ADVERTISEMENT

Iowa attorney general calls on Congress to overturn California animal welfare law

cigaretteman

HR King
May 29, 2001
77,442
58,937
113
Iowa Republican Attorney General Brenna Bird has led 16 states in a letter to U.S. congressional leadership, urging passage of legislation to prohibit states from banning animal products from outside the state that don’t meet certain confinement standards.



The Ending Agricultural Trade Suppression, or EATS, Act is aimed at California’s Proposition 12, a law regulating the conditions of livestock whose products are sold in California.


The U.S. Supreme Court rejected a challenge to Proposition 12 earlier this year. Farm groups that challenged the law argued it violated constitutional provisions banning states from regulating interstate commerce.



Iowa Republican U.S. Rep. Ashley Hinson, of Marion, introduced the bill in the House alongside fellow Iowa GOP U.S. Rep. Zach Nunn, of Bondurant. Iowa Republican U.S. Sens. Joni Ernst and Chuck Grassley co-led the Senate version of the bill.


Iowa Republican U.S. Sen. Joni Ernst and Republican U.S. Rep. Ashley Hinson, of Marion, are co-leads on the EATS bill in the House and Senate.


Opponents have taken particular aim at the pork provision in California's law. It requires that sows that give birth to pigs sold for pork in California be given at least 24 square feet of space, more than most Iowa farmers use. Birthing sows generally are held in small gestation crates without enough room to turn around.


Animal rights groups have called the practice cruel and argued it could harm public health.


California accounts for about 13 percent of the nation’s pork consumption.


Bird said Proposition 12 sets harsh regulations that increase prices for consumers, and may force many pork producers unable to comply to close their businesses.


On Iowa Politics​


Newsletter Signup
checkmark-yellow.png
Legislative & Politics News Delivered to your inbox each weekday






“California needs to keep their hands off our bacon,” Bird said in a statement. “No other state should be dictating how Iowans farm, let alone California’s bureaucrats. The EATS Act stops California’s overreach and gives state attorneys general the tools they need to fight for farmers and ranchers. We urge Congress to pass the EATS Act and stand up for livestock producers across the nation.”


Critics, including California farmers and ranchers, also argue the bill would dismantle hard-fought state laws that support farming families — invalidating thousands of state-level agriculture laws.


Straw Poll returns to Iowa State Fair​


Iowa State Fair attendees will again be able to vote for their preferred presidential candidate in the Iowa Secretary of State’s State Fair Straw Poll.


Secretary of State Paul Pate announced the return of the unscientific poll, which allows fairgoers to cast a vote for their favorite candidate in the presidential primary, as well as their favorite fair food.


The poll also encourages individuals to register to vote, update their registration and cast a ballot in upcoming elections.


The State Fair Straw Poll can be accessed on iPads at the Iowa Secretary of State booth inside the Varied Industries Building at the fairgrounds in Des Moines. Results will be available at www.sos.iowa.gov.


The poll will include 36 presidential candidates, including Democrats, Republicans and Libertarians who have been identified as candidates by their respective political parties.


Pate has invited each presidential candidate and their supporters to visit the booth and participate in the straw poll. The Secretary of State’s Office takes no official role in Iowa’s upcoming precinct caucuses, which are functions of Iowa’s political parties.


“This is just a fun way to engage with Iowa State Fairgoers and measure what the caucus results could look like in 2024,” Pate said in a statement.


Treasurer reunites Iowan with $4.5 million​


Iowa State Treasurer Roby Smith said his office has reunited an Iowan with unclaimed property valued at a record-breaking $4.5 million from the Great Iowa Treasure Hunt.


“At some point, the owner invested in over 15,000 shares in McDonald’s Corporation. When the company deemed the property unclaimed, it was turned over to the State since the owner’s last known address was in Iowa,” Smith said in a news release. “Like we do for all owners, my office sent a due diligence letter to inform them of the unclaimed funds in the Great Iowa Treasure Hunt. This prompted a claim, and the rest is history.”


The Great Iowa Treasure Hunt has returned more than $346 million to more than 951,000 individuals, according to the treasurer’s office.


Smith said it’s a great reminder to log into one’s investments periodically so the account doesn’t go dormant.


In addition to shares, forgotten checking and savings accounts, stocks, uncashed checks, life insurance policies, utility refunds and abandoned safe deposit box contents are also examples of unclaimed property that gets turned over to the state. Businesses and financial institutions are required by law to send such assets to the State Treasurer’s Office after going a certain period of time with no successful contact with the owner — generally three years.


Iowans can search for unclaimed property that may be owed to them at GreatIowaTreasureHunt.gov.

 
Maybe Brenna can convince Kim to send some National Guard troops to Cali to guarantee Iowa pork rights there!
States don’t have a right to monitor their borders for incoming products? It may not be the smartest move California has ever made but it certainly is their decision to make! Methinks Brenna is giving the wrong state “the bird” this time.
Brenna, Brenna, Brenna...
 
Just stop selling Iowa pork in California,... not a problem.
Unfortunately some can't afford to lose the business and some can't afford the requirements for their farm.

But like always the dimrats didn't think the new policy through and can't vet what they are selling now and delayed this till January.

I'm with you, let them eat their silicon valley meat at 5x the price.
 
Unfortunately some can't afford to lose the business and some can't afford the requirements for their farm.

But like always the dimrats didn't think the new policy through and can't vet what they are selling now and delayed this till January.

I'm with you, let them eat their silicon valley meat at 5x the price.

The voters of CA approved it nitwit
 
Unfortunately some can't afford to lose the business and some can't afford the requirements for their farm.

But like always the dimrats didn't think the new policy through and can't vet what they are selling now and delayed this till January.

I'm with you, let them eat their silicon valley meat at 5x the price.
I’ve met two different farmers who were all about this law. They were looking forward to meeting the requirements and charging a premium.
 
Unfortunately some can't afford to lose the business and some can't afford the requirements for their farm.
I don’t see the problem. That’s capitalism at its core. If people want pork, they’ll pay your prices. If they don’t, you lower your prices or go out of business.

I don’t understand why we go out of our way to save businesses…there will always be new ones to take their place.
 
Iowa Republican Attorney General Brenna Bird has led 16 states in a letter to U.S. congressional leadership, urging passage of legislation to prohibit states from banning animal products from outside the state that don’t meet certain confinement standards.



The Ending Agricultural Trade Suppression, or EATS, Act is aimed at California’s Proposition 12, a law regulating the conditions of livestock whose products are sold in California.


The U.S. Supreme Court rejected a challenge to Proposition 12 earlier this year. Farm groups that challenged the law argued it violated constitutional provisions banning states from regulating interstate commerce.



Iowa Republican U.S. Rep. Ashley Hinson, of Marion, introduced the bill in the House alongside fellow Iowa GOP U.S. Rep. Zach Nunn, of Bondurant. Iowa Republican U.S. Sens. Joni Ernst and Chuck Grassley co-led the Senate version of the bill.


Iowa Republican U.S. Sen. Joni Ernst and Republican U.S. Rep. Ashley Hinson, of Marion, are co-leads on the EATS bill in the House and Senate.


Opponents have taken particular aim at the pork provision in California's law. It requires that sows that give birth to pigs sold for pork in California be given at least 24 square feet of space, more than most Iowa farmers use. Birthing sows generally are held in small gestation crates without enough room to turn around.


Animal rights groups have called the practice cruel and argued it could harm public health.


California accounts for about 13 percent of the nation’s pork consumption.


Bird said Proposition 12 sets harsh regulations that increase prices for consumers, and may force many pork producers unable to comply to close their businesses.


On Iowa Politics​


Newsletter Signup
checkmark-yellow.png
Legislative & Politics News Delivered to your inbox each weekday






“California needs to keep their hands off our bacon,” Bird said in a statement. “No other state should be dictating how Iowans farm, let alone California’s bureaucrats. The EATS Act stops California’s overreach and gives state attorneys general the tools they need to fight for farmers and ranchers. We urge Congress to pass the EATS Act and stand up for livestock producers across the nation.”


Critics, including California farmers and ranchers, also argue the bill would dismantle hard-fought state laws that support farming families — invalidating thousands of state-level agriculture laws.


Straw Poll returns to Iowa State Fair​


Iowa State Fair attendees will again be able to vote for their preferred presidential candidate in the Iowa Secretary of State’s State Fair Straw Poll.


Secretary of State Paul Pate announced the return of the unscientific poll, which allows fairgoers to cast a vote for their favorite candidate in the presidential primary, as well as their favorite fair food.


The poll also encourages individuals to register to vote, update their registration and cast a ballot in upcoming elections.


The State Fair Straw Poll can be accessed on iPads at the Iowa Secretary of State booth inside the Varied Industries Building at the fairgrounds in Des Moines. Results will be available at www.sos.iowa.gov.


The poll will include 36 presidential candidates, including Democrats, Republicans and Libertarians who have been identified as candidates by their respective political parties.


Pate has invited each presidential candidate and their supporters to visit the booth and participate in the straw poll. The Secretary of State’s Office takes no official role in Iowa’s upcoming precinct caucuses, which are functions of Iowa’s political parties.


“This is just a fun way to engage with Iowa State Fairgoers and measure what the caucus results could look like in 2024,” Pate said in a statement.


Treasurer reunites Iowan with $4.5 million​


Iowa State Treasurer Roby Smith said his office has reunited an Iowan with unclaimed property valued at a record-breaking $4.5 million from the Great Iowa Treasure Hunt.


“At some point, the owner invested in over 15,000 shares in McDonald’s Corporation. When the company deemed the property unclaimed, it was turned over to the State since the owner’s last known address was in Iowa,” Smith said in a news release. “Like we do for all owners, my office sent a due diligence letter to inform them of the unclaimed funds in the Great Iowa Treasure Hunt. This prompted a claim, and the rest is history.”


The Great Iowa Treasure Hunt has returned more than $346 million to more than 951,000 individuals, according to the treasurer’s office.


Smith said it’s a great reminder to log into one’s investments periodically so the account doesn’t go dormant.


In addition to shares, forgotten checking and savings accounts, stocks, uncashed checks, life insurance policies, utility refunds and abandoned safe deposit box contents are also examples of unclaimed property that gets turned over to the state. Businesses and financial institutions are required by law to send such assets to the State Treasurer’s Office after going a certain period of time with no successful contact with the owner — generally three years.


Iowans can search for unclaimed property that may be owed to them at GreatIowaTreasureHunt.gov.

I'll give her this. At least she is pursuing the constitutional appropriate avenue for relief.
 
Unfortunately some can't afford to lose the business and some can't afford the requirements for their farm.

But like always the dimrats didn't think the new policy through and can't vet what they are selling now and delayed this till January.

I'm with you, let them eat their silicon valley meat at 5x the price.

Difficult part will be convincing major packers to segregate their product lines into California compliant and California non-compliant,.. Will only happen if producers stick together and demand it,.. Which basically means not a chance in hell.
 
It makes my head spin to see free-market/local control conservatives insist that the markets won't be able to adapt and insist on regulations that override the will of a state's voters. It's almost as though they don't actually believe in the principles they profess.
Yes, and likewise with nonfree market/national control types arguing that "but it's hard" is not a valid excuse.
 
She is afraid California won't let her visit as they don't Iowa Pork. Fat, dumb, and eating her own shit. She has a lot in common with pork
 
  • Like
Reactions: MitchLL
It's not,.. California is just being the tail attempting to wag the dog again.
And not Is that what’s on the table. I think what’s on the table is simple federal preemption.

That said, I suspect an outright state a statutory boycott of state b products might draw commerce clause scrutiny.
 
The answer is simply not to sell to California, then force them to grovel or retreat.
 
The answer is simply not to sell to California, then force them to grovel or retreat.

Yep, but very tough to do,.. Producers will give in just to have a place to sell their product and any added cost will be borne by consumers nationwide.
 
Yep, but very tough to do,.. Producers will give in just to have a place to sell their product and any added cost will be borne by consumers nationwide.
Probably. But you could also argue if production holds steady and there is a 13% drop in demand that consumers outside California win with lower costs.
 
I’m curious what percentage of pork produced in Iowa ends up in California. I would assume it’s lower than the 13% national total, but that’s just an educated guess.
 
Probably. But you could also argue if production holds steady and there is a 13% drop in demand that consumers outside California win with lower costs.

Production won't hold steady,... If major packers knowingly produce only California non-compliant product they will cut production,... You don't slice pork chops to sell on the moon.
 
State's rights! Unless we disagree with their positions. Hypocrites.

Smaller producers may benefit greatly from these standards as they'll likely be more flexible to pivot to compliance and it will command correspondingly higher market prices.

Our AG is working for her masters, Big Pork.
There isn't a single small producer left in the state of Iowa so I have no clue what you are talking about.
 
Difficult part will be convincing major packers to segregate their product lines into California compliant and California non-compliant,.. Will only happen if producers stick together and demand it,.. Which basically means not a chance in hell.

Yep, but very tough to do,.. Producers will give in just to have a place to sell their product and any added cost will be borne by consumers nationwide.
Correct on both posts. It's going to be higher prices for everyone.
 
I’ve met two different farmers who were all about this law. They were looking forward to meeting the requirements and charging a premium.
2-3 months ago one of the local TV channels interviewed a pig farmer fron either DVis or Wayne Counties...He was smilin’ And luffing about all the hub-bub over Cali’s new rules...Folks knew two ago these rules were coming...and he has already complied to the new regulations. He said the cost was minimal and he expects to expand his production to satisfy his California customers! He stated he couldn’t understand why more pig farmers were compliant....or were they just being pig-headed?
 
Iowa Republican Attorney General Brenna Bird has led 16 states in a letter to U.S. congressional leadership, urging passage of legislation to prohibit states from banning animal products from outside the state that don’t meet certain confinement standards.



The Ending Agricultural Trade Suppression, or EATS, Act is aimed at California’s Proposition 12, a law regulating the conditions of livestock whose products are sold in California.


The U.S. Supreme Court rejected a challenge to Proposition 12 earlier this year. Farm groups that challenged the law argued it violated constitutional provisions banning states from regulating interstate commerce.



Iowa Republican U.S. Rep. Ashley Hinson, of Marion, introduced the bill in the House alongside fellow Iowa GOP U.S. Rep. Zach Nunn, of Bondurant. Iowa Republican U.S. Sens. Joni Ernst and Chuck Grassley co-led the Senate version of the bill.


Iowa Republican U.S. Sen. Joni Ernst and Republican U.S. Rep. Ashley Hinson, of Marion, are co-leads on the EATS bill in the House and Senate.


Opponents have taken particular aim at the pork provision in California's law. It requires that sows that give birth to pigs sold for pork in California be given at least 24 square feet of space, more than most Iowa farmers use. Birthing sows generally are held in small gestation crates without enough room to turn around.


Animal rights groups have called the practice cruel and argued it could harm public health.


California accounts for about 13 percent of the nation’s pork consumption.


Bird said Proposition 12 sets harsh regulations that increase prices for consumers, and may force many pork producers unable to comply to close their businesses.


On Iowa Politics​


Newsletter Signup
checkmark-yellow.png
Legislative & Politics News Delivered to your inbox each weekday






“California needs to keep their hands off our bacon,” Bird said in a statement. “No other state should be dictating how Iowans farm, let alone California’s bureaucrats. The EATS Act stops California’s overreach and gives state attorneys general the tools they need to fight for farmers and ranchers. We urge Congress to pass the EATS Act and stand up for livestock producers across the nation.”


Critics, including California farmers and ranchers, also argue the bill would dismantle hard-fought state laws that support farming families — invalidating thousands of state-level agriculture laws.


Straw Poll returns to Iowa State Fair​


Iowa State Fair attendees will again be able to vote for their preferred presidential candidate in the Iowa Secretary of State’s State Fair Straw Poll.


Secretary of State Paul Pate announced the return of the unscientific poll, which allows fairgoers to cast a vote for their favorite candidate in the presidential primary, as well as their favorite fair food.


The poll also encourages individuals to register to vote, update their registration and cast a ballot in upcoming elections.


The State Fair Straw Poll can be accessed on iPads at the Iowa Secretary of State booth inside the Varied Industries Building at the fairgrounds in Des Moines. Results will be available at www.sos.iowa.gov.


The poll will include 36 presidential candidates, including Democrats, Republicans and Libertarians who have been identified as candidates by their respective political parties.


Pate has invited each presidential candidate and their supporters to visit the booth and participate in the straw poll. The Secretary of State’s Office takes no official role in Iowa’s upcoming precinct caucuses, which are functions of Iowa’s political parties.


“This is just a fun way to engage with Iowa State Fairgoers and measure what the caucus results could look like in 2024,” Pate said in a statement.


Treasurer reunites Iowan with $4.5 million​


Iowa State Treasurer Roby Smith said his office has reunited an Iowan with unclaimed property valued at a record-breaking $4.5 million from the Great Iowa Treasure Hunt.


“At some point, the owner invested in over 15,000 shares in McDonald’s Corporation. When the company deemed the property unclaimed, it was turned over to the State since the owner’s last known address was in Iowa,” Smith said in a news release. “Like we do for all owners, my office sent a due diligence letter to inform them of the unclaimed funds in the Great Iowa Treasure Hunt. This prompted a claim, and the rest is history.”


The Great Iowa Treasure Hunt has returned more than $346 million to more than 951,000 individuals, according to the treasurer’s office.


Smith said it’s a great reminder to log into one’s investments periodically so the account doesn’t go dormant.


In addition to shares, forgotten checking and savings accounts, stocks, uncashed checks, life insurance policies, utility refunds and abandoned safe deposit box contents are also examples of unclaimed property that gets turned over to the state. Businesses and financial institutions are required by law to send such assets to the State Treasurer’s Office after going a certain period of time with no successful contact with the owner — generally three years.


Iowans can search for unclaimed property that may be owed to them at GreatIowaTreasureHunt.gov.


This is an example of why I'm barely a Republican.
 
Just watch.. Iowa Republicans will beg for some grant or subsidies to compensate pork producers.

Hopefully the USDA tells em to fvck off!
 
Pork producers will be short term subsidized by the packers, who will be compensated by the consumer...
 
two rather humorous notes on this letter...
1. Taking into account the house seats of the signators, they have 109 votes assuming they got all of them. I'd say they have some work to do.
2. While IA is of course far and away the most significant hog producing state, they only got 5 of the top 10, and none of 2, 3, or 4.

Also, yet one more reason that AG's shouldn't be elected.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cigaretteman
I'm with you, let them eat their silicon valley meat at 5x the price.
I don't know what Iowa prices are (or what a good/normal price is for pork) but I see pork chops selling for $3.99/lb or $4.99/lb at grocery stores here in SoCal.

Again, I don't know if that's pricey or not.
 
And not Is that what’s on the table. I think what’s on the table is simple federal preemption.

That said, I suspect an outright state a statutory boycott of state b products might draw commerce clause scrutiny.
Are you saying it might be illegal for Iowa to refuse to sell California marijuana because of the commerce clause?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mustang_hawk
Are you saying it might be illegal for Iowa to refuse to sell California marijuana because of the commerce clause?
No, I'm saying IA probably couldn't prohibit the cross IA border distribution of mj produced in CA, solely because it's been produced in CA.
 
No, I'm saying IA probably couldn't prohibit the cross IA border distribution of mj produced in CA, solely because it's been produced in CA.
But CA isn't prohibiting the cross border distribution of IA pork, they just put regulations on the pork CA can sell. If an Iowa company produces pork that meets the regulations then CA will allow it to be sold in their state.
 
But CA isn't prohibiting the cross border distribution of IA pork, they just put regulations on the pork CA can sell. If an Iowa company produces pork that meets the regulations then CA will allow it to be sold in their state.
understand that completely, and that it was upheld. AG is saying, 'preempt that'. I'm saying cant discriminate in commerce SOLELY based on state of origin
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT