ADVERTISEMENT

New Story Drew Ott appeal denied, will be going pro

That stinks but we all saw it coming. He didn't meet the criteria, those are the rules. Either he is going to be grabbed late in the draft or go as an UDFA, but someone is going to get a steal.
 
Last edited:
Why the hell did it take so long? This should have been done months ago, for his sake.

Best wishes to Drew. He has a bright future ahead of him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SDHawkDoc
Best of luck to him! Shame on the B1G and NCAA for dragging it out.
 
This was an appeal that was denied. He had already been denied previously so I don't think the NCAA is at fault for dragging their feet. He played to much, we knew he did. Good luck in the NFL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawks_Rock_12
I'm going to sit back and wait until someone in a very similar situation gets approved in less than a weeks time.

It will happen in the next few years and my guess is that individual will play for say Michigan, Ohio State, Alabama, Florida State, USC, Notre Dame, etc... you do the math

You know, the schools that when they win it is "good for college football".
 
  • Like
Reactions: HawkGem11
Why did Iowa think he had any shot at winning this? He played in like 5 games last year.
 
If I was in his shoes, I would get the records via foia and find similar situations where the NCAA has granted extra years and wait a couple of years for future cases. If it appears to be unfair, have a lawyer look at and possibly sue for money lost...
 
  • Like
Reactions: HawkGem11
Why did Iowa think he had any shot at winning this? He played in like 5 games last year.

I'm not familiar with Ott's appeal but my impression is that there were details in Ott's medical records that, when considered in connection with other similar past NCAA medical appeals, gave Drew and his crew reason to believe that he could make a credible case even if the odds were against him. I don't know what they believed those odds to be but if they were operating on even 25/30 percent chance of success it was probably worth the effort.
 
Why did Iowa think he had any shot at winning this? He played in like 5 games last year.
Appeared in 6 games actually, so more than 40% and well beyond the 30% requirement.

Iowa's argument was that his season should have been over after the dislocated elbow in week two, but instead of having surgery he decided to play through it. That resulted in only a few snaps in the next two games, followed by two Big Ten games that ended with the torn ACL. Snaps wise, quarters wise, he could have qualified, but not games wise, which is what they use.
 
If I was in his shoes, I would get the records via foia and find similar situations where the NCAA has granted extra years and wait a couple of years for future cases. If it appears to be unfair, have a lawyer look at and possibly sue for money lost...

I would imagine Drew and University staff have already done that.
Rule is bases on participation in games. If based on number of plays or quarters played, he probably met criteria but that's not way rule written. As stated in other posts, it is no real surprise
 
The denial is bogus on any reasonable, common sense, best interest of the athlete standard. Period. And I believe The Gazette, weeks ago, published info on a case or two of athletes getting even a SIXTH year who had exceeded the 30% standard. So there's that.

And, of course, anyone who thinks participating in a few plays is the same as playing the whole game is challenged on many, many levels.

Drew Ott had virtually no impact on Iowa's season, especially the Big Ten season. Add all that to the fact he never redshirted and, IMHO, you get a wrong-headed ruling by the lords of the NCAA.

I don't care if the kid played for Iowa State, Ohio State, Alabama, or wherever, he deserved his fifth year. And I'd love to see an attorney sue the NCAA in this case while Drew heads off for the NFL.

The Iowa defense will be just fine without Drew, just as it was last year. But the NCAA fumbled this one. No shock there.

I've been in favor of blowing up the NCAA for quite a while now. This is just one more brick in the wall.
 
Drew Ott post on Instagram:

mullott95
Finding out that my time has come to an end here at Iowa leaves me with a lot of people to thank. Thank you to my coaches for giving me the opportunity, believing in me, and staying with me through this whole process. Hawkeye fans, you have been amazing and thank you for the constant support. I wouldn't have been able to do any of this without my friends and family. #onceahawkalwaysahawk#TheDecision



 
Appeared in 6 games actually, so more than 40% and well beyond the 30% requirement.

Iowa's argument was that his season should have been over after the dislocated elbow in week two, but instead of having surgery he decided to play through it. That resulted in only a few snaps in the next two games, followed by two Big Ten games that ended with the torn ACL. Snaps wise, quarters wise, he could have qualified, but not games wise, which is what they use.
Right, which is why the NCAA is a f'ing JOKE. Look at the freaking specifics he hardly freaking played. F the NCAA!!!!!!!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: WORTHYWISH
It's a thankless job that the NCAA has to do. Being an arrogant, totalitarian regime takes a lot of energy and sacrifice. Thank god it's young men and women that do most of the sacrificing for them...so they can focus on building their reputation. It was an uphill battle here, I get that, but it's been awhile since I've seen anything that makes me think this organization is worth a crap. F$%& you Emmert and the high horse you ride in on.
 
He had a couple appeals. It wasn't the NCAA who drug their feet. The B1G didn't meet on it until late February.
 
Right, but why did the appeal take so long?

No idea but what difference did it make? He wasn't going to participate in combine drills or iowa spring training.

He got an answer, the correct answer in a very timely fashion. He chose to appeal it. When you do that you sort of forfeit the right to demand a speedy decision.

I hate the ncaa and all their corruption but this one they were in the right in both final decision and taking their time to research the appeal.

People are just bitching because they didn't get the answer they wanted.
 
NCAA Denies UI Appeal for Drew Ott

The University of Iowa has been notified that the medical hardship waiver appeal, filed on behalf of student-athlete Drew Ott , has been denied by the NCAA.

Coach Kirk Ferentz:

“First and foremost, really disappointed for Drew. Drew has done such a great job, and it's a tough situation. Beyond that, I am disappointed with the decision and also disappointed at the process.

Going back to Drew, I can't say enough about him as a player, team member, and just how he's handled what I think is a very challenging circumstance and situation over the last couple months. But if you look back last fall, how he handled going through some injuries and what happened after he was injured, taken out of the field of play, just how he upped his investment with our football team, upped his leadership and I didn't think that was possible but he did. He found a way to even add and contribute more, so he was a huge part of our success and really appreciative of that; all the coaches are, I know all of his teammates are, as well.

Again, I was a little bit hopeful and mildly optimistic this ruling would go the other way. It didn't. The good thing is, the comforting thing is, I know he's got a bright future and he's going to do well in whatever he chooses to do moving on.

A couple things about Drew: He's extremely smart, he's very, very talented athletically, outstanding football player. He's truly a team-first guy. And then his mental toughness is off the charts.

So needless to say, we are sorry that he won't be with us for his full senior year next year but again very, very appreciative of all he's done and certainly very, very confident he'll do extremely well in the future.

So we certainly wish him all the best, and again thank him everything he's done for our football team, our program, over the last several years.”

Drew Ott:

“It's unfortunate I didn't get my ruling to go the other way to get another year, but very thankful for the coaches and everyone here to help with my rehab and things like that. So I'm very thankful for Hawkeye Nation staying with me, and it's been a lot of fun. It's really confusing. There's just a lot of steps that they have to go through and things like that. So hopefully they can get that a little more streamlined for the next person.

Either way I'm excited to play football next year, whether it's here or with another team. I've just got to rehab and do things like that, so I'm pretty confident I'll succeed in whatever happens. Just waiting for the decision.”

Drew Ott at Iowa:

Suffered season and career ending knee injury in 29-20 win over Illinois in sixth game of the season . . . tied for sixth in the Big Ten in QB sacks (7.5) in 2014 . . . one of 13 seniors named to 2015 Leadership Group . . . one of four sophomores named to 2013 Leadership Group . . . one of seven true freshmen to see action in 2012.

In 2015:

Permanent Team Captain, defense . . . “Extra Heartbeat” Award, defense . . . Academic All-Big Ten . . . Big Ten Conference Sportsmanship Award . . . named to CoSIDA Academic All-District 6 first team . . . 2015 Preseason Honors - - One of six players in West Division selected as Big Ten Players to Watch . . . named to Nagurski Award Preseason Watch List . . . preseason second team All-Big Ten by Athlon Sports and Phil Steele . . .

Career totals include 57 solo tackles and 64 assists for a total of 121 tackles. Also had 26 tackles for loss (-122 yards), 15.5 sacks (-96 yards), one pass interception, three pass break-ups, 12 QB pressures and five forced fumbled. Also had a punt return touchdown vs. Nebraska in 2014.
 
COACH FERENTZ: Sorry we're a little bit late here. I appreciate you kind of adjusting your schedules here. Had a conference call so we had to push this back a little bit. Just a couple words. The ruling came out on Drew, obviously, a couple thoughts on that.

First and foremost, really disappointed for Drew. Drew has just done such a great job, and it's a tough situation. Beyond that, I am disappointed with the decision and also disappointed at the process, and that being said, I'll just move on.

Going back to Drew, I can't say enough about him as a player, team member, and just how he's handled what I think is a very challenging circumstance and situation over the last couple months here. But if you look back last fall, how he handled going through some injuries and what happened after he was injured, taken out of the field of play, just how he upped his investment with our football team, upped his leadership and I didn't think that was possible but he did. He found a way to even add and contribute more, so he was a huge part of our success and really appreciative of that; all the coaches are, I know all of his teammates are, as well.

Again, I was a little bit hopeful and mildly optimistic this ruling would go the other way. It didn't. The good thing is, the comforting thing is, I know he's got a bright future and he's going to do well in whatever he chooses to do moving on.

A couple things about Drew: He's extremely smart, he's very, very talented athletically, outstanding football player. He's truly a team-first guy. And then his mental toughness is off the charts and quite frankly that probably might have been his undoing in this whole circumstance. That's probably what got him in trouble in the eyes of the NCAA.

Really when you look at it, whether it's the NFL or whatever he chooses to do beyond that, to me he's got a bright future. Kind of ironic, this morning I shared an article with our football team, just about Brandon Scherff and the reason the Redskins drafted him, that was kind of a mildly controversial pick, I guess, at No. 5.

But it really got down to the message in the article from their general manager; he was trying to establish a culture with that organization. He wanted a player that he knew was going to set a great example for everybody in the Redskins organization the next decade, and to me that's what Brandon Scherff is all about, and Drew Ott is that same type of individual. I don't care if it's football, family, business, whatever environment he ends up in, that's what he's going to bring. Just a tremendous young person.

So needless to say, we are sorry that he won't be with us for his full senior year next year but again very, very appreciative of all he's done and certainly very, very confident he'll do extremely well in the future.

So we certainly wish him all the best, and again thank him for everything he's done for our football team, our program, over the last several years.

DREW OTT: It's unfortunate I didn't get the ruling to go may and get another year, but very thankful for the coaches and everyone here who helped with my rehab and things like that. So I'm very thankful for Hawkeye Nation staying with me, and it's been a lot of fun.

Q. Were you given an explanation why it took so long?
DREW OTT: No.

Q. Is there a way to ask?
DREW OTT: I don't know. I don't know who to talk to or how to ask them, but no.

Q. Did they basically say, the 30 percent rule was just hard and fast?
DREW OTT: Yeah, I mean, that's what they said the first time is just I played too many games. I mean, it's understandable.

Q. You played hurt, the elbow; did you ever think about not playing?
DREW OTT: I never thought about not playing. I mean, it was something I could work with. I had it dislocated before so I knew how to work my way around it. Wasn't too concerned about it.

Q. The Big Ten had it for the first three months, and then they forwarded the petition to the NCAA if I'm not mistaken. Do you know why that took so long for the Big Ten to forward it?
DREW OTT: I don't know. It's really confusing. There's just a lot of steps that they have to go through and things like that. So hopefully they can get that a little more streamlined for the next person.

Q. You seem to be handling it pretty well. Did you just prepare yourself for whatever happens, happens?
DREW OTT: Either way I'm excited to play football next year, whether it's here or with another team. I've just got to rehab and do things like that, so I'm pretty confident I'll succeed in whatever happens. Just waiting for the decision.

Q. Do you hit the ground running as far as the NFL?
DREW OTT: Yeah, I contacted people, got my agent lined up and things like that. Should be set.

Q. Will you visit any teams?
DREW OTT: I haven't talked to any teams yet about visits or anything like that, but will probably soon start talking to them.

COACH FERENTZ: That's one of the downsides I think of the process taking so long. The last couple weeks, the guys have been out traveling a little bit, and for somebody with health issues, that might have been helpful. Nice for it to have been expiated a little bit but that's not how it worked out.

Q. They said he played too much?
COACH FERENTZ: Basically, yeah, if you do the math on it. One of our arguments was he played around 200 snaps last year which in a normal game our guys play 70 to 80 snaps defensively. Depends how you look at it and how you cut it up. We don't sit on those meetings. I know there are hard-and-fast rules, but there are also interpretations. If you look at Case Keenum who played at Houston six years, one of the NFL people brought him to mind; the Temple basketball player; Ohio State just had a six-year receiver.

Again, I don't know all the details of the situations, but to make it all make sense is hard, but that's just kind of the way it is.

Q. It looks like the Big Ten sat on it for three months. Obviously it's more complicated than that.
COACH FERENTZ: I don't know if I'd use that terminology but it's been very cumbersome. The whole process has been cumbersome. It's not a cut-and-dry case, I guess, obviously, or else it would have been done months ago I would assume.

So I appreciate the fact that Drew got to run the race. It would have been preferable if it was expiated a little bit.

Q. Did it feel like you were getting heard?
COACH FERENTZ: It's really hard to answer that question because -- and I don't mean this in a disrespectful way. But 17 years being a head coach, I really don't understand how things happen, how things come about a lot of times and that's not my focus.

I'll qualify it by saying it's not my focus to really understand the process. Usually you just kind of deal with what comes your way. Really not unlike the satellite camps and all that other stuff. Things just happen and you roll with the flow on that stuff. But you know, I think the case was presented and heard. It just took a while.

Q. Is this something you're going to maybe bring up in a Big Ten meeting or something to maybe streamline this process, make it easier for the student athlete?
COACH FERENTZ: We went through one other appeal that comes to mind, would have been 2005 with Lee Gray. We thought he had grounds for a sixth year and the answer was negative on that, also.

It's kind of a -- it's a cloudy, cloudy topic I guess, and I'm not sure, you know, how much we're supposed to know or do know, that type of thing. You roll with the decisions that come your way. But the big thing is to get the information out there and let people that are knowledgeable make the decisions.

Q. How is your rehab going, and when do you feel you'll be able to get back to do what you do?
DREW OTT: Rehab's going great. Started running here and things like that, so things are going good for me. I should be ready to go by the season.

Q. Who called you and told you and when did it happen?
DREW OTT: Coach Ferentz told me last night. Talked to him about it.

Q. NCAA call you?
COACH FERENTZ: Actually yeah, Gary (Barta) found out prior to the event we were at and then didn't think it was appropriate really to let Drew know -- and I didn't know until actually I spoke with you last night. I wasn't aware about it at that point. I found out during the program and shared it with Drew when we got back to Iowa City.

Q. How much did you want to come back here for one more year?
DREW OTT: It would have been great. I love playing for Coach Ferentz and his staff and things like that. I've got a lot of friends on the team and would have been just a great time. So I would have really enjoyed coming back for another year.

FastScripts Transcript by ASAP Sports
 
I can't wait to read from all the blind homers about how the NCAA screwed Ott & Iowa.
 
I can't wait to read from all the blind homers about how the NCAA screwed Ott & Iowa.

While I wouldn't put it that bluntly...Drew wasn't going to get this year back. I think we're seeing the emotion come out in the thread.

Usually, 6 year guys miss 3 entire seasons - a red shirt, then two years where they might play under the 30% rule thingie in each.

Let us remember, Jess Settles got a 6th year too.

Drew...quite simply...played 4 "complete years" at Iowa. I'm more "upset" about him playing his true frosh year than this. I detest how many player/years KF has burned by giving guys what amounts to being token playing time. Scott Chandler comes to mind, and I want to say there was a WR too that effectively played 1 game mid season and lost that year because of it (the kid who went to Houston maybe?).
 
Why did Iowa think he had any shot at winning this? He played in like 5 games last year.
Because you try to do the best for your players. He didn't get to show his stuff going into this year's draft, so why not try to get him another year to improve is draft stock.
 
Thats-a-bummer.jpg
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT