ADVERTISEMENT

Mt. Rushmore of U.S. WWII Generals

LuteHawk

HB Legend
Nov 30, 2011
29,052
21,800
113
As we prepare our hearts and minds to celebrate Veterans
Day this month, we pause to honor the 4 greatest U.S.
Generals of WWII.

General Dwight Eisenhower
General George Patton
General Douglas MacArthur
General Omar Bradley

This 4 Generals stand out in my mind, who do you have?
 
Washington, Lee, MacArthur, Marshall.
Reread the OP.

I have zero respect for MacArthur for what he did to Wainwright following Corregidor. Fighting vehemently against Wainwright ' MOH citation based on what he said was cowardice then pushing for his own despite fleeing to Australia? The guy should have been kicked out of the Army over it. I don't care what else he did in his Army career, you do that to your "friends" and deserve zero respect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lucas80
For WWII don't you really have to ask which generals were the best in the field, and which were the best in planning and the politics of war?
The best fighters I'll go Mark Clark, George Patton, Omar Bradley, and Holland Smith.
The politicians Dwight Eisenhower, George Marshall, HAP Arnold, and Carl Spatz.
 
For WWII don't you really have to ask which generals were the best in the field, and which were the best in planning and the politics of war?
The best fighters I'll go Mark Clark, George Patton, Omar Bradley, and Holland Smith.
The politicians Dwight Eisenhower, George Marshall, HAP Arnold, and Carl Spatz.
Not that I disagree, but I feel Gavin has to be in there too.
 
As we prepare our hearts and minds to celebrate Veterans
Day this month, we pause to honor the 4 greatest U.S.
Generals of WWII.

General Dwight Eisenhower
General George Patton
General Douglas MacArthur
General Omar Bradley

This 4 Generals stand out in my mind, who do you have?
I'd replace Dugout Doug with Ira Eaker.
 
Even great Generals make mistakes and even if one considers MacArthur and Clark in this category, they are not exceptions.

Somehow, MacArthur missed acting on the memo that Japan had attacked Pearl Harbor. He and his staff allowed their aircraft to be destroyed on the ground 9 hours after they knew they were now in the World War.

Clark went for glory rather than good tactics. Instead of bagging a large portion of the Germans in Italy, he turned toward Rome which had no strategic significance. Clark had the headlines he craved for only 2 days, then the Normandy invasion drew the attention of the world.
 
I think that we can all agree that Eisenhower and Patton
were two of the best U.S. Generals in WWII.
 
I'd replace Dugout Doug with Ira Eaker.
Eaker is definitely interesting. I went with Spatz over Eaker because I think he had a lot of critical arguments with Ike about strategic targeting.
 
As we prepare our hearts and minds to celebrate Veterans
Day this month, we pause to honor the 4 greatest U.S.
Generals of WWII.

General Dwight Eisenhower
General George Patton
General Douglas MacArthur
General Omar Bradley

This 4 Generals stand out in my mind, who do you have?
People really prepare their hearts and minds to celebrate Veterans Day???

Wow. Didn't realize what an unpatriotic sonuvabitch I am. Time for some serious introspection I guess.
 
  • Like
Reactions: moral_victory
People really prepare their hearts and minds to celebrate Veterans Day???

Wow. Didn't realize what an unpatriotic sonuvabitch I am. Time for some serious introspection I guess.

Buy one support the troops car magnet, watch a veteran's day parade, and enjoy the savings of a veteran's day sale. You know as a thank you for the freedoms.
 
Nimitz
IKE
Arnold
Patton
Chester Nimitz was a navy Admiral and Overall Commander of the Pacific fleet. Basically equal to a General of the Army (4 star), but not a General.

Patton was insubordinate, a prima donna, but a hell of a fighter who spilled allot of his men's blood as well as the enemies. Died as a 4 star.

Bradley was a great success story. Came up through the ranks the hard way.
 
No question that General Patton was a prima donna,
and he even admitted it. Yet, the guy was passionate
about defeating the Germans and he did his part to
accomplish it.
 
No question that General Patton was a prima donna,
and he even admitted it. Yet, the guy was passionate
about defeating the Germans and he did his part to
accomplish it.
It's amazing what an Academy Award winning movie and performance by lead actor will do for your reputation.

That said, I'm not trashing Patton. He struck fear in the German high command and his 3rd Army's trek to provide relief to the 101st Airborne at Bastogne is legendary.

I went to his Leadership Institute and Museum at Fort Knox this summer. Very impressive.

During a battle, he ordered each General under his command spend some time up at the front every day to bolster the morale of the troops.

After spending time at the front during a battle, Patton preferred to be transported back to the command area via small plane because he did not want the troops ever seeing him retreating in a jeep or his staff car. Appearances matter.

The pearl-handled revolvers he wore were not matched. One was pearl-handled, the other was ivory. Just little stuff on display at his museum.

He was an excellent athlete as a young man. He competed in the Olympics (I think it was 1912) for the U.S. in the decathlon. Finished 9th, I believe.

My Mount Rushmore list of U.S. Generals for WWII:

Dwight Eisenhower - incredible pressure and responsibility on his shoulders
Hap Arnold
Omar Bradley
Wainwright - highest ranking U.S. General captured during the war. Captured at Corrigedor (sp) when MacArthur left him swinging in the wind. Survived the Bataan death march and stood on the deck of U.S.S. Missouri to witness Japanese surrender. IMHO - they should have given him a sword and allowed him to decapitate the Japanese delegation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LuteHawk
No question that General Patton was a prima donna,
and he even admitted it. Yet, the guy was passionate
about defeating the Germans and he did his part to
accomplish it.
It's amazing what an Academy Award winning movie and performance by lead actor will do for your reputation.

That said, I'm not trashing Patton. He struck fear in the German high command and his 3rd Army's trek to provide relief to the 101st Airborne at Bastogne is legendary.

I went to his Leadership Institute and Museum at Fort Knox this summer. Very impressive.

During a battle, he ordered each General under his command spend some time up at the front every day to bolster the morale of the troops.

After spending time at the front during a battle, Patton preferred to be transported back to the command area via small plane because he did not want the troops ever seeing him retreating in a jeep or his staff car. Appearances matter.

The pearl-handled revolvers he wore were not matched. One was pearl-handled, the other was ivory. Just little stuff on display at his museum.

He was an excellent athlete as a young man. He competed in the Olympics (I think it was 1912) for the U.S. in the decathlon. Finished 9th, I believe.

My Mount Rushmore list of U.S. Generals for WWII:

Dwight Eisenhower - incredible pressure and responsibility on his shoulders
Hap Arnold
Omar Bradley
Wainwright - highest ranking U.S. General captured during the war. Captured at Corrigedor (sp) when MacArthur left him swinging in the wind. Survived the Bataan death march and stood on the deck of U.S.S. Missouri to witness Japanese surrender. IMHO - they should have given him a sword and allowed him to decapitate the Japanese delegation.
Nimitz was a Fleet Admiral = 5 Star General

Later in the war, yes.
 
Hap Arnold.

The job he did building the Army Air Force caused him multiple heart attacks throughout WWII. But he turned the then USSAF into the largest air force over the rest of the world combined in 3 years' time.

I know the air force and navy WWII history better than the Army...but I'd have to go with Ike. Field commander...Bradley.
 
I think that we can all agree that Eisenhower and Patton
were two of the best U.S. Generals in WWII.

You're probably right, but Nimitz deserves to be in the discussion. I'd throw Curtis "Bombs Away" Lemay in there too, but admit he didn't quite have the public status of the others. He orchestrated an absolutely ruthless strategic bombing campaign against Japan.
 
Wasn't MacArthur ordered by Roosevelt to escape? I don't think he had much choice in the matter.

Nimitz would have to be up there since he was in command of not just all naval forces but all air/land/sea units under his jurisdiction
 
Last edited:
Carlos D'Este wrote a fascinating biography of Patton. He wrote one on Eisenhower too but Patton was a much more colorful character.
Also recommend his WWII histories like Bitter Victory-the Battle for Sicily and Fatal Decision-Anzio and the Battle for Rome.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT