Correct, and that's to make sure women get equal funding for sports. That's it.
CNN guests clash after Trump's victory in heated debate over 'transphobia'
- Thread starter NorthernHawkeye
- Start date
No, that is NOT it.
What is Title IX? - Women's Sports Foundation
Athletic programs are considered educational programs and activities. Title IX gives women athletes the right to equal opportunity in sports in educational institutions that receive federal funds, from elementary schools to colleges and universities. While there are few private elementary...
www.womenssportsfoundation.org
It’s a common sense issue, that when gets out to a vote in state legislatures, only liberals vote against, painting them into the corner of allowing bio boys to compete with bio girls. It’s going to be, like I’ve said for the last year, a hill Dems will
Well, to be fair, this is something that I'd vote against on the grounds that i don't think it's something we should be voting on. That's not representative of my position on this.
More importantly, you do not get to “reimagine” the English language.
Why was title 9 a government issue? Trans girls in sports is a breach of title 9 laws. This is not hard to understand.
Last edited:
Where exactly in that legislation does it refer to trans students?
That's the point. Boys are taking away opportunities from girls.
Back when title 9 was written, people still had common sense about what a woman is. Historically, trans people did not think they actually ARE the opposite sex,they just wanted to present themselves as the opposite sex. they did not think they had the same rights as a woman, they just wanted the right to dress and present themselves how they felt comfortable.
Today we are told that trans people actually ARE the opposite sex and therefore they deserve the same rights as a woman. this idea is not based in science or reality.
The idea that anyone can be a woman if they say they are obviously undermines the protections that title 9 was created for.
The fact is, title 9 was created to prevent sex based discrimination and to ensure women have the same opportunity as men. if men are taking away the opportunities from women, this is a clear violation of title 9 laws.
Biden tried to change the title 9 laws to include protections for gender identity. This has been challenged in court.
Remember that per the wpath, gender identity is fluid and can change at any time. Every sane person should realize that granting protections based on feelings will undermine the protections for women.
I understand the background of Title IX, my wife worked in a division 1 athletic department. I’m still of the belief that ‘trans’ athlete participation should be left up the conferences and leagues and not decided by the government. This is such a minor issue in the big picture of this country, so many other things to worry about.
When does this move from a minor issue to an issue that needs to be addressed in your opinion? 20 men in women's sports? 50? 100? Man winning a woman's sporting event?
Imo, leaving this up to the conferences will end up making the issue an attack on a trans individuals.
Think lia Thomas. He won in swimming and lots of people criticized him for it. Schools were forced to address the trans in sports issue knowing it was due to the success of lia Thomas that got them talking.
I'm sure lia Thomas received a lot of hate for winning. how is this better than having politicians clarifying the title 9 laws before it becomes a bigger issue with more attacks on individual trans athletes.
You approve of it and your explanation is your cover.
And then go even a step further and hire several of them into the worst admin in the history of the USA. Not the most qualified, just the most diverse.
LOL, the algorithm did its job. Into the OPs in box, and out onto the internet for amplification.
I find it funny in a sad way that the OP starts these threads, and the usual "I support women/girls", posters come out, right after they voted for the guy who famously creeped his way around backstage at beauty pageants.
I always think of the OP and his amplification efforts, and all the people who get totally energized by trans hysteria.
"This is a typical practice of a totalitarian regime. You take a group, vulnerable people in society, and you turn them into outcasts, and you direct all the disappointment and dissatisfaction about lack of development or lack of success in the war and all of society's hatred and negative feelings against that group".
The quote is from a critic of Putin, who famously has railed against the trans community. Little wonder that the OP amplifies the messaging of despots.
I find it funny in a sad way that the OP starts these threads, and the usual "I support women/girls", posters come out, right after they voted for the guy who famously creeped his way around backstage at beauty pageants.
I always think of the OP and his amplification efforts, and all the people who get totally energized by trans hysteria.
"This is a typical practice of a totalitarian regime. You take a group, vulnerable people in society, and you turn them into outcasts, and you direct all the disappointment and dissatisfaction about lack of development or lack of success in the war and all of society's hatred and negative feelings against that group".
The quote is from a critic of Putin, who famously has railed against the trans community. Little wonder that the OP amplifies the messaging of despots.
Last edited:
Sure, because you are such a huge supporter of opportunities for women and girls given your posting history. Let's pretend this is true, and it's all about protecting girls. Tell us this is where anti trans activism ends for you? Let's say the is a law passed by Congress, and signed by Donald Trump restricting access to girls sports, is this where it ends for you? Or, will you be honest and admit this is just the gateway for a bigger agenda?
You seem very comfortable taking away rights and opportunities from other people. You seem fine with marginalizing and demonizing a very small, relatively powerless group of citizens. Some people aren't you.
You seem fine marginalizing girls. And all because your party overlords say so.
Let's put it to a popular voting process. We can put it to a national vote.
I think the left is going to find out that people are sick of their bullshit on this topic. Since the recent elections weren't enough to send that message and all. Anonymous popular vote. I think the result would be north of 90 percent against every single trans issue the left is pushing. Beyond of course adults being able to make decisions for themselves at their own expense if it doesn't impact others negatively. Even that though on this issue may require extensive counseling before taking any sort of action and prohibitions outright for those individuals affected by other mental health issues. The grooming of kids in any form even if they call it affirming or supporting genders will probably result in jail time.
The left has found a losing topic and wants to keep digging.
I think the left is going to find out that people are sick of their bullshit on this topic. Since the recent elections weren't enough to send that message and all. Anonymous popular vote. I think the result would be north of 90 percent against every single trans issue the left is pushing. Beyond of course adults being able to make decisions for themselves at their own expense if it doesn't impact others negatively. Even that though on this issue may require extensive counseling before taking any sort of action and prohibitions outright for those individuals affected by other mental health issues. The grooming of kids in any form even if they call it affirming or supporting genders will probably result in jail time.
The left has found a losing topic and wants to keep digging.
I would suggest that you explain it to everyone. I think we all know what a trans person is, but a lot of us may be missing the boat.
The dude wigging out in the video over the usage of the word boy is a pretty good example of the lefty sort of attitude that is detrimental to democrat politics.
Obviously the other guy was just using the world to refer to biologically male people.
Obviously the other guy was just using the world to refer to biologically male people.
He is just asking a commonsense question. Dems have become the party of no Commonsense
Bill maher has coined that expression regarding Dems.
I support the governing bodies to make the right choices.
How many trans citizens participated sports last year?
Exactly. These people arrived on the scene a few years back and declared that worlds like "boy" or "woman" no longer contained reference back to biological sex in their definition and if you don't agree you're a bigot.
Language doesn't work like that, it's just a rolling consensus over time.
Around 70 percent of people believe that sports should be sex segregated.
news.gallup.com
More Say Birth Gender Should Dictate Sports Participation
Americans are less supportive than two years ago of transgender athletes being allowed to play on sports teams that match their current gender identity.
news.gallup.com
It’s like you have to talk to them and treat them like a little child or they throw a tantrum
I answered. I support allowing the governing bodies and professionals make the decisions. It seems like it's occurred on a very limited basis and been managed well. I was speaking with some City High moms who are as MAGA as MAGA can be a few weeks ago, and they were speaking glowingly of a trans athlete at City. They commented on how dedicated the kid was to the sport The difference I suppose is they've known this child for years. It's harder to hate when you know someone.
I'm asking YOU. Does it end here for you? Or, are you going to have another front in the trans wars?
Why are you afraid to state whether or not YOU support boys in girls sports?
Because it’s only conservatives that are told what to think Northern!! Democrats have principles, don’t you know?!?!
I dont know. How many would it need to be for it to matter?
It's not just about sports but also private/safe spaces like restrooms and locker rooms which lucas doesn't want to touch for obvious reasons. I will give a real life local story about this being a major issue so I don't have to hear about how this doesn't affect me or my family (this happened at my gym).
At lifetime fitness in wildwood, MO a "trans woman" was using the locker room and doing his make up in the middle of the communal mirrors/shared space with no clothes or towel on.. totally naked with his dick hanging out for all the women and girls to see. Keep in mind children use this space, and a grown man thought it appropriate and acceptable to expose his male genitalia to all of them. This guy has since been banned (for violent threats on social media and not exposing himself to minors interestingly enough) but continues to be a general cancer on the community. You can actually look him up on fb and x, his account names are Eris Discordia. He spends the majority of every day screaming into the void about how he needs to be accepted and affirmed or you're Hitler. The most amazing part of this to me is almost nobody even engages with him. Some days he will make 30 or more social media posts and not get a single like. If only his severe male pattern baldness and penis weren't complete tells...
At lifetime fitness in wildwood, MO a "trans woman" was using the locker room and doing his make up in the middle of the communal mirrors/shared space with no clothes or towel on.. totally naked with his dick hanging out for all the women and girls to see. Keep in mind children use this space, and a grown man thought it appropriate and acceptable to expose his male genitalia to all of them. This guy has since been banned (for violent threats on social media and not exposing himself to minors interestingly enough) but continues to be a general cancer on the community. You can actually look him up on fb and x, his account names are Eris Discordia. He spends the majority of every day screaming into the void about how he needs to be accepted and affirmed or you're Hitler. The most amazing part of this to me is almost nobody even engages with him. Some days he will make 30 or more social media posts and not get a single like. If only his severe male pattern baldness and penis weren't complete tells...
A lot more than currently you guys are getting hysterical over.
Do you still work at Hy-Vee? There have been two trans employees at my local Hy-Vee the last few years. Should Hy-Vee be able to discriminate against trans workers if you were uncomfortable with a trans citizen in the break room?
I have made my position clear. That you cannot comprehend it is a you problem.
Why are you afraid to answer my question? Does it end with girls sports?
Do you support trans citizens being denied employment opportunities despite merit or ability? Do you support denial of health care? Are you in favor of bathroom monitors?
I have stated my position. Let the governing bodies and professionals handle it. Do you know any trans citizens? What rights and opportunities do you want denied to them? Or, are you 100 percent just about girls sports? Do your principles extend to denial of health care and employment opportunities? The right to marry and share in a family? Is it just the male to female trans citizens that make you feel icky?
What makes a sports governing body the expert on transgenders playing sports? At least politicians are elected and are supposed to represent the people.
What number is an acceptable number of trans girls (boys) playing sports against girls? people keep trying to say its not a big enough problem to be addressed, and yet we keep having these threads. It might be time to re-evaluate your position.
Of course not. Is anyone advocating for that? Lol don't be stupid.
