ADVERTISEMENT

Better coach— Fry or Ferentz?

Fair enough, then I have to assume you must enjoy what we have going on now because he had even more offensive ineptitude than KF. I'm also assuming you and others that think like you, would probably be a lot fairer about the constant criticism when we lose to sub 500 teams and score less than 14 points, correct?
IT is my opinion and I really could care less what you think about anything! You are quite the self-appointed auttority on everything and a legend in your own mind. Put me on ignore and I will do the same with you.
 
I care nothing about anybody else's opinion nor do I care what anybody thinks of mine. Hayden by a landslide!
 
It's like arguing Johnny Unitas vs Tom Brady, both HOF quarterbacks but from different eras so you can't really directly compare one to the other.

Fry took Iowa from being legit the worst team in Div 1 over 20 years, to an eventual (and legit) #1 ranking during the 1985 season. He had ups and downs, and left a bare cupboard, but the hill KF had to climb was not nearly as steep as Hayden's was.

KF has had more consistent success, and seems poised to have a good team going forward the next few years, whereas Fry seemed to lose steam and motivation at the end, albeit partly because he got prostate cancer which, obviously, wasn't something he could control.

But truly, given what each did at Iowa, it's crazy to think one could be said to be clearly better than the other. Now, one might debate who had the best Iowa team during their eras (I'd vote Iowa 1985 followed by end-of-season Iowa 2008). But best Iowa coach?

Oh, that was Howard Jones, by the way. Better than Fry, Ferentz, OR Evashevski.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cmhawks99
Here is the million dollar question really...

Knowing what we now know, the new "message board age" is very critical of KF?!

How long would Hayden have lasted, knowing he scored ...

14 points or less vs BIG 10 competition an astounding 49 times..

Lost to as many Sub .500 BIG 10 teams and...

Despite being an offensives genius scored 40 points way less times...22?

How long before you critics would have wanted him fired?
 
Both have the same number of wins— Ferentz in one fewer season, but Fry in two fewer games.

Fry took over a program that was in a two decade drought. Ferentz took over a team that was in a few season drought.

Ferentz has three prime Bowls with 1 win. Fry was 0-3.

Ferentz is more of a conservative in game manager where Fry was a “scratch where it itches”.

Fry had an abundance of assistant coaches get head coaching gigs. I can’t think of any from Ferentz era.
Hayden played against weak Wisc, NW, as ISU teams, they had all improved when KF took over. HF had to play Mich and OSU every year while expansion has allowed Ferentz to miss osu more than he has played them. Fry was more ' exotic', bUT some of those exploded horribly against us.
All that said, I was six when Hayden came to Iowa so they are all I have ever known. I'm not going to choose, I'm just going to appreciate them both.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cmhawks99
I hope the next Iowa head coach can be as good as Fry and Ferentz.

1990 and 1991 Fry was without KF as OL coach.

Fry from 1981 to 1991 was special. Ferentz rebooted Iowa, after entering Iowa in 1999 with depleted OL and DL, as Nick Saban was quick to suggest after B1G opener in 1999 in East Lansing.

Ferentz has been more methodical than Fry. He also was part of 1981 to 1989, so it has been a special 39 years.

On Iowa!
 
cmhawks99 we are talking football opinions! I do not feel my manhood is compromised if another poster has a different opinion. Obviously you and others do so if all on this board refuse to worship the ground Ferentz walks on!
 
cmhawks99 we are talking football opinions! I do not feel my manhood is compromised if another poster has a different opinion. Obviously you and others do so if all on this board refuse to worship the ground Ferentz walks on!


Waaayyy to strong....
 
Hayden played against weak Wisc, NW, as ISU teams, they had all improved when KF took over. HF had to play Mich and OSU every year while expansion has allowed Ferentz to miss osu more than he has played them. Fry was more ' exotic', bUT some of those exploded horribly against us.
All that said, I was six when Hayden came to Iowa so they are all I have ever known. I'm not going to choose, I'm just going to appreciate them both.

May have been weak Wisc, NW, and ISU teams but Hayden's preseason also included teams like UCLA, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Miami, Arizona, Penn St, Tennessee, and more. Iowa also played OSU and Michigan every year. Purdue was often a ranked team during Fry's tenure also. Take a look at Fry's schedule during his time at Iowa. Not many teams outside of power conferences.
 
The "charisma part" is the key to your statement. I don't mind somebody's opinion I get that... but put something a little tangible to it for the rest of us so we can understand it. Hayden scored 40 points verse big team competition less times than KF, he scored 14 points or less vs BIG waaaayyu more times and he lost two or tied a similar amount of sub 500 teams. How is he better in a landslide?

Now again I understand some of this kind of stuff is sacred and I don't begrudge anybody's opinion. But I can't find any measurable data that would suggest they're probably even equal anymore, let alone Hayden is better in a landslide.

If it's rescuing us from 20 years of ineptitude sure I get that...but as I pointed out earlier there was clearly more talent on those early teams then even the most positive fan realized. So his greatest gift was psychology, energy & that charisma you mentioned which apparently we are still under.

No major bowl wins, two top 10 finishes, was really average at absolute best his last 8/9, years we seem to be on an upswing right now.

As it turns out when you look at comparative scores he wasn't near the offensive juggernaut I remember him to be and had Way more inept performances on offense to boot.

Hell l, Hayden had 49 games va big team competition where he scored two touchdowns or less.....WTH!!! This generation & this era would not give him a pass on that...can you at least explain that part to me?
His greatest gift was putting an unbelievable staff together.......His first staff was legendary,one of the best staffs ever.... He and his staff could recruit,but when he got sick and the word got out that he wasn't going to be around very long- it was hard to attract coaches and players.
 
May have been weak Wisc, NW, and ISU teams but Hayden's preseason also included teams like UCLA, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Miami, Arizona, Penn St, Tennessee, and more. Iowa also played OSU and Michigan every year. Purdue was often a ranked team during Fry's tenure also. Take a look at Fry's schedule during his time at Iowa. Not many teams outside of power conferences.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Purdue_Boilermakers_football_seasons
Purdue was good the 1st two years and the last two years of Fry’s tenure, otherwise they were bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cmhawks99
Something else that a reread of Aristotle's post reminded me.....Hayden "built up" KF poor mouths...Holy crap where do you buffoons think he learned that.

Hayden was famous for saying our 1's could play with anyone but when we got hurt not so much, then EVERY Saturday he'd get on the radio and whine about how he didn't know if we could field a team. My dad used to joke with me on the way up..do you think we should go bud, sounds like Hayden doesn't think we have a shot....honestly how do people not remember this or let it go, yet hold KF to the fire for a similar approach...?!

Its kind of shi&^%Y honestly and definitely ignorant...
Hayden was a below average FOOTBALL coach and above average PEOPLE person. Went to NTSU in the early 80's after Fry left. There was not anyone in town that had much good to say about him as a football coach. Hayden was a master marketing guy with his catch phrases and "new" ideas. His most admirable and smartest thing he did while at Iowa was to jump on the farm crisis. Coming up with the ANF mantra was genius to gain fans that were not fans. It created national buzz that was well received by many.

But a "great" football coach was not what HF was....but if I was him I would rather be known as a "great" person.
 
Hayden had back-to-back nine win seasons his last two years at North Texas (77 and 78). Did those geniuses in Denton realize that 40 years later they would still be waiting for that to happen again? To be fair, they have had a total of three 9-win seasons there since then.

Of course, Hayden did it with an 11 game schedule. Those three 9-win seasons since, they played at least 13 games.

Hayden had already taken Iowa to a Rose Bowl, and three other bowls, before he "jumped" on the farm crisis in'85. Of course, he went to the Rose Bowl again that season, too.
 
Fry beat Nebraska once, Ferentz has beaten Nebraska four times. Isn't that the only thing that matters? :confused:
 
I don't know who is better but Indian we could have flipped them. I wish it would have been the steady eddy (7-5) coach that would have brought us from the depths and then the flashy 7-5 after. I know everyone says wiscy was horrible during that time but looking at coaching trees we would have been wiscy if it would have gone KF then HF.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT