see me like family. And I should be appreciative of that.

“I said I was but still thought he could’ve added the necklace as a great combo, but he got even madder, saying he couldn’t understand why I’d value a necklace as much as or even over a special gift he and the kids made for me. We went back and forth on this, and breakfast got ruined. He went upstairs and refused to speak to me. I feel like he blew this out of proportion since he asked for my opinion, and I don’t know if he has the right to be upset with me now.”

Redditors thought the woman was completely in the wrong.

“You should be ashamed about your reaction,” a user said.

“Get over yourself and appreciate what you’ve got with these people before you lose them,” another wrote.

“You sound brutally self-centered and materialistic,” someone added.
 
  • Like
Reactions: h-hawk
Haven't voted yet, but after 2 years if they didn't know this would be each others' reactions, something's wrong with the relationship.

I can honestly see both sides being both right and wrong here.
 
This one is easy. Directions:

1. Hold on for a bit to bang it.
2. Kick it to the curb when bored.

Ain't got time for that shit.
 
Haven't voted yet, but after 2 years if they didn't know this would be each others' reactions, something's wrong with the relationship.

I can honestly see both sides being both right and wrong here.

I'm not sure 2 years is necessarily enough to know that kind of stuff.

That said I think she deserves a chance to recognize she was wrong and apologize. But if that doesn't happen he should probably get out now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Old_wrestling_fan
I would much rather have a handmade gift made just for me rather than something purchased. I'm not a jewelry person so I'd be pissed if Mr. Birch bought me a necklace I would never wear. I'm curious if the internet response will change this lady's perspective on the situation.
 
Some people are really into jewelry and bling...others, not so much, a personal gift would have much more meaning to them. Me...I like to spend time with the folks that are more personal, not into "things" as much.
 
Some people are really into jewelry and bling...others, not so much, a personal gift would have much more meaning to them. Me...I like to spend time with the folks that are more personal, not into "things" as much.
But to make an attempt to humiliate your SO publicly to simply garner, "You're so right, girl" comments is ridiculous. I'm glad I married a (no pics) woman who would prefer something personal from those who love her over some piece of retail.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT