Balistreri's has awesome pizza and plenty of other great Italian food and is actually really reasonable! Always go there when I go to Milwaukee when back in the midwestIf you guys are looking for a good food spot, check out The Truck Stop MKE (theyve also got a couple food trucks). My buddy from college helped start one of the food trucks, and it developed into multiple trucks and a brick and mortar location. He was the head chef there for a bit, but I think he's gotten back into teaching now and left the biz.
Great food though.
Edit to tag @ThorneStockton