ADVERTISEMENT

Solar panels, worth it?

How old is your home?
Built in ‘79…the electrical panel was “ original” and out-dated.. we knew full well it would someday need to be replaced..took the opportunity to do it now because of federal deductibility of the “total cost” involved in the solar expense…… might as well deduct a goodly portion of the new panel..
 
Last edited:
Built in ‘79…the electrical panel was “ original” and out-dated.. we knew full well it would someday need to be replaced

Most ~50 yr old homes would not have enough electrical service (total amps) to supply energy for today's stuff.
So, you're 100% correct here - part of that is simply needed upgrade, and you paid a little more for the solar capability. Generally, most of your install/upgrade cost is labor, not materials, so you paid a fairly modest hike on materials here.

If you do your homework on solar, payoffs these days for positive ROI is <10 yrs.
That does not mean there aren't solar companies out there "overselling" systems that are bad systems for way more money than they are worth, pushing their "$0 out of pocket for you" stuff. The minute I hear "$0 cost for you", I am skeptical, and want to verify all of their numbers, assumptions, and quality of the panel systems against an install that I would pay out of pocket for. There are some installers who might swing you a pretty good deal and loan for $0 out of pocket - I would bet that many (or most of those) are not "good deals", though.
 
We just had 12 panels put on our roof. We paid cash, and it was $12,800. We did some electrical work on the side that took about $1200 or so off the estimate. We will get $4000 back from the Feds, assuming Trump doesn't f**k that up, but I doubt it. He can't remove the credits without Congress, and lots and lots of red voters would be pissed. Solar panels are all over the place these days. The told us about 7 years to recover the costs, but I assume it will be 8. Sucky time of the year to put the panels on, but we should really crank it up in the Spring and Summer. The excess goes back to MidAmerican as credits we can use during the lower producing months.
What electrical work did you have to do and how old is your home that you put them on if you don't mind me asking.
 
And, in case you didn't read what's been posted several times, panels protect your shingles, so you will get longer lifespan out of them.
Which means "access" is pretty much a moot point.

I don't need to protect my shingles,.. I need to be able to maintain them.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: RileyHawk
You truly are a phucking clown,.. Develop a personality, find some friends.
 
WTF are you even talking about?

The "shingle maintenance" you claim you need access for.

Do you not remember what you posted, already? Roof shingles are not a "maintenance" item.
You replace your roof when they are "used up". Solar panels actually extend the lifespan of your shingles, and protect them from hail damage. That's been posted for you already, and you can ask any roofer about it, because that is what they will tell you.
 
Last I looked the only way it worked from a financial standpoint is if you have a farm and/or business nearby and put the solar on them then run the lines to your personal property. But that might be frowned upon.

I have zero idea the cost of this but I probably would pay $200,000 for Solar Roof | Tesla . If it really lasted 25 years and can with stand typhoons. I hate getting generators out all the damn time.
 
What kind of costs would the city stick me with?
Possible a net metering charge? I think it's a one time fee depending if you have a single phase or a three phase service. My specific town is a charge of up to 25kw of single phase for $825 or over 25kw three phase for $1,100
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrunoMars420
Possible a net metering charge? I think it's a one time fee depending if you have a single phase or a three phase service. My specific town is a charge of up to 25kw of single phase for $825 or over 25kw three phase for $1,100
That’s a new one on me. WTH?
 
Possible a net metering charge? I think it's a one time fee depending if you have a single phase or a three phase service. My specific town is a charge of up to 25kw of single phase for $825 or over 25kw three phase for $1,100
Here, that is not a “city” charge though…it’s a charge made by the provider (Mid-America in my case) for a “two-way” meter to be installed..
Now our panel solar provider took care of everything… they agreed to todo the electrical update, install the new meter and “co-ordinate” everything with the local utility provider and we wrote them 3 checks… it took them maybe 3-4 months to get ALL the work done…from signing the contract to start generating our own power.
 
What electrical work did you have to do and how old is your home that you put them on if you don't mind me asking.
When we signed the contract it had an allowance with Shay Electric here in IC to do the electrical work. As a side project I had them come out to inspect the fuse box, they didn't say replace it..., but it's 50+ years old. so to me it was time to do it while other stuff was going on, versus pay more money a few years down the line. And, less disruption and fewer times I needed to be here at the house and off work. They ended up doing a bunch of the prep work for the solar install when they replaced the fuse box about a month before the panels went on. They also made two fixes to some work a contractor screwed up when we had a kitchen remodel done 10 years ago. Our electrical allowance was lower when we paid for he panels, but we had wound up just paying Shay anyway.
 
Last I looked the only way it worked from a financial standpoint is if you have a farm and/or business nearby and put the solar on them then run the lines to your personal property.
If you have zero south facing roof facets.

Were my house oriented 180 degrees from what it is, I'd have a giant facet I could put 40 panels on that would run my house and pay me back several hundred a month from the utility.

No idea when you looked at panel costs, etc, but probably should learn how to run the numbers...
 
Here, that is not a “city” charge though…it’s a charge made by the provider (Mid-America in my case) for a “two-way” meter to be installed..
Now our panel solar provider took care of everything… they agreed to todo the electrical update, install the new meter and “co-ordinate” everything with the local utility provider and we wrote them 3 checks… it took them maybe 3-4 months to get ALL the work done…from signing the contract to start generating our own power.
It is a city charge since the city's electrical department that handles that portion of it. It is listed in our city's list of city fees.
 
….sooooo, totally forgot about this thread and I’m now pretty buzzed up lol. @BrunoMars420 let me know what questions you have and I’ll do my best to answer.
Essentially what I posted in the first OP and if it’s worth it? I’ll probably be paying it off way earlier then the 25 year loan fwiw but the $0 down then paying basically what I’m paying now to the utility company to them after they finance us for “X” amount seems like a no brainer in theory. I still haven’t seen the full breakdown of the numbers and the actual type of panels but on the face of it, it seems dumb not to do it.

Just was wondering your thought on this approach from a solar company and if it makes sense to do it now before the new administration comes in?
 
  • Like
Reactions: beanerhawk
Essentially what I posted in the first OP and if it’s worth it? I’ll probably be paying it off way earlier then the 25 year loan fwiw but the $0 down then paying basically what I’m paying now to the utility company to them after they finance us for “X” amount seems like a no brainer in theory. I still haven’t seen the full breakdown of the numbers and the actual type of panels but on the face of it, it seems dumb not to do it.

Just was wondering your thought on this approach from a solar company and if it makes sense to do it now before the new administration comes in?
They have been at our house a lot this year also basically telling me the house sets up perfectly for it with the direction of my house and size of the roof on the back of our house. Problem is like you, I have no idea what I'm doing and what I've found online to read isn't very helpful. It's annoying.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrunoMars420
@SolarHawk

I have a south facing roof so it’s perfect. Spoke to a person on this and basically he said that there is $0 down and we just get a loan through the company and pay them on the loan over 25 years at a rate of 6.99%. Essentially it would be the same amount we are paying now (according to him, haven’t seen the actual numbers) energy wise for the loan but the big kicker is that these panels supposedly add 4-12% value to your home.

Still waiting on the breakdown of the numbers and break even point but wanted to get your thoughts on what I’m being sold. You think it would be worth it with this minimal info I gave you?
No
 
So you are basically committing to living in the same house for 25 years...

Uh, no.

You pay off the loan when you sell the home.
Panels then belong, outright, to the new buyer.

Out here, at least, homes w/ panels get higher resale, because most buyers view it as a benefit to not have an electric utility bill for much of the year. If the panels are near "end of life", you may not get much benefit, since the new buyer would need to replace them when they no longer produce as much electricity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3boysmom
Essentially what I posted in the first OP and if it’s worth it? I’ll probably be paying it off way earlier then the 25 year loan fwiw but the $0 down then paying basically what I’m paying now to the utility company to them after they finance us for “X” amount seems like a no brainer in theory. I still haven’t seen the full breakdown of the numbers and the actual type of panels but on the face of it, it seems dumb not to do it.

Just was wondering your thought on this approach from a solar company and if it makes sense to do it now before the new administration comes in?
What are the financing terms and who is the bank? The dirty secret in solar is upfront finance fees the banks charge. They can get up into the 40% range depending on your credit and loan terms. Also, what PPW are they selling it to you at?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joes Place
What are the financing terms and who is the bank? The dirty secret in solar is upfront finance fees the banks charge. They can get up into the 40% range depending on your credit and loan terms. Also, what PPW are they selling it to you at?
He just gave a high level rundown of everything but nothing concrete. I have a meeting Thursday to go over the numbers but said something about our utility company charging 1 to 1 energy and that will be going up soon. He mentioned a 6.99% loan for 25 yrs and not sure of the bank yet. I work with financial contracts and deal with a lot of financing in my job so I’ll have all the dirty little secrets when I look them over.
 
He just gave a high level rundown of everything but nothing concrete. I have a meeting Thursday to go over the numbers but said something about our utility company charging 1 to 1 energy and that will be going up soon. He mentioned a 6.99% loan for 25 yrs and not sure of the bank yet. I work with financial contracts and deal with a lot of financing in my job so I’ll have all the dirty little secrets when I look them over.
Utility rates on average increase at least 4% every year. Usually more. The 1 to 1 refers to net metering which means the utility has to buy the power you export at the same rate they sell it to you. Republicans are constantly trying to take this away. Almost did here in Florida, but for some unknown reason DeSantis vetoed it(Thank God). Last thing I will tell you, do not accept the price they present you. The most disgusting part of this industry is the sales commissions. I'm not joking when I say I've seen over $20k commission on a $60k total sale contract. If you would like me to review the proposal they give you before you make a decision I would be more than happy to do so.
 
Utility rates on average increase at least 4% every year. Usually more. The 1 to 1 refers to net metering which means the utility has to buy the power you export at the same rate they sell it to you. Republicans are constantly trying to take this away. Almost did here in Florida, but for some unknown reason DeSantis vetoed it(Thank God). Last thing I will tell you, do not accept the price they present you. The most disgusting part of this industry is the sales commissions. I'm not joking when I say I've seen over $20k commission on a $60k total sale contract. If you would like me to review the proposal they give you before you make a decision I would be more than happy to do so.
Thank you!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SolarHawk
Utility rates on average increase at least 4% every year. Usually more. The 1 to 1 refers to net metering which means the utility has to buy the power you export at the same rate they sell it to you. Republicans are constantly trying to take this away. Almost did here in Florida, but for some unknown reason DeSantis vetoed it(Thank God). Last thing I will tell you, do not accept the price they present you. The most disgusting part of this industry is the sales commissions. I'm not joking when I say I've seen over $20k commission on a $60k total sale contract. If you would like me to review the proposal they give you before you make a decision I would be more than happy to do so.
So it came out to $36,500 for 22 seg 410w premium black in black panels. With the 30% tax credit it is $25,600ish on a 25 year loan (I will pay it off way sooner) at 6.99% through Dividend Financing and payments $185. Currently Midamerican charges .13 kWh and raising it to .21-.23 kWh next year. My annual usage is aroun 13,000 kWh.

Seems like a no brainer with how it’s laid out and putting up $0. What am I missing here @SolarHawk
 
After some more maths and research, it would take me around 12ish years or so to recoup my money. Sales guy was dishonest on the rate increase (surprise). Maybe in the future but right now it doesn’t make financial sense unless I want to use my funds upfront to pay it off immediately
 
After some more maths and research, it would take me around 12ish years or so to recoup my money. Sales guy was dishonest on the rate increase (surprise). Maybe in the future but right now it doesn’t make financial sense unless I want to use my funds upfront to pay it off immediately
8-10 yrs is not a bad ROI on a 25-30 yr asset.

12 still makes sense, as you still have the asset to convey to a new seller.
If the monthly cash flow is a push, I'd still consider it, but I'd shop around first to look for better deals, anyway.
 
I see them on numerous municipal buildings so I’d say no

Why it seem like only yesterday...

A failed multi-million dollar transit experiment in Cedar Rapids is now sitting in a scrap yard. Ten years ago, the city of Cedar Rapids purchased nine electric buses for nearly $3 million. But, the battery powered vehicles didn’t run far without dying in the cold weather. Last week, the city sold the buses at auction for $30,000.

C.J. Bacon placed the winning bid. “It is kind of weird, a penny on the dollar. I’d like to buy stuff that way all day,” Bacon said. Bacon, and his son Charles, run a salvage operation in Hopkinton. They originally planned to tear the buses apart for scrap and spare parts, but have recently heard from people who may want to purchase the vehicles and see if they can get them running again.

“If we can’t find a buyer, they’ll be scrapped,” Charles Bacon said. The money for the electric bus program came from federal and utility company grants. Some of the buses have just 6,000 miles on the odometer.
 
After some more maths and research, it would take me around 12ish years or so to recoup my money. Sales guy was dishonest on the rate increase (surprise). Maybe in the future but right now it doesn’t make financial sense unless I want to use my funds upfront to pay it off immediately
I was gonna say a nearly 100% increase on utility rate is unheard of. You can count on average 4-6% increase year over year. Additionally, there are two ways to look at solar. People tend to look at ROI, however the true benefit of solar is lowering your energy bill immediately and also knowing what you should expect to spend each month assuming the system is sized correctly. Lastly, salespeople are liars and I would shop around for other companies and see what they present to you.
 
So it came out to $36,500 for 22 seg 410w premium black in black panels. With the 30% tax credit it is $25,600ish on a 25 year loan (I will pay it off way sooner) at 6.99% through Dividend Financing and payments $185. Currently Midamerican charges .13 kWh and raising it to .21-.23 kWh next year. My annual usage is aroun 13,000 kWh.

Seems like a no brainer with how it’s laid out and putting up $0. What am I missing here @SolarHawk
That’s just over $4/watt. If you shop around you can likely get closer to $3/watt or maybe slightly under before tax credits. That would drop the $36,500 price closer to $27,000. At that point securing your own financing would likely make sense over taking theirs even if you can’t get the same rate.

We had a 15.3kw system installed last year for $43,500 before tax credit, around $30,500 after the 30% credit. This didn’t include financing as we paid cash. We’re on pace for the system to pay for itself in somewhere around 7 years.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT