Sure didn't appear to be a TD on the big screen in the stadium. I think it would have made it 3rd or 4th and 1. We had already stone walled them so could have made a difference. Just curious what it looked like on TV.
For those at home: Barkley's TD
- Thread starter StormHawk42
- Start date
It was a td. The one they should have looked at was his long run earlier that drive. Looked like his knee might've been down.
It was close but I don't think it would have been definitive enough to reverse the call. It was so close that the on field call would have stood if either way.
That was a TD great effort by SB. The knee was down and it hit hard that help him keep his balance and keep going
Until the replay booth slowed it way down and gave us a good angle, it looked like he was out.
It was td. Why didn't they reshow his knee down on that long run? Coaches needed to challenge. Learning why PSU is most hated fan base. They are whiny unrealistic babies.
No way it was a TD. The ball must pass inside the pylon as it is OOB. The ball clearly passed over the top of it. And it was equally clear his knee was down earlier on the possession. How that was not reviewed is unexplainable.
The ball must cross above the pylon, not inside the pylon. Either way it clearly did both. It was an obvious TD. The ball can hit the pylon and still be a TD.
Barkley was down back on the PSU 36 yd line. That too was obvious. How that wasn't reviewed or challenged by the Iowa coaching staff is a complete mystery. After all of the garbage that's reviewed game after game and that play is let go.
Unbelievable.
I think his knee was highly likely down, not might have been down. The lack of review was gutless. Just like he ran out of bounds a couple times on long runs and those weren't called in real time. That said, he was a beast and too much for Iowa defense. I'm sure a lot of teams will be able to keep him under 211 yards.
