I basically agree, but Tyler did say he should have caught it because it did hit him in the hands. I recognize that he’s expected to say that so as not to throw his QB under the bus, but he presumably believes it at least to some degree.
Oh, I played football. Maybe you did too. If you did...I'm betting you were terrible and kind of a pussy.
No, that was a bad throw. The QB is to blame here. I know you weren't addressing me, but I enjoy calling out posters when they reply like you did.
Yep....bad throw. Bad throws can be caught....and that pass should have been caught, especially under the circumstances.No, that was a bad throw. The QB is to blame here. I know you weren't addressing me, but I enjoy calling out posters when they reply like you did.
That is kind of throw you get out of backup quality QB.
Of course he think that, he's an elite competitor and he's taking one for the team as any good dude would do. Duh.
Very rarely is that the case, but this room seems to be filled with people who don't know much about playing football. Which is fine, no skin off my back.
Yeah maybe Indy should've played better D the possession before not allowing a TD and then they wouldn't have been in that 4th down situation? See, it does go both ways and not calling out any posters yet you can play that game all day long. Yep, in the hands yet its 50% on Tyler and 50% QB, and yes, VERY tough situation to be tossed into late in a pressure game in the 4th q, they were riding the Taylor horse and suddenly went pass, maybe that should've been the 3rd down call...
Don't threaten me asshole...you're wasting your time. I'm not concerned about internet tough guys.
Yeah, I replayed that frame by frame. A professional should catch that ball. He had turned to face it. Once he did that, I would say it wasn't even off beyond his side. He simply pulled his hands away too early.
I'm not threatening you at all. I was just describing to you the person you were calling a pussy.
Good grief man....just stop. You threatened me...I called you out on it...and I asked you not to do that. Trying to be a tough guy and attempting to threaten and intimidate (especially on the internet) is a horrible quality to have.
Incorrect. I did not threaten you. I was informing you that the person you called a pussy is far from it. We are done here. You either get it or you don't. And you don't.
Incorrect. I'm quoting you now...."fair warning". Sure sounds like a threat to me....especially when put into context of your other statements in the same post. You're right...we are done here. You wont threaten or try to intimidate me again.
Trying to be the peacemaker here.
You must have an "interesting" definition of snowflake. Way to jump in out of nowhere and make such a solid contribution.
Catchable, but to his left, away from the goal line. Minshew does a lot of good things, but he is not very accurate when he needs to be.
“
Oh you played football and you made every tackle, never missed a tackle, or a block, or never fumbled, or dropped a pass or threw a poor pass.
Yeah, I don't get the "drop" angle. It was a shitty pass behind him.
Exactly. No one is debating that the pass should have been thrown better....but it doesn't change the fact that it was a catchable ball....and he should have made the catch.
Good grief....I played high school football....I'm not an NFL RB. Of course I missed tackles, and dropped a pass or two (several, I'm sure). I'm not debating that the pass was poorly thrown! I'm stating my strong opinion that the ball was in fact catchable....and especially given the circumstances...and especially considering he is an NFL RB....he should have caught that pass. He knows it...and he stated that he should have made the play. He's not making excuses....and you should stop making excuses for a dropped pass that should have been caught.
Short pass....hit him in both hands....he wasn't diving for the ball....he wasn't getting hit by a defender while trying to make the catch...it was a big play at 4th and 1 that needed to made...he's in the NFL trying to retain a spot on the roster to build a career.....HE SHOULD HAVE MADE THE CATCH. He didn't, and I'm sure he is/was devastated because he knows he should have made the play. He "man'd up" and admitted it was on him. I respect his honesty, and I hope he continues to grow a a career of success in the NFL.
