ADVERTISEMENT

Is mental health the reason more elementary students are taking guns to school?

400 million guns is a big reason why kids have guns.

I don't think that's the most important number. Households with a gun hasn't changed much over time. Culture has. (now, that's not saying widely available guns aren't a problem, depending on how you see things, however, I don't that their availability, especially to kids, has really changed much over time -- and we didn't used to have these issues)

 
I don't think that's the most important number. Households with a gun hasn't changed much over time. Culture has. (now, that's not saying widely available guns aren't a problem, depending on how you see things, however, I don't that their availability, especially to kids, has really changed much over time -- and we didn't used to have these issues)

Maybe the fact is there are too many irresponsible gun owners. I think the parents of elementary students need to serve a month or two of jail time if their child brings a gun to school. Something has to make the issue of proper storage of weapons a priority for parents.
 
Maybe the fact is there are too many irresponsible gun owners. I think the parents of elementary students need to serve a month or two of jail time if their child brings a gun to school. Something has to make the issue of proper storage of weapons a priority for parents.

I wouldn't be against that. I'm not sure parents changed that much where gun responsibility was concerned.

I think the people that point to culture are absolutely right; but so are the gun availability people. Both.
 
Maybe the fact is there are too many irresponsible gun owners. I think the parents of elementary students need to serve a month or two of jail time if their child brings a gun to school. Something has to make the issue of proper storage of weapons a priority for parents.
If it was the parents gun, then I agree. Some sort of repercussions. Hefty fine maybe…
 
I think the people that point to culture are absolutely right; but so are the gun availability people. Both.

Exactly. Yet we have a thread here asking if one thing is “the” reason.

Our politicians do not like the hard, long, non-sexy work of breaking down a problem into its numerous causes and then overseeing the resolution of each.

So they talk about “the” solution.
 
Kids do the things they see. This is all news is anymore. Very little journalism just skimming social media for catchy stories and thats all we see.
 
I don't think that's the most important number. Households with a gun hasn't changed much over time. Culture has. (now, that's not saying widely available guns aren't a problem, depending on how you see things, however, I don't that their availability, especially to kids, has really changed much over time -- and we didn't used to have these issues)

It is absolutely a problem. More guns than people. Easy to get them. It's a huge problem.
 
Not interested in making excuses. I want results. And looking at half a billion guns is where I'm looking first.
There are an estimated 393 million guns owned be 33% of Americans. You're not interest in knowing if there were the same amount, lesser amount or more amount of guns in America during periods of time where gun violence isn't what it is today?

I would think you'd be interested in causation for gun violence. I know I certainly am because it's a pretty big deal in our current society.

A 2013 report from the American Academy of Pediatrics found that violence in films has more than doubled since 1950, and gun violence in PG-13-rated films has more than tripled since 1985:

EB20130320REVIEWS130329996AR-3.jpg


I'm actually pretty surprised you're uninterested in this topic, Huey. It's no secret our society keeps sliding the goal posts on what's acceptable. Remember when Psycho was Rated R for violence? I watched that flick with my kids. PG-13 movies are now more violent than R-rated '80s flicks according to a study I read.

 
I don't think that's the most important number. Households with a gun hasn't changed much over time. Culture has. (now, that's not saying widely available guns aren't a problem, depending on how you see things, however, I don't that their availability, especially to kids, has really changed much over time -- and we didn't used to have these issues)

Perhaps the "at least one gun" is the issue. We have a sheet ton more guns now than in 1972 so it must be the existing gun households having more guns and not keeping track of the larger number like they did with 1 or 2?
 
  • Like
Reactions: gohawks50
Perhaps the "at least one gun" is the issue. We have a sheet ton more guns now than in 1972 so it must be the existing gun households having more guns and not keeping track of the larger number like they did with 1 or 2?
This study is old, but looks like gun ownership had been declining steadily from 1972-2014 (mostly because hunting isn't as popular).


EDIT: Found a more current report:

GUN OWNERSHIP IN AMERICA: 1973 TO 2021 Comprehensive, national data spanning 49 years contained in the General Social Survey (GSS) conducted by the National Opinion Research Center (NORC) at the University of Chicago reveals that after years of decline through the 1980s and 1990s, and a relatively stable rate during the 2000s, our nation may be seeing a slight increase in gun ownership starting in 2018.1

GRAPHIC ONE: THE LONG-TERM DECLINE IN HOUSEHOLD GUN OWNERSHIP

 
Exactly. Yet we have a thread here asking if one thing is “the” reason.



Our politicians do not like the hard, long, non-sexy work of breaking down a problem into its numerous causes and then overseeing the resolution of each.



So they talk about “the” solution.
I hope you realize my thread title was "tough in cheek". Gun advocates usually blame school shootings on mental health. Situations like these could easily result in a tragic event that even the child with the gun wasn't intending. Guns have become too "normal" in children's lives. Many kids see having them as cool, tough, and patriotic. The reasons for intentional shooters are harder to define, but children bringing guns to "show off" should be something we can agree on about the cause and punishment for adults responsible.
 
Last edited:
I don't think that's the most important number. Households with a gun hasn't changed much over time. Culture has. (now, that's not saying widely available guns aren't a problem, depending on how you see things, however, I don't that their availability, especially to kids, has really changed much over time -- and we didn't used to have these issues)

Good God. I can’t with this shit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huey Grey
There are an estimated 393 million guns owned be 33% of Americans. You're not interest in knowing if there were the same amount, lesser amount or more amount of guns in America during periods of time where gun violence isn't what it is today?

I would think you'd be interested in causation for gun violence. I know I certainly am because it's a pretty big deal in our current society.

A 2013 report from the American Academy of Pediatrics found that violence in films has more than doubled since 1950, and gun violence in PG-13-rated films has more than tripled since 1985:

EB20130320REVIEWS130329996AR-3.jpg


I'm actually pretty surprised you're uninterested in this topic, Huey. It's no secret our society keeps sliding the goal posts on what's acceptable. Remember when Psycho was Rated R for violence? I watched that flick with my kids. PG-13 movies are now more violent than R-rated '80s flicks according to a study I read.

Are you shitting me? Movies are more to blame than the half a billion guns we have?
 
Perhaps the "at least one gun" is the issue. We have a sheet ton more guns now than in 1972 so it must be the existing gun households having more guns and not keeping track of the larger number like they did with 1 or 2?
Could factor in.

In general... seems the "random" mass shootings and kids bringing guns to school thing is a more recent social phenomenon. I can't explain why it wouldn't have happened earlier in American history, but gun availability was pretty strong then. Of course those make up a small fraction of gun deaths, but it seemed we kind of went 0-60 on those pretty fast.
 
You also have access to high powered automatic weapons that may have changed.

Most all of the big mass shootings are of recent. Really do think there is some social stuff in there.

Deadliest mass shootings almost all occur in recent history.

The same with school shootings. (seems to pick up in steam a bit in the 60s and 70s, really gets rolling in the 90s and present day)

before 2000
after 2000
 
Are you shitting me? Movies are more to blame than the half a billion guns we have?
I never said that. You said the problem was 400 million guns. I asked what the numbers were from time-periods where gun violence wasn't nearly as high is it is today. You said you're weren't interested. In subsequent posts, I shared links where gun ownership has declined. So, if we have less gun ownership, then that isn't the sole problem.

Now, we've beat the ever loving $hit out of this topic here on HROT and I've stated a million times that I'm all for gun reform (I strongly support it, in fact). I've also stated that my reasons are different than most. I want to limit gun access so that once that [guns] is out of the equation we, as a society, can focus on the real issue. Because I hate to tell you that once little Johnny no longer has access to a gun, little Johnny's desire to do harm will still be present (if it's not addressed).

EDITING FOR AFTERTHOUGHT:
A better way to put it is, I think we don't have a choice but to make drastic changes to gun laws because society has changed, not the guns. The guns were there by the millions in the 80s 90s 00s and we didn't have these type of issues. So, since no one wants to to figure out why people are shooting the hell out of each other, then we need to limit/prevent access.

 
Last edited:
I never said that. You said the problem was 400 million guns. I asked what the numbers were from time-periods where gun violence wasn't nearly as high is it is today. You said you're weren't interested. In subsequent posts, I shared links where gun ownership has declined. So, if we have less gun ownership, then that isn't the sole problem.

Now, we've beat the ever loving $hit out of this topic here on HROT and I've stated a million times that I'm all for gun reform (I strongly support it, in fact). I've also stated that my reasons are different than most. I want to limit gun access so that once that [guns] is out of the equation we, as a society, can focus on the real issue. Because I hate to tell you that once little Johnny no longer has access to a gun, little Johnny's desire to do harm will still be present (it it's not addressed).

EDITING FOR AFTERTHOUGHT:
A better way to put it is, I think we don't have a choice but to make drastic changes to gun laws because society has changed, not the guns. The guns were there by the millions in the 80s 90s 00s and we didn't have these type of issues. So, since no one wants to to figure out why people are shooting the hell out of each other, then we need to limit/prevent access.

Then why was the bulk of your post about movies?
 
It's a) available guns at home, and b) they hear their parents talk about how to handle problems.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gohawks50
It's about culture...much of which is played out in the media we, as a society, consume. It doesn't matter if it's music, television, games, movies, or social media. Society is being desensitized.
I agree. And our culture is guns. We've been fed by the NRA and Republicans for decades that guns solve problems. So it's no surprise that so many believe it.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: KFsdisciple
I agree. And our culture is guns. We've been fed by the NRA and Republicans for decades that guns solve problems. So it's no surprise that so many believe it.
So, kids are watching NRA and Republican propaganda?

You're going to tell me a kid has a better chance of being influenced by this:

gettyimages-1139645353_wide-082b2cd930c277a5cdfdabd60088d90d59ea0a5a.jpg


Than this?

gun_violence.jpg


I'd be shocked if a kid even knows what the NRA is.

I blame the NRA for nothing being done regarding gun legislation reform, but they aren't responsible for our society's steady consumption of violence nor the fact so many Americans are flat out pissed off.

And no, I'm not just parking the blame on "movies".
 
So, kids are watching NRA and Republican propaganda?

You're going to tell me a kid has a better chance of being influenced by this:

gettyimages-1139645353_wide-082b2cd930c277a5cdfdabd60088d90d59ea0a5a.jpg


Than this?

gun_violence.jpg


I'd be shocked if a kid even knows what the NRA is.

I blame the NRA for nothing being done regarding gun legislation reform, but they aren't responsible for our society's steady consumption of violence nor the fact so many Americans are flat out pissed off.
Yes kids are listening to this propaganda. You think kids don't listen to their parents parroting FoxNews gun garbage every week? They're reared on this bullshit.
 
So, kids are watching NRA and Republican propaganda?

You're going to tell me a kid has a better chance of being influenced by this:

gettyimages-1139645353_wide-082b2cd930c277a5cdfdabd60088d90d59ea0a5a.jpg


Than this?

gun_violence.jpg


I'd be shocked if a kid even knows what the NRA is.

I blame the NRA for nothing being done regarding gun legislation reform, but they aren't responsible for our society's steady consumption of violence nor the fact so many Americans are flat out pissed off.

And no, I'm not just parking the blame on "movies".
The biggest influence on elementary students is their parents. The NRA message trickles down from adults to children.
 
Our parents were correct and we laughed at them......"gratuitous violence" in our entertainment is out of control for the maturity level of our society as a whole.
Yes kids are listening to this propaganda. You think kids don't listen to their parents parroting FoxNews gun garbage every week? They're reared on this bullshit.
Kids play violent video games and think nothing about blowing people apart. They just do not understand the difference betweem fantasy play and reality. Sorry...I am just "old" school here.
 
Yes kids are listening to this propaganda. You think kids don't listen to their parents parroting FoxNews gun garbage every week? They're reared on this bullshit.
Well, there ya go. Shut down FoxNews and problem solved. You're welcome. :cool:

giphy.gif
 
Holy $hit. I think I want to quit researching this topic. It's making me sick to my stomach.

The average child sees 8,000 murders by the end of elementary school and 200,000 acts of violence by age 18.
 
Holy $hit. I think I want to quit researching this topic. It's making me sick to my stomach.

The average child sees 8,000 murders by the end of elementary school and 200,000 acts of violence by age 18.
And parents have no control over what they are watching?
 
And parents have no control over what they are watching?
You assume that most parents are good parents. Too many don't care or are uneducated to understand the ramifications.

Nationwide, on average, 79% of U.S. adults are literate in 2022. 21% of adults in the US are illiterate in 2022. 54% of adults have a literacy below sixth-grade level. 21% of Americans 18 and older are illiterate in 2022.

Do some research on how many kids are being raised by screens and unmonitored screens at that. My son's school had an issue with kids playing "red light, green light" because so many 3rd graders (and younger) were watching Squid Games.
 
You assume that most parents are good parents. Too many don't care or are uneducated to understand the ramifications.

Nationwide, on average, 79% of U.S. adults are literate in 2022. 21% of adults in the US are illiterate in 2022. 54% of adults have a literacy below sixth-grade level. 21% of Americans 18 and older are illiterate in 2022.

Do some research on how many kids are being raised by screens and unmonitored screens at that. My son's school had an issue with kids playing "red light, green light" because so many 3rd graders (and younger) were watching Squid Games.
So where are all the Korean shootings?
 
  • Like
Reactions: auntie_fah
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT