ADVERTISEMENT

Costco worth it?

I recall seeing a story on CNBC, or some such station, a few years ago that Costco can save 10-15 percent even on name brand items. Depending on the item I choose the cheaper Kirkland variety and save more. You can pay GP prices for paper goods, or just buy the Kirkland brand that I am pretty sure is made in the same factory.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GOHOX69
I recall seeing a story on CNBC, or some such station, a few years ago that Costco can save 10-15 percent even on name brand items. Depending on the item I choose the cheaper Kirkland variety and save more. You can pay GP prices for paper goods, or just buy the Kirkland brand that I am pretty sure is made in the same factory.
The only Kirkland brand item I don't care for is the toilet paper. No proper substitute for Charmin.
 
Does Costco have a Scan and Go app similar to Sam’s Club? IMO, the app is a game changer. Sam’s is 30 minutes closer for us, but IF we had a Costco closer AND they have an app, I’d choose it over Sam’s.
I use Sam's Club solely because I can order online and they bring it out to my car. I'd switch to Costco in a heartbeat if that was an option.
 
I’ll add that seasonally they have outstanding value and quality clothing. I have a Kirkland jacket that is much like a north face and it was $19.99. Performance T’s and shorts for the summer. $8 for T’s I’ve had for 3-5 years and look new.
 
I’ll add that seasonally they have outstanding value and quality clothing. I have a Kirkland jacket that is much like a north face and it was $19.99. Performance T’s and shorts for the summer. $8 for T’s I’ve had for 3-5 years and look new.
Shoot, I'd never buy new clothes if it wasn't for Costco. Just yesterday came home with a pair of $5 clearance shorts and new pair of sweatpants for the cooler weather ahead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NoleATL
Likely no

we go every couple weeks and drop $100-$200, although a lot of the food we buy gets thrown away because we can't eat it all

Americans love the concept of feeling like they are part of special club and we love over-spending, so Costco has a great scheme
 
I use Sams club but they are pretty similar. Def. worth it if you buy a lot in bulk.

I do pickup orders from Sams once a week.
Post-Covid one of the biggest benefits for me has been the ground beef. Generally $2 cheaper than Fareway for the 93% lean packages.
 
Likely no

we go every couple weeks and drop $100-$200, although a lot of the food we buy gets thrown away because we can't eat it all

Americans love the concept of feeling like they are part of special club and we love over-spending, so Costco has a great scheme
Costco fees range from 65 to 130 a year. Call it 100 for easy math. HyVee charges twice as much for a jar of Rao's marinara as does Costco or Sam's. Breakeven is 10 jars of marinara. Add in everything else I posted and others have posted, and the savings is several thousand per year on consumable goods and household items. It has nothing to do with being part of a club.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BelemNole
I’m sold, I’ll give the NP the go ahead. As far as the fresh produce goes, you guys could always can or freeze what you don’t eat before it goes bad, it’s not that difficult for your wives to do. That’s the responsible thing to do, but most Americans do like to waste a lot of shit.
 
I’m sold, I’ll give the NP the go ahead. As far as the fresh produce goes, you guys could always can or freeze what you don’t eat before it goes bad, it’s not that difficult for your wives to do. That’s the responsible thing to do, but most Americans do like to waste a lot of shit.
We freeze meats/meals when deemed appropriate (especially if buying bulk meat at Costco).
Since our grocery store is 10 seconds from the gym we go to 6x a week, it doesn't make any sense to buy bulk produce and can/freeze them.
 
We freeze meats/meals when deemed appropriate (especially if buying bulk meat at Costco).
Since our grocery store is 10 seconds from the gym we go to 6x a week, it doesn't make any sense to buy bulk produce and can/freeze them.
That makes way more sense than buying them in bulk to save a few bucks and wasting half of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: texashawkeye87
That makes way more sense than buying them in bulk to save a few bucks and wasting half of it.
Why? I know the notion of waste is abhorrent but people are paid to pick and bring produce to market. The wholesale prices are the wholesale prices, and the mark up at HyVee, Costco, Sam's, etc. is the mark up. What is wrong with paying less for the produce consumed while keeping people in the agricultural industry around the world employed?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BelemNole
Why? I know the notion of waste is abhorrent but people are paid to pick and bring produce to market. The wholesale prices are the wholesale prices, and the mark up at HyVee, Costco, Sam's, etc. is the mark up. What is wrong with paying less for the produce consumed while keeping people in the agricultural industry around the world employed?
Okay bud, you justify your wastefulness anyway you want. I was just suggesting ways to avoid being wasteful.
 
Okay bud, you justify your wastefulness anyway you want. I was just suggesting ways to avoid being wasteful.
It is just being smart. Literally a pack with 5 heads of romaine lettuce at Costco is $5. HyVee probably charges $5 for two heads of romaine, maybe 3. Twice as much, at least. A bag of limes is also like $5, and HyVee charges something like 2 limes for $3. You can get a box of vine-ripened tomatoes at Costco for somewhere between $5 and $10, and the same tomatoes would cost you $30 at HyVee. It just goes on and on and on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BelemNole
It is just being smart. Literally a pack with 5 heads of romaine lettuce at Costco is $5. HyVee probably charges $5 for two heads of romaine, maybe 3. Twice as much, at least. A bag of limes is also like $5, and HyVee charges something like 2 limes for $3. You can get a box of vine-ripened tomatoes at Costco for somewhere between $5 and $10, and the same tomatoes would cost you $30 at HyVee. It just goes on and on and on.
Didn’t realize you were a poor. I hope you at least compost your waste.
 
Didn’t realize you were a poor. I hope you at least compost your waste.
That is just one aspect of Sam's/Costco. It literally adds up to thousands of dollars a year. Having a membership could be a huge swing freeing up cashflow for actual poors.
 
That is just one aspect of Sam's/Costco. It literally adds up to thousands of dollars a year. Not having a membership could actually be a huge swing in freeing up cashflow for actual poors.
I agree with the membership saving money, just don’t agree with saving a little money on produce just to throw half of the product away. That’s just me, our family grows a lot of our own produce anyway and we can or freeze what we can’t consume.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tenacious E
I agree with the membership saving money, just don’t agree with saving a little money on produce just to throw half of the product away. That’s just me, our family grows a lot of our own produce anyway and we can or freeze what we can’t consume.
I guess I look at as another car trip wasting my time and gas, when I can just knock it out all at once. I do respect the home garden game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: InsaneHawkJJP
Does Costco have a Scan and Go app similar to Sam’s Club? IMO, the app is a game changer. Sam’s is 30 minutes closer for us, but IF we had a Costco closer AND they have an app, I’d choose it over Sam’s.

I don't think they have Scan and Go like Sam's, which is definitely a game changer. I have both Sam's and Costco memberships because of my work. I like certain things about each better than the other, but if I really had to chose, I'd take Sam's over Costco. I like their produce, meats and bakery better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HawkeyeShawn
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT