ADVERTISEMENT

Aaron Nagao in the Portal

Come on, guy. It’s not like I was saying this way gives them a chance to recruit as well as PSU, let alone pass them. It’s simply what I think is the best way moving forward to try to stay competitive with them.

There are plenty of people out there with the “chip on the shoulder mindset” that don’t want to just go to the clear #1 destination and “blend” in. Those are the guys Iowa needs to identify early on and build a relationship with.

They wouldn’t just want to beat the PSU team, but also beat that top guy at PSU. Maybe someone like Austin O’Connor. I know it isn’t an easy thing to do or close to a perfect system, but I do think it’s the best option for now…
Fair enough, no malice intended. I happen to believe a possible downside to that mindset, though, is the added pressure to win for something other than just yourself. Tougher to wrestle “free” in that mindset, IMO.

The other critical component, besides psychology, is maintaining physical health.
 
Yeah, the fact that a 133lber would have Spencer, Desanto, and Woods to roll around with, Iowa likely being the biggest pay day, as well as being able to wrestle in front of the biggest fan base, and he said “nah, I’m good”, this has to be an indictment on TnT’s lack of recent tournament success outside of Spencer to point to.
I think this is spot on. Recruits want to get better and TnT's recent track record is not flattering to say the least. Marinelli, Kemerer, Warner, Cass, and even Spencer all failed to continue an upward trajectory that resulted in NCAA titles. Time will tell if it continues with Woods and Kennedy. Realistically, what evidence does a top recruit have TODAY to choose TnT and Iowa over others? Those gold medals and world titles only work so long for a coach....results matter.
 
It’s simply what I think is the best way moving forward to try to stay competitive with them.
Is this the same or similar advice to that you gave to the MSU program before following Metcalf and becoming an Iowa supporter?

Like @herkcy, would you want @bnicolls to be your messenger boy to Iowa's Athletic Department and wrestling coaches?

Just kidding guys. It's times like these that having some sense of humor and even laughing at the circumstances can help one pull thru darker times. Even @IRONBIRD gets this, and he's probably not the sharpest knife in the drawer.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: el dub and fmo
A little bitter aren't you? Member since 2012, 860 plus posts. Probably posted a few in 2020 and 2021.

Not bitter at all. Just curious why you choose to spend your time in a rivals board starting arguments. What are you hoping to get out of this that you don’t get on your own board?
 
So when the chant goes up... "WE ARE" !!!........ do we respond by yelling " BOUGHT NOT TAUGHT " ....or do we respond with yelling " POACHED NOT COACHED " ??????????????
I think you need a response that's only two syllables. And the 2nd syllable should rhyme with 'state.' Might I suggest,

"I-RATE!!!"​
That would seem to best capture the current sentiment.
 
The sport is taking a nasty turn at this point. 1 team just cashing in all top recruits, locking up a title before season even begins. Great way to grow the sport.
Iowa had their day, was that bad for growing the sport? Wrestling is a niche sport which we love that's not that popular with the general sports crowd.
It's always been this day. It might have been even more popular back when the traditional Olympic sports were much more popular.
 
No, I’m not stupid enough to fall for that “I’m just going there to serve God bullshit”. Be honest kid, you’re going there to win a team title and get paid, even if you could have squeezed more out of Iowa. The next reason is to get into your freestyle club. You volunteer at church, charity’s, and go on mission trips to serve God, not jump on board the most talented college wrestling team that has ever been assembled. Finally, if you do like me or other hawk fans, then go back to your PSU board, nobody invited you assholes to OUR fan board!
His beliefs and his decision are his decision. You would think a guy with a handle like you would appreciate his freedom to express himself and make up his own mind.
 
Last edited:
Not even close. They were the prohibitive favorite but PSU could probably have a top wrestler get injured next year and still win by 30 points over the field.

With the team PSU has on paper right now they have a chance to take out 170 while the rest of the field struggles to get to 100 team points. They will be ranked top 5 at 8 weights when the season starts, heck most of them top 3.
Would like to see their projected lineup with rankings and accolades.
 
Not bitter at all. Just curious why you choose to spend your time in a rivals board starting arguments. What are you hoping to get out of this that you don’t get on your own board?
It's called negative reinforcement. He isn't able to partake on his own forum so he comes here to get a rise out of people. Pretty basic human behavior - for deviants.
 
Anyone who doesn’t have nitlion6 on ignore is a glutton fur punishment. My list is growing as I added two more “I come in peace” nitwits yesterday. These PSU agitators have ruined what used to be a good experience on HR talking about the sport I’ve enjoyed so much over the years. I encourage more of you to employ the 3 strikes you’re on ignore principle.
 
Is this the same or similar advice to that you gave to the MSU program before following Metcalf and becoming an Iowa supporter?

Like @herkcy, would you want @bnicolls to be your messenger boy to Iowa's Athletic Department and wrestling coaches?

Just kidding guys. It's times like these that having some sense of humor and even laughing at the circumstances can help one pull thru darker times. Even @IRONBIRD gets this, and he's probably not the sharpest knife in the drawer.
Wow, you have pretty much shed the fake skin of trying to be somewhat friendly on here and have gone FULL DICK MODE.

Much like starting with the "with all due respect" phrase, saying something in a true asshole manner and then saying just kidding guys doesn't make you any less of a dick. Especially when you really can only get away with saying things like that to your best of friends and even then you risk truly pissing them off.

You want all the credit for just so happening to be a "fan" of the best program there is, feel free to pat yourself on the back. But, I can guarantee I gave more to MSU and STILL DO then you EVER will to PSU....

Keep on being you. For the first time, I truly get why fans on here want to simply eliminate you guys. I used to think differing viewpoints are a true benefit. But, nearly none of you offer that anymore. You simply gloat and insult. I hope one of those on here tag your post and send it up. You are the VERY FIRST I would endorse being removed from here.

Our discourse has now concluded for now and the forseeable future. Go spit...
 
Would like to see their projected lineup with rankings and accolades.
125 - ?
133 - Nagao, 5th (MN)
141 - Bartlett, 3rd
149 - Van Ness, 3rd
157 - Haines, 2nd
165 - Facundo, DNP (elite recruit with multiple elite recruits in this range)
174 - Star, 3x champ
184 - Truax, 4th @197 (CalPoly)
197 - Brooks, 3x champ @ 184
HWT- Kerkvliet, 2nd

Accolades? Most if their recruits were top 10-15 p4p. Transfers are both high AA (and way better than what we have at those weights).

They are absolutely loaded! They can take out 170 this year.

Can they find a 125? Will Facundo or someone else take a step forward this year at a stacked weight?
 
125 - ?
133 - Nagao, 5th (MN)
141 - Bartlett, 3rd
149 - Van Ness, 3rd
157 - Haines, 2nd
165 - Facundo, DNP (elite recruit with multiple elite recruits in this range)
174 - Star, 3x champ
184 - Truax, 4th @197 (CalPoly)
197 - Brooks, 3x champ @ 184
HWT- Kerkvliet, 2nd

Accolades? Most if their recruits were top 10-15 p4p. Transfers are both high AA (and way better than what we have at those weights).

They are absolutely loaded! They can take out 170 this year.

Can they find a 125? Will Facundo or someone else take a step forward this year at a stacked weight?
The plan is Howard at 125. But of course, his health is a going concern.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pointingdogsrule
125 - ?
133 - Nagao, 5th (MN)
141 - Bartlett, 3rd
149 - Van Ness, 3rd
157 - Haines, 2nd
165 - Facundo, DNP (elite recruit with multiple elite recruits in this range)
174 - Star, 3x champ
184 - Truax, 4th @197 (CalPoly)
197 - Brooks, 3x champ @ 184
HWT- Kerkvliet, 2nd

Accolades? Most if their recruits were top 10-15 p4p. Transfers are both high AA (and way better than what we have at those weights).

They are absolutely loaded! They can take out 170 this year.

Can they find a 125? Will Facundo or someone else take a step forward this year at a stacked weight?
The depth of 165 might keep them from scoring big there, but I think Mesenbrink is the real deal and will place for them right away. He's already great and wrestles a style that develops well in their system (as opposed to Facundo who's never been an offensive dynamo).

If Howard somehow stays healthy, he has a good pedigree and 125 is insanely weak. He could sneak on the podium too, though I wouldn't predict it.

In short, we're looking at one of the greatest teams of all time. They could realistically put 8 in the finals.
 
not for what matters for recruiting -individual titles.

In the last 10 years, Iowa had 8 #1 seeds at NCAA's. They went 1/8 in those attempts (2021 Spencer). Shocking level of underperformance in the biggest moment.
Additional context: PSU went 15/19 over the same span. 3/4 who lost won at least 1 title in their career. The only PSU #1 seed who never won a title was Morgan McIntosh and he lost to an all time great.
 
My point isn’t that Iowa cannot change for the better. You can always improve. My point is that what his happening for PSU has nothing to do with Iowa needing to change. PSU, Cael and Ira were a match like no other. Put the biggest name in wrestling at a powerhouse university located in the center of the ultimate wrestling hotbed and then give him nearly unlimited funding. What did you think was going to happen?

Iowa can make all the changes they want but PSU is currently “too big to fail”. What Iowa needs to start doing is recruit the top kids who want to topple the apple cart. Find those that like being the underdog. Portray PSU as the “Evil Empire” like Iowa was back in the day. They can’t fight with PSU over kids that are attuned to their culture. All that will happen is finishing 2nd in many recruiting battles and in recruiting 2nd truly is the same as last.

Spencer Lee was that type of recruit. He came to try to put Iowa back on top. They need to go after kids that buy into that. Own being far behind PSU and sell that to the recruits. Sell the chip on the shoulder approach. It almost certainly won’t get them even with PSU, but it can be a way to grind their way closer…
Best post I've seen on this board, EVER.
 
Additional context: PSU went 15/19 over the same span. 3/4 who lost won at least 1 title in their career. The only PSU #1 seed who never won a title was Morgan McIntosh and he lost to an all time great.
If you are going to use that argument for McIntosh, it’s only fair to do the same for the Iowa guys. Kemerer lost in OT to a guy that could actually be the only 5 timer in history. Eierman lost to a 2xer. Both guys at least had wins over them as well.

Lee had to wrestle with 2 knees that may never work right again and came into Iowa with considerable injury history. Gilman admittedly flopped against Moisey.

Marinelli is hard to gauge either way. He had Covid strip him of his chance the year he was actually wrestling his very best. His other 2 chances he simply lost to bad style matchups where the opponents may have simply been better wrestlers. Looking at the styles and his overall career would you say either of those losses were upsets? Mind you Mekhi and Shane have both been Finalists twice and AA’ top five as well.

With that said, there is no question PSU produces NCAA Champs at a ridiculously high rate. However, give Iowa that many top recruits and their numbers would go up considerably as well…
 
Last edited:
If you are going to use that argument for McIntosh, it’s only fair to do the same for the Iowa guys. Kemerer lost in OT to a guy that could actually be the only 5 timer in history. Eierman lost to a 2xer. Both guys at least had wins over them as well.

Lee had to wrestle with 2 knees that may never work right again and came into Iowa with considerable injury history. Gilman admittedly flopped against Moisey.
Okay take away the McIntosh excuse and the point speaks for itself.
 
Additional context: PSU went 15/19 over the same span. 3/4 who lost won at least 1 title in their career. The only PSU #1 seed who never won a title was Morgan McIntosh and he lost to an all time great.
Other than recruiting better, and injury prevention this is the other key area that we have to do better in. Winning more individual titles is another thing that goes a long way in dispelling negative perceptions (shocking revelation here). When we have guys capable of winning, they need to WIN. To be clear I'm not knocking the following guys, but these are guys who should have titles in an Iowa singlet, they were all more than good enough - Eierman, Kemerer, Marinelli, Gilman, Woods, Warner. This is where our focus needs to be, and the team accolades will follow.

Now we need to see some title contending and winning progress from Ayala/Chittum/Kueter/Arnold and the 2 younger Ferrari's (and we'll see what happens with AJ. & we actually need to land Angelo first). Plus Woods has one more shot at it - we have to have that one.
 
Okay take away the McIntosh excuse and the point speaks for itself.
I edited my post to make sure I covered all 8. Overall, I agree that PSU produces champs at a far better rate. However, they also start with so much more talent on a far more consistent basic. Am I saying Iowa would produce at the same rate? Probably not. But, would the rate increase considerably. I don’t doubt that for one second.

Simply put, the bluest of blue chips would still do VERY well at Iowa. They just simply have recruited enough of them to have a fair comparison…
 
If you are going to use that argument for McIntosh, it’s only fair to do the same for the Iowa guys. Kemerer lost in OT to a guy that could actually be the only 5 timer in history. Eierman lost to a 2xer. Both guys at least had wins over them as well.
Morgan was more of a 184, but put it out there anyway. And he beat both Cox and Snyder, which is pretty cool.
 
My point isn’t that Iowa cannot change for the better. You can always improve. My point is that what his happening for PSU has nothing to do with Iowa needing to change. PSU, Cael and Ira were a match like no other. Put the biggest name in wrestling at a powerhouse university located in the center of the ultimate wrestling hotbed and then give him nearly unlimited funding. What did you think was going to happen?

Iowa can make all the changes they want but PSU is currently “too big to fail”. What Iowa needs to start doing is recruit the top kids who want to topple the apple cart. Find those that like being the underdog. Portray PSU as the “Evil Empire” like Iowa was back in the day. They can’t fight with PSU over kids that are attuned to their culture. All that will happen is finishing 2nd in many recruiting battles and in recruiting 2nd truly is the same as last.

Spencer Lee was that type of recruit. He came to try to put Iowa back on top. They need to go after kids that buy into that. Own being far behind PSU and sell that to the recruits. Sell the chip on the shoulder approach. It almost certainly won’t get them even with PSU, but it can be a way to grind their way closer…
Excellent take, but I don't think the current staff can do it. If it was me acting as a general manager putting together a team to compete with PSU, I'd start by putting Kyle Dake at the helm. He showed time and again that he could look the lions in the eye and come out victorious.
 
I edited my post to make sure I covered all 8. Overall, I agree that PSU produces champs at a far better rate. However, they also start with so much more talent on a far more consistent basic. Am I saying Iowa would produce at the same rate? Probably not. But, would the rate increase considerably. I don’t doubt that for one second.

Simply put, the bluest of blue chips would still do VERY well at Iowa. They just simply have recruited enough of them to have a fair comparison…
Idk what point you think you're making.

It's the same tired old BS: "but..but..recruiting"

Bottom line: Iowa's produced plenty of wrestlers good enough to win NCAA titles in the last 10 years. When it comes down to it, they don't get it done. And that's the difference between Iowa and PSU.

When PSU produces a guy capable of winning it, they usually do at least once. in the past 10 years, the only guy they've had who was capable of winning a title, but didn't was Morgan McIntosh. You could make an argument for 2019 Shakur Rasheed, but he had a torn ACL.

Here's another stat for you: Iowa hasn't had multiple champs since 2010. Since 2011, PSU's had multiple champs 10 times out of 12 tournaments. They've gone 12 straight tournaments with at least 1. That's not just recruiting. That's development and performance.
 
Last edited:
I've been saying for a few years now that we (yes we) need a CHANGE.

I was called a moron and that I wasn't a fan, etc etc etc. TNT had everything under control. Just wait for these new recruits...

Y'all still on the TNT ship?

The best practice facility in the world WILL NOT stop PSU's dominance.

Kids would rather practice in a dump and win individual and team titles vs second place finishes.

We need new blood, and not ****ing Iowa Hawkeye blood.

We need David Taylor blood.
 
I've been saying for a few years now that we (yes we) need a CHANGE.

I was called a moron and that I wasn't a fan, etc etc etc. TNT had everything under control. Just wait for these new recruits...

Y'all still on the TNT ship?

The best practice facility in the world WILL NOT stop PSU's dominance.

Kids would rather practice in a dump and win individual and team titles vs second place finishes.

We need new blood, and not ****ing Iowa Hawkeye blood.

We need David Taylor blood.
Because you need to present an actionable solution, not some pie in the sky fantasy of David Taylor. Guess what, between his club, M2 Trained and NLWC pay, plus Living the dream paychecks, David Taylor is more than set financially for life. He has zero incentive to come to Iowa. He can continue helping PSU build their dynasty, stay with his friends and family, compete as long as he wants to, and I'm sure Cael might even have plans to bring him on to PSU staff eventually - hell, he might even be Caels successor when the day comes. Or he can just continue to run his extremely successful club without the stresses of a head coaching position. Ask yourself what reason would David Taylor have to want to build Iowa up to surpass his Alma Mater and mentor? If you think throwing a lot of money at him will change his mind, I think you are sadly mistaken.
 
Because you need to present an actionable solution, not some pie in the sky fantasy of David Taylor.
Yes he might be a hard draw.

But we need a big name, and I'd prefer it to be a non-Hawkeye.

Why and the **** is every coach on our bench an ex Hawkeye?

Yes, get Spencer Lee once he's done competing. But get another guy from outside the program.
 
Morgan was more of a 184, but put it out there anyway. And he beat both Cox and Snyder, which is pretty cool.
Trust me, I was in no way meaning to besmirch Morgan. He is still probably in my top 5 PSU wrestlers under Cael. He just always seemed very likeable and willing to do whatever it took to help the team!
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT