ADVERTISEMENT

Bill Nye: Genius

A

anon_snp6dc585nnj4

Guest
ik8gyhF.jpg
 
Not that any of this bothers me but how would ultra violet light change genetics?

Ultimately I agree with him in that I view race as ultimately a social construct. This is because if a person has parents of 2 different races we tend to inexplicably assign a single race to them anyways.
 
Well he clarifies it as scientifically, and ignores it (fine for his purpose) anthropologically and socially.

Race might not be "real" in "scientific" calculations, but it certainly can be in other arenas. But I agree with his overall point.
 
Not that any of this bothers me but how would ultra violet light change genetics?

UV light is linked to skin cancer. In tropical regions, those with genetically darker skin tended to avoid cancer so darker skin evolved as a defense mechanism against exposure.
 
UV light is linked to skin cancer. In tropical regions, those with genetically darker skin tended to avoid cancer so darker skin evolved as a defense mechanism against exposure.

Isn't skin cancer something that takes a little long to prevent a person from reproducing?

What if it isn't the other way around that skin pigment became more pale to help with cold winter weather in Europe and modern day Russia.

Also that doesn't exactly explain anything other then skin pigment. Given that there are notable physical differences between people of different races other then skin pigment what caused these?

Also what of the variety of races found in Asia? Native Americans both from the area that became the US but also natives from Alaska and Canada? Plus natives from what is now Latin America and the islands of the Caribbean.

Listen I agree it's more or less social construct, we can all reproduce with one another, the differences are more or less minor and when a person has parents of 2 different races it makes no sense in how we try to racially identify him/her with only one race.

All of that said, I think he's over simplifying a bit and there is probably a good deal of mystery around it as well.
 
UV light is linked to skin cancer. In tropical regions, those with genetically darker skin tended to avoid cancer so darker skin evolved as a defense mechanism against exposure.

Not before they had a chance to breed and spread the skin cancer susceptible gene.... your theory fails.
 
Isn't skin cancer something that takes a little long to prevent a person from reproducing?

What if it isn't the other way around that skin pigment became more pale to help with cold winter weather in Europe and modern day Russia.

Also that doesn't exactly explain anything other then skin pigment. Given that there are notable physical differences between people of different races other then skin pigment what caused these?

Also what of the variety of races found in Asia? Native Americans both from the area that became the US but also natives from Alaska and Canada? Plus natives from what is now Latin America and the islands of the Caribbean.

Listen I agree it's more or less social construct, we can all reproduce with one another, the differences are more or less minor and when a person has parents of 2 different races it makes no sense in how we try to racially identify him/her with only one race.

All of that said, I think he's over simplifying a bit and there is probably a good deal of mystery around it as well.

He only had a paragraph. Would've been pretty hard to fit all the ins and outs of human evolution in there. You may have missed his point
 
He only had a paragraph. Would've been pretty hard to fit all the ins and outs of human evolution in there. You may have missed his point

Sorry, Bill Nye has been completely Baptized into the Church of Climate Change. I have no respect for him any more. He's really nothing more than a "celebrity" now days and is no longer a scientist.
 
He only had a paragraph. Would've been pretty hard to fit all the ins and outs of human evolution in there. You may have missed his point

Everyone is missing the point when the world is being educated one meme at a time...it allows people to take a small bit of "truth" out of context and incorporate it to their narrative. We're screwed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawk and Awe
Isn't skin cancer something that takes a little long to prevent a person from reproducing?

What if it isn't the other way around that skin pigment became more pale to help with cold winter weather in Europe and modern day Russia.

Also that doesn't exactly explain anything other then skin pigment. Given that there are notable physical differences between people of different races other then skin pigment what caused these?

Also what of the variety of races found in Asia? Native Americans both from the area that became the US but also natives from Alaska and Canada? Plus natives from what is now Latin America and the islands of the Caribbean.

Listen I agree it's more or less social construct, we can all reproduce with one another, the differences are more or less minor and when a person has parents of 2 different races it makes no sense in how we try to racially identify him/her with only one race.

All of that said, I think he's over simplifying a bit and there is probably a good deal of mystery around it as well.

It's an oversimplification, surely. Also bass-ackwards since man evolved in Africa and then went into Europe. Our skin didn't darken....it lightened. UV radiation destroys folate which can cause women to produce fewer healthy babies. Dark skin protects folate. As we moved north, the shorter days required a greater ability to absorb sunlight to manufacture vitamin D. Lighter skin was a distinct evolutionary advantage there.
 
Not that any of this bothers me but how would ultra violet light change genetics?

Ultimately I agree with him in that I view race as ultimately a social construct. This is because if a person has parents of 2 different races we tend to inexplicably assign a single race to them anyways.
Unless they are pure Aryan stock all the way back to Jesus, they are mongrels.

OTOH, it's OK for them to have abortions because they aren't really human.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT