ADVERTISEMENT

Opinion Netanyahu is picking a fight with Israel’s best friend: Joe Biden

cigaretteman

HR King
May 29, 2001
77,442
58,935
113
All the way back in 2019, Benjamin Netanyahu became Israel’s longest-serving prime minister. In the past year, since assuming his nation’s highest office for the third time, he has cemented his reputation as Israel’s worst prime minister. And now, by picking a needless and reckless fight with President Biden, Israel’s closet ally, he is only compounding the damage that he is doing to his own country.


Need something to talk about? Text us for thought-provoking opinions that can break any awkward silence.

A quick recap for those who have not been watching the long-running “Bibi” show closely: Netanyahu returned to the prime minister’s office last December while battling corruption charges. In fact, the case against him continues today. To win power, he made common cause with ultraright parties led by the likes of Itamar Ben Gvir, who had been previously convicted of supporting a terrorist organization, and Bezalel Smotrich, a self-described “fascist homophobe.”
Once in office, Netanyahu immediately launched an effort to neuter Israel’s Supreme Court, which was widely seen as an attempt by him to escape his criminal case and by his far-right allies to expand West Bank settlements and to impose their religious agenda on secular Israelis. The result was massive protests and a refusal by many military reservists to serve, leading Israeli intelligence to warn Netanyahu last summer that Israel’s deterrence against its enemies was eroding.



Netanyahu ignored those general warnings — as well as more specific information that Israeli intelligence had obtained about an ambitious Hamas plan to attack Israel. Instead, he continued a cynical policy of supporting Qatari payments to Hamas to “buy quiet” and to foster divisions among Palestinians so as to stymie the emergence of a Palestinian state.


The bankruptcy of Bibi’s policy was painfully revealed on Oct. 7 when Israel suffered the worst one-day attack in its history. Netanyahu allowed this calamity to occur and was slow to respond even as Hamas terrorists were killing 1,200 Israelis and kidnapping hundreds more. Now he seems to be intent on compounding the damage by picking a fight with America’s ardently pro-Zionist president.
Biden has resisted growing criticism of Israel among Democrats (in one recent survey, only 18 percent of Democrats and Democratic-leaning respondents said Israel was taking the right approach in Gaza) to staunchly support the Jewish state. Biden has resisted calls by leading Democrats to attach conditions, such as reducing civilian casualties in Gaza and ending the expansion of West Bank settlements, on aid to Israel. The administration just bypassed Congress to send Israel 14,000 rounds of tank ammunition, and it just vetoed a U.N. Security Council resolution (supported by 13 of 15 Security Council members) demanding an immediate Israeli cease-fire.












While publicly backing Israel, Biden has tried to work behind the scenes to convince Netanyahu to be more discriminate in the use of firepower in Gaza, to curb settler violence in the West Bank and to plan for the Palestinian Authority (PA) to take charge of Gaza after Hamas is defeated. Yet Netanyahu doesn’t seem to be listening.

 
Last week, Biden’s frustration broke into public view. Speaking at a campaign fundraiser, the president stressed that he would provide “Israel what they need to defend themselves and to finish the job” against Hamas but also noted, accurately, that Israel is “starting to lose” international support because of its “indiscriminate bombing.” He went on to say that Netanyahu needs to “strengthen” the PA. “You cannot say there’s no Palestinian state at all in the future.”
Instead of accepting this constructive critique from a friend, Netanyahu chose to strike back publicly against Biden. He released a video rejecting Biden’s call for the Palestinian Authority to rule in Gaza. “I will not allow Israel to repeat the mistake of Oslo,” he said, referring to the 1993 Oslo accords that created the Palestinian Authority. “Gaza will be neither Hamastan nor Fatahstan.”



As with so much of what Netanyahu says, this statement bears little relation to reality. Fatah — the ruling party in the PA — is in no way comparable to Hamas. PA security forces work every day with Israeli security forces to prevent attacks on Israel. The problem is that Netanyahu, while forced to accept the Oslo process, has done everything in his power to undermine the PA and prevent the emergence of a viable Palestinian state.
No wonder nearly half of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank support Hamas: They have seen their hopes of statehood dashed as right-wing Israeli governments continue to expand settlements in the West Bank and to resist making any concessions to the Palestinians. If Israel winds up the war against Hamas by simply reoccupying Gaza, as now seems likely, it will be giving birth to a new generation of anti-Israel militants. That is what Biden is warning against. As he has made clear, there is no realistic alternative to a two-state solution.
Netanyahu is ignoring Biden’s wise words of counsel because his coalition allies are anxious to annex the West Bank and opposed to the creation of a Palestinian state. Bibi plainly hopes to stay in office by promising to block a two-state solution, no matter how much damage that does to Israel’s long-term security interests or its alliance with the United States.



“During World War II, Churchill would often howl over policy differences with FDR but never in public. Netanyahu is no Churchill,” Robert Satloff, executive director of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, told me. “Biden may be the most Zionist president in American history and Netanyahu should be kissing his a--, not kicking it.”
Netanyahu may soon learn the cost of alienating Israel’s best friend in the world. If Bibi wants time for the Israel Defense Forces to continue destroying Hamas — a process that is likely to take months — he needs to keep U.S. support. As previous presidents have done in recent decades, Biden could tell Israel to stop its offensive, whether the IDF has attained its military objectives or not. He could stop vetoing U.N. Security Council resolutions critical of Israel or introduce a U.S. resolution that balances criticism of Hamas with criticism of Israel. He can withhold U.S. aid — as he has already done with 20,000 assault rifles that, the administration fears, could be used by violent settlers in the West Bank. Biden can also signal his displeasure by simply not making a major effort to normalize relations between Israel and Saudi Arabia, knowing that Riyadh’s price for a deal is a U.S. security guarantee.
Unfortunately, Netanyahu continues to place his political interests above Israel’s security interests. His past year in office has incinerated the reputation he tried to build over his previous decades in politics as a strong leader who kept Israel safe. He is now intensely unpopular but still clinging desperately to power even as the cost of his misrule continues to accumulate.
 
That's a nice & wonderful narrative that ignores the real world.

The real world isn't about a 2 state solution, it's about the Palestinians taking over Israel, starting with Jerusalem.

The real world is about destroying all Jews in the region.

The real world is the surprise of the size and intensity of anti-Israel protestors in the US.

Biden isn't trying to look forward to Bibi's successor or Hamas' successor or how things can be better in the future. Biden is trying to walk a political tightrope so he can get re-elected, and the opposing sides (in the US) both tend to vote Democrat. Biden is doing what politicians do, and that's keeping power. IF he can spin it as being good for everyone, that's even better. There hasn't been peace between the Jews and their neighbors in the Middle East for thousands of years. Arrogance is ignoring that fact.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT