Mark May provides intelligent football commentary. When he and Trev Alberts were on you thought about something they said and maybe even learned something. Intelligent, football-knowledgeable men who played the college game at a high level.
I'll admit that May is obviously smarter than your typical ex-jock given a cushy broadcasting gig (Jesse Palmer, David Pollack, Joey Galloway, Desmond Howard, etc.), and you are correct, he and Alberts were perfect foils for each other. But that was how many years ago? His opinions since then have been forced and generally nonsensical. He would frequently be forced to take the contrarian opinion in order to provide some semblance of balance with dumbass Holtz. He also came across as bitter and mean a lot of times, probably because he resented having to take the wrong end of issues in order to prop up someone like Holtz. Either way, his opinions on football, at least what he would say on air, were routinely awful.
For the Corso detractors I admit that he is past his prime. But he put the fun in ESPN Game Day for decades. When he, Fowler and Herbstreit were on camera it was just fun.
Again, because their show was fun 10 years ago, we're just supposed to ignore how awful it's become lately?
I'm as diehard a CFB fan as there is, and watched Gameday religiously for years, going all the way back to when it was a studio only show and they might do one "road game" per year. I was at the show in Iowa City in '96 and actually met all 3 guys offstage afterwards. Nowadays, on the rare Saturday morning when I'm actually home and not tailgating somewhere, I avoid ESPN like the plague. The stupid guest pickers? Like I give 2 fvcks what some idiot NASCAR driver or Gaby Reece thinks about some random ACC game. Corso slurring his words, Dez Howard generally being obnoxious and irritating, Herbie talking about how the "speed and athleticism" of whoever the favored team is will prove to be the difference, how he can't lower himself to give a prediction on the top game because he's broadcasting it later, like anyone in America gives a shit about his journalistic integrity on some random midseason football game. And don't even get me started on the "headgear" crap. That was really funny the first few times that he did it, and has been the dumbest thing on television since about, oh, 2006.
Gameday sucks, and has for years. The entire thing should just go away.