ADVERTISEMENT

Bob Costas: College Football could collapse like house of cards if people begin connecting the dots

Franisdaman

HB King
Nov 3, 2012
100,105
136,399
113
Heaven, Iowa
As far as longtime sports broadcaster Bob Costas is concerned, the future of football in the United States is clear — and bleak.

“The reality is that this game destroys people’s brains,"
he said Tuesday night.

Speaking at a roundtable discussion at the University of Maryland, Costas, who hosted Football Night in America on NBC for more than a decade, said the sport could collapse over time, barring a development in technology to make it reasonably safe. He said the decline of football, which was once “a cash machine,” is the most significant story in American sports.

“The cracks in the foundation are there,” Costas said. “The day-to-day issues, as serious as they may be, they may come and go. But you cannot change the nature of the game. I certainly would not let, if I had an athletically gifted 12- or 13-year-old son, I would not let him play football.”

Kornheiser likened football's trajectory to that of boxing, saying that safety concerns could make the game obsolete in the coming decades.

“It’s not going to happen this year, and it’s not going to happen in five years or 10 years," Kornheiser said. "But Bob is right: At some point, the cultural wheel turns just a little bit, almost imperceptibly, and parents say, ‘I don’t want my kids to play.’ And then it becomes only the province of the poor, who want it for economic reasons to get up and out.

"If they don’t find a way to make it safe, and we don’t see how they will ... the game's not going to be around. It's not."

Costas added that existing literature and research will eventually lead families to what he called a “common-sense conclusion," that children should not play tackle football until they’re 18, if they play at all.

But then where’s the talent pool for college? What happens to college football?” Costas continued. “The whole thing could collapse like a house of cards if people actually begin connecting the dots.”


Full story: http://www.hawkcentral.com/story/sp...-this-game-destroys-peoples-brains/842904001/
 
Last edited:
I think it is a really hard subject. Football is without a doubt my favorite sport, and would be crushed to see it go away. I'm all for college and pro players being allowed to decide if it is worth the risks. Ask any police officer, construction worker, or truck driver if they have risks involved with their line of work.

However, the situation gets tricky because I don't like the idea of those younger than 18 deciding on a situation that might give them long lasting brain damage. It should not be the parents decision to risk their kid's health, just as I don't believe parents should have the right to refuse their kids vaccines (won't go into this anymore off of HROT).

Ultimately, this causes massive changes to college and pro football which saddens me, but I really don't see any way around it. Also would like to see more CTE research into other sports such as basketball, baseball, soccer, wrestling, etc.
 
I am not sure why Costas ever got into sports (other than to become a millionaire)

The concussion thing aside - as far back as I can remember - he continually brings up negative things about sports and the people involved with it. Maybe if he thinks sports are so horrible - he should give his salary (paid by sports) to some of these people he continually brings up. If he isn't happy get a different job. I watch sports to have a good time and get a break from my stressful life - not to be lectured to by some millionaire that is making his millions off the backs of talented athletes.
 
Has football been proven to cause brain damage?
As in: peer reviewed randomized placebo-controlled double blind studies?
Is that even possible?
From my understanding yes, but it isn't so cut and dried, because we don't know how prevalent it is in the normal, everyday lives of people outside of football. I should have specified above that I think we need more research into this before we start getting carried away with changing the game.

"While we still don't know what the incidence is in the general population or in the general population of football players," she says, "the fact that we were able to gather this many cases [in that time frame] says this disease is much more common than we previously realized."
McKee cautions, however, that researchers cannot extrapolate from the numbers and come to conclusions about CTE.

All the brains studied were donated, she says. "Families don't donate brains of their loved ones unless they're concerned about the person. So all the players in this study, on some level, were symptomatic. That leaves you with a very skewed population."

Still, McKee is adamant about one point.

"We're seeing this [CTE] in a very large number that participated in football for many years. So while we don't know the exact risk and we don't know the exact number, we know this is a problem in football."

 
  • Like
Reactions: Franisdaman
Football isn't going away. It's becoming safer by the day as we understand more about it and there will always be guys willing to play. This over-the-top hyperbole of there being no football in 20 years because it kills everyone who has ever played it is ridiculous.
 
Where do you draw lines? Risk is present everywhere we go. People are aware of them (at least they should be, unless they choose to play the dumb victim card) and choose to accept them or not accept them. We can always look for ways to improve, but I’m not a fan of someone deciding for me and taking away the option altogether.

The end game, is eventually we will all live in secured bubbles somewhere, and live out our lives through virtual reality plug ins. That way we can control and eliminate most if not all risk.

I’m all for looking at ways of improving the safety of the game, and that can be driven by players unions, parents, schools, etc. But lawyers and government are destroying this country.

Take away helmets altogether and let them wear foam helmets like you see in martial arts. Enough protection to help from hands, unintentional contact, etc, but not enough that anyone could use as a weapon like they do in today’s game. Go back to the old school leather helmets...
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_i8nzeu2gbf0ba
Soccer is one of the biggest sources of sports concussions...and boredom.

It's easy to be a naysayer, a pessimist. I wonder what Bob thinks about the future of motorcycles?

Costas, like many famous folks, has become a caricature of himself.

There are concerns about football safety, absolutely. But I think they can be controlled without destroying either the game or the people who choose to play it.
 
Football isn't going away. It's becoming safer by the day as we understand more about it and there will always be guys willing to play. This over-the-top hyperbole of there being no football in 20 years because it kills everyone who has ever played it is ridiculous.

Agreed, wholeheartedly. In today’s social media society, everyone wants the wow factor for attention, so everyone uses over the top hyperbole to draw attention. It’s ridiculous. And not a Trump fan per se, but he is right in that the media as a result has declined greatly in the past 10 years as a result, and is hard to trust anymore. Their job now is headline attention grabbing crap to try and draw max attention and max dollars, not fair and balanced, unbiased, good old regular discussion (goes for Fox as well, not trying to plug them).
 
You may be right, but you will have to convince all the Moms (and good luck with that)

Those are probably the same suburban moms who think vaccines are bad and that the new juice cleanse will help them lose the 40 pounds they put on after college. They are going to be impossible to convince otherwise, despite facts and science. So hopefully they are just a minority and most moms are more sensible.
 
100% agree, I don't see football as we know it surviving my lifetime (I'm 30). That's why I want the Hawks in the playoffs NOW before they don't exist anymore!
 
unfortunately i think he is right. love football but barring some major technological breakthrough i fear its days are numbered. as imaging technology become more sophisticated, i suspect that we will be able to detect the earlier stages of brain damage produced by head trama. if we find that brain damage in your 20s is more widespread than just tyler sash etc., very few parents will allow their kids to play football.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Franisdaman
They never said football was going away.

We're on a football board so you're going to get a lot of people naysaying this but the fact is, participation rates in high school football are declining. This article says 10% in the last decade, 3.12% in the past year. This CTE thing came up in the mid 2000s and has hit mainstream only in the past couple years. It's still relatively new and I think you're going to see more and more parents steer their young children into other sports. Sure football will never go away but barring any big change in how it's played, you're going to see less football players and poorer quality.
 
concussion treatments are already available... pulsed laser and tbi
Explain more....A concussion is a concussion, what is it they treat, the bleeding...and how is this monitored.
Just curious...I do think one thing all levels are doing a much better job is making sure that someone who does experience concussion symptoms is not allowed to return till asymptomatic....
 
Soccer is one of the biggest sources of sports concussions...and boredom.

It's easy to be a naysayer, a pessimist. I wonder what Bob thinks about the future of motorcycles?

Costas, like many famous folks, has become a caricature of himself.

There are concerns about football safety, absolutely. But I think they can be controlled without destroying either the game or the people who choose to play it.
Costas has always had the same shtick. He wants to present a side of a given sport and make you think about it in ways that nobody else does. Unfortunately, that's typically in some sort of negative light. He is what he has always been.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iahawkeyes17
Soccer is one of the biggest sources of sports concussions...and boredom.

It's easy to be a naysayer, a pessimist. I wonder what Bob thinks about the future of motorcycles?

Costas, like many famous folks, has become a caricature of himself.

There are concerns about football safety, absolutely. But I think they can be controlled without destroying either the game or the people who choose to play it.

Funny was thinking same thing with soccer because it reminded me of an interview I heard with Jim Nantz year or 2 ago on Dan Patrick show he stated % wise of the team womens soccer produces the most concussions than any other college sport including football.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HawkAttackDial911
Just provide the link where anyone on a sports talk show claims that "football kills everyone that every played it" and I'll delete my post.

Yeah I'm not gonna find the link to a bunch of random audio, thanks though. It was a hyperbolic over-the-top statement which a lot of personalities have echoed about football over the past couple years. Pretty simple.
 
Yeah I'm not gonna find the link to a bunch of random audio, thanks though. It was a hyperbolic over-the-top statement which a lot of personalities have echoed about football over the past couple years. Pretty simple.
"Killed everyone that has ever played"...????
Nobody ever said that. Just admit that your hyperbole is way more over the top. It's not hard to do.
 
Prove it.
images
 
Football won't decline only due to less parents letting their children play, but also because schools and organizations that facilitate football will eventually be too afraid of the liability. Once people start filing lawsuits against high schools, youth organizations, etc., their insurance rates will go up drastically and their tolerance of the risk and liability will go down.
 
It is up to each family and what Costas thinks does not hold any more value than a can of piss.
 
I think it is a really hard subject. Football is without a doubt my favorite sport, and would be crushed to see it go away. I'm all for college and pro players being allowed to decide if it is worth the risks. Ask any police officer, construction worker, or truck driver if they have risks involved with their line of work.

However, the situation gets tricky because I don't like the idea of those younger than 18 deciding on a situation that might give them long lasting brain damage. It should not be the parents decision to risk their kid's health, just as I don't believe parents should have the right to refuse their kids vaccines (won't go into this anymore off of HROT).

Ultimately, this causes massive changes to college and pro football which saddens me, but I really don't see any way around it. Also would like to see more CTE research into other sports such as basketball, baseball, soccer, wrestling, etc.
Not 1 player is forced to play the game, they know the inherent dangers of it.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT