How will "mass deportation" impact the US economy?

[ICHerky]

Most Latin Americans are decent, family-oriented, hard-working people.

As far as I am concerned, they belong here more than MAGA scum, pieces of shit like you.

Btw, why is it so difficult for you dumbasses to construct a basic sentence in English? Even middle school SPED students know the difference between two sentences and a comma splice.

Move.

You’re an idiot. Only you and crazies like you make it about race. Those that came here illegally should be deported, nothing to do with race you dipshit.

 

[lucas80]

Wash, rinse and repeat.

People like you aren't serious about this.

What have you done to fight the invasion?

 

[lucas80]

You’re an idiot. Only you and crazies like you make it about race. Those that came here illegally should be deported, nothing to do with race you dipshit.

Fair enough. How much more are you willing to pay for food? How much more will you be willing to have dry wall or a roof installed?

 

[Tom Paris]

You’re an idiot. Only you and crazies like you make it about race. Those that came here illegally should be deported, nothing to do with race you dipshit.

Bull effing shit.

 

[RagnarLothbrok]

You’re an idiot. Only you and crazies like you make it about race. Those that came here illegally should be deported, nothing to do with race you dipshit.

Lol

 

[chonk]

Fair enough. How much more are you willing to pay for food? How much more will you be willing to have dry wall or a roof installed?

Fair point. People did not buy food or build and fix houses prior to the democratic mass immigration program under Harris/Biden. Good thing the costs of these items came down during the highest level of immigration the USA has ever seen. I am now switching my vote to Kamala…cause we need change.

 

[lucas80]

Fair point. People did not buy food or build and fix houses prior to the democratic mass immigration program under Harris/Biden. Good thing the costs of these items came down during the highest level of immigration the USA has ever seen. I am now switching my vote to Kamala…cause we need change.

Good point. There were no illegals in the US between 2017-2021.

 

[Gimmered]

Conjecture…but even not doing anything would be significantly better for the USA than what the Democratic Party will intentionally do.

And you're an idiot, so there is that. I will never vote away my liberty, I will vote Democrat.

 

[Gimmered]

Fair point. People did not buy food or build and fix houses prior to the democratic mass immigration program under Harris/Biden. Good thing the costs of these items came down during the highest level of immigration the USA has ever seen. I am now switching my vote to Kamala…cause we need change.

You think immigration is driving these prices up and not the $5 trillion we printed for COVID relief?

 

[Here_4_a_Day]

And you're an idiot, so there is that. I will never vote away my liberty, I will vote Democrat.

 

[Joes Place]

Please demonstrate for us.

Read the article, dipshit.

 

[Joes Place]

We are always being told what will happen if......

Somehow very few of the predictions come true.

First, all of the mass deportations won't happen overnight, or even close to that.

This is why the writeup refers to a 10 yr, ongoing effort, deporting 1M a year, and what both the costs and impacts to the economy would be.

Again, read the damn article/analysis.

 

[Here_4_a_Day]

This is why the writeup refers to a 10 yr, ongoing effort, deporting 1M a year, and what both the costs and impacts to the economy would be.

Again, read the damn article/analysis.

Are you ****ing an ILLEGAL or something? Just marry it.........

 

[Joes Place]

https://www.cato.org/blog/fentanyl-smuggled-us-citizens-us-citizens-not-asylum-seekers

U got any non-liberal links, tho???

😉

 

[Joes Place]

Right. The data are clear that a high percentage of American citizens consume the shit

Do you not understand the word "trafficking" here?

 

[Joes Place]

Are you saying that fentanyl is being smuggled into America for non-citizens? I am confused.

BY Americans, for non-citizens.... apparently....

 

[Joes Place]

So it's pretty damn clear that Americans are the biggest problem - and Republicans won't mention it - for bringing drugs into the country. It's easier to scare their base blaming it on brown people.

We should deport them....

 

[Joes Place]

Illegal aliens no right to be in this country. Why don’t they just come in legally?

People have been migrating between North and South America for >20,000 years.
Yet somehow NOW it's a 'big problem'.....

 

[Randon]

Surely Trump must have a "plan" for his mass deportation of 11 million illegals.! Which begs the question, what is the fate of the children of these illegals born here in the US which are in fact US citizens.? But just like his "plan" for replacing Obamacare, his "plan" for ending the war in Ukraine in 24 hours, and his "plan" for immediately reducing the cost of gas and groceries, Trump has no "plan" at all. And sadly this huckster has convinced millions of Americans that he does.

 

[lucas80]

Surely Trump must have a "plan" for his mass deportation of 11 million illegals.! Which begs the question, what is the fate of the children of these illegals born here in the US which are in fact US citizens.? But just like his "plan" for replacing Obamacare, his "plan" for ending the war in Ukraine in 24 hours, and his "plan" for immediately reducing the cost of gas and groceries, Trump has no "plan" at all. And sadly this huckster has convinced millions of Americans that he does.

2 weeks. He is going to release his plan in 2 weeks. It’s going to be beautiful.

 

[RagnarLothbrok]

Do you not understand the word "trafficking" here?

Nope. No clue. Completely oblivious.

But I do understand the term “annoying, know-it-all wise ass.”

At least Seminole97 is entertaining.

 

[billanole]

2 weeks. He is going to release his plan in 2 weeks. It’s going to be beautiful.

Well, maybe a concept of a plan.

 

[chonk]

And you're an idiot, so there is that. I will never vote away my liberty, I will vote Democrat.

By liberty I can only assume you aren’t referring to your right to vote

 

[Finance85]

Fair point. People did not buy food or build and fix houses prior to the democratic mass immigration program under Harris/Biden. Good thing the costs of these items came down during the highest level of immigration the USA has ever seen. I am now switching my vote to Kamala…cause we need change.

Ummmm.... If we need change then why would you vote for Kamala, or even Trump for that matter?

 

[cohawk]

Likely very little noticeable effect.

Based on what? Let's assume most of those 11 million have jobs. Wouldn't that have a negative effect on labor supply?

 

[cohawk]

90% is brought in by American citizens through normal border checkpoints

Most Sentenced for Trafficking Fentanyl are U.S. Citizens | KFF

Former President Trump has routinely blamed undocumented immigrants for a rise in drug trafficking and overdose deaths…But most fentanyl is being trafficked by American citizens. …

www.kff.org

Not quite 90% but close.

 

[Here_4_a_Day]

Based on what? Let's assume most of those 11 million have jobs. Wouldn't that have a negative effect on labor supply?

Huge savings on healthcare >

Former GOP governor warns Harris admin will 'try to sneak through' healthcare benefits for illegal immigrants

Former Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal is warning that a Medicare for All plan, which Vice President Kamala Harris has previously supported, would be an invitation to illegal immigrants.

www.foxnews.com

 

[cohawk]

Please demonstrate for us. And who cares, they are here illegally, they broke the law. Do you even care about the USA? Send them home and require them to follow the legal process. Stop hating America.

Thank you for telling everyone you know little about labor supply and inflation. You know very little about economics. This is my issue with Trump supporters they overly simplify complex issues.

 

[fsu1jreed]

Most Sentenced for Trafficking Fentanyl are U.S. Citizens | KFF

Former President Trump has routinely blamed undocumented immigrants for a rise in drug trafficking and overdose deaths…But most fentanyl is being trafficked by American citizens. …

www.kff.org

Not quite 90% but close.

Rounding error

 

[NoleATL]

That’s about as practical as setting up speed cameras every 1/10 of a mile on every roadway in America to ticket everyone breaking the law by speeding. Only an absolute moron would think what you’re saying is remotely feasible.

Step one is to secure the border. That has to be priority number one.

Step two is using available manpower to hunt down illegals committing violent crimes and/or bringing in narcotics.

I don’t know what the statute of limitations is for illegally entering the country or outstaying your visa, but to try to get rid of every single person who is here illegally, especially those who have been here for years working and contributing to society without issue, is just not practical and is next level stupid.

The MAGA idiot brigade’s collective brain just can’t compute common sense when the issue involves brown people.

Step 1.A is criminal penalties, including jail time, for employers who hire the undocumented immigrants.

 

[NoleATL]

You are going to have riots on Wall Street if the coke supply gets low.

FIFY

 

[NoleATL]

When gas prices went up, MAGA 100% believes that it's Biden's fault.

It was actually because of Trump's sharp negotiating skills and that 10% capacity REDUCTION he negotiated with OPEC.

 

[NoleATL]

2 weeks. He is going to release his plan in 2 weeks. It’s going to be beautiful.

He has a concept of a plan. Ike the concept of a transportation plan for Trumpchella.

 

[Scruddy]

Proof that leftists have moved from the "it's not happening" phase to the "it's happening but it's actually a good thing" phase.

 

[globalhawk]

It was actually because of Trump's sharp negotiating skills and that 10% capacity REDUCTION he negotiated with OPEC.

I believe the negotiations were during Covid and to benefit Russia.

 

[RicoSuave102954]

A: It's pretty bad.

Like $1T cost over 10 yrs and 4-6% reduction in GDP, along with billions in lost tax revenues...

View embedded media

View embedded media

The Devil is in the details; here are what those details look like, in reality.

Mass Deportation: Devastating Costs to America, Its Budget and Economy

The mass deportation of millions of undocumented individuals would be tremendously expensive and would have a catastrophic impact on our economy—one that would be expansive and impact every American. The American Immigration Council analyzes the fiscal costs and economic impacts of such a mass...

www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org

FAKE NEWS -

 

[fsu1jreed]

I believe the negotiations were during Covid and to benefit Russia.

Probably an ancillary benefit

 

[TonyTheTiger.1865]

Only deport those convicted of crimes, have a criminal record, are on welfare or any other type of government payout. Problem solved.
If you have a job, are not sucking on the government tit, are not a criminal, maybe you can stay.

 

[TonyTheTiger.1865]

And you're an idiot, so there is that. I will never vote away my liberty, I will vote Democrat.

Seems you will vote away your liberty. Or maybe just other people’s liberty.

 

[fsu1jreed]

Seems you will vote away your liberty. Or maybe just other people’s liberty.

Holy fvck?!? Do you not understand that what you're doing with a vote for Trump?