ADVERTISEMENT

A question....why punt at end of 1st half?

Hawk-A-Doodle-Doo

HB Legend
Oct 1, 2001
22,377
16,182
113
Island of Misfit Message Board Posters
Ol' Doodle's not gonna hyperventilate about this loss. What we have here folks, if we're being honest with ourselves, is yet another typical 7.5-win Iowa team. Not terrible. Not great. Just good enough to make a bowl, and that's about it.

But the decision to punt at the end of the first half is befuddling to say the least.

You can punt or throw on that play. Either way the half is going to end. But only one of those choices gives you a chance to score. Sure it's a remote chance...but a chance nonetheless. Meanwhile the punt seems to carry much more risk than a Hail Mary to the endzone. And if you throw, you also open the opportunity for a penalty that could extend the half by one play.

So please, enlighten Doodle as to the logic of that decision. It seemed to offer virtually no upside whatsoever.
 
Because an offfense as shitty as ours could leave time on the clock to let MSU score. You have to remember, it was 5 seconds. Stanley got pressure all game. Asking for that amount of time with a rattled oline and QB isn't a shot worth taking. I'm fine with that decision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Capital1Hawk
Ol' Doodle's not gonna hyperventilate about this loss. What we have here folks, if we're being honest with ourselves, is yet another typical 7.5-win Iowa team. Not terrible. Not great. Just good enough to make a bowl, and that's about it.

But the decision to punt at the end of the first half is befuddling to say the least.

You can punt or throw on that play. Either way the half is going to end. But only one of those choices gives you a chance to score. Sure it's a remote chance...but a chance nonetheless. Meanwhile the punt seems to carry much more risk than a Hail Mary to the endzone. And if you throw, you also open the opportunity for a penalty that could extend the half by one play.

So please, enlighten Doodle as to the logic of that decision. It seemed to offer virtually no upside whatsoever.
Cmon the punter got off his best punt when it didn’t matter.
 
Padding the punters stats so us fans stop questioning why he is in there. He flies the ball somewhere near 30yrds on average - that's terrible.
Also, the "hail mary" is far too exotic for Iowa....
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT