ADVERTISEMENT

My thoughts on Tim Lester

So, the only QB on the roster that was a "Brian/Kirk/Budmayr guy is Cade. Sullivan and Shaggy arrived after Lester was on board. I still don't know if Iowa has a legitimate P4 starting QB on the roster. Getting Northwestern and Colorado State cast offs at QB typically isn't a recipe for success at that position. They were last minute additions at a moment of crisis at that position. The fact that they looked more efficient than Cade says way more about Cade than anything else.
Yeah, and then they move Resar to receiver...

I can't even begin to try to solve this problem we have of recruiting quarterbacks, but, hopefully Lester knows what one looks like.

Portal here we come!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: HawkOn15
Total offense ranking last year 132
This year 114

70 yds more a game.

Pts per game way up to 28….15 last year

Not as much improvement as we would like but improvement nonetheless.

I think the jury is still out. He took over a train wreck offense.
We're likely to have the #1 rushing offense for the first time under KF. Passing game showed signs of life imo. OL took a big step forward, but now we will see what happens with having to replace several starters.
I’m saying the only real guy that Lester has brought in that’s expecting to play is Sullivan. Every other scholarship qb is Brian and Kirk’s recruit and been a disaster.
Sure, but anyone expecting a major turnaround at the position in just one offseason, especially when there wasn't nearly the number of options at the QB position in the portal that was expected.
So the thing that I kept asking yesterday was why Iowa didn't use more play action. They had an opponent that was selling out against the run on every play so it seemed ripe for play action and yet it seemed we saw almost none of it. The run plays had almost no chance of gaining any yards. Seemed like a perfect chance to run play action and leak the tight end up over the safeties and linebackers that were cheating up on every play.
I'm hoping someone asks Kirk/Lester/Stratton...it didn't seem like Stratton had much zip on his passes last night; I'm wondering if the cold was bothering him. Lester has been good enough as a playcaller that it was perplexing to see Iowa insist on running into a brick wall all game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: binsfeldcyhawk2
Sully was in pregame warmup and halftime warmup and looked like he could plant on foot fine and was throwing good.

I didn't even see Cade on the sideline at all.
I think the problem for Sully was that with his ankle his mobility was still really limited. Not really an upgrade imo to put Sully in there if he was a statue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WaterlooChazz
going off what was reported from the various podcasts I listen to. Dropback passing fine; running like he wants to would have been really pushing it.

My understanding is that he was an emergency option only.
Maybe cutting I guess because he was not trying to do that when I watched, but straight ahead running and dropping back looked totally normal. 0 limp.
 
Kirk alluded to it in his press conference after the game. The most, if not only, important thing for Stratton last night was to not make a mistake. While I have heard him say many times that he does not get involved in the actual play calls, he does manage overall game strategy. In that regard, rule number one and rule number last for the game yesterday was to not have Stratton do something stupid and lose it. Therefore, there was a zero risk strategy employed.

Also, Sullivan was not ready to go last night. Stratton is not a run threat. Nebraska was daring Iowa to have Stratton try to win the game. And the only way he could accomplish that was by throwing the ball downfield. Kirk did not take that bait. So, there were no good options for offense last night. Don’t hand to Nebraska an easy score. In that regard, mission accomplished.

I am not saying anyone has to like it, but that’s what was going on last night.

Kirk also said in his press conference last night, that the number one thing he looks at over time is turnover margins. Iowa won that last night. He also said that in games like this, you have to rely on your best players stepping up. Both of those things happen. It was a classic Kirk Ferentz game when you are undermanned.

After listening to him for 26 years, he’s actually quite transparent and what he is trying to do. Last night, it worked out.

I would not judge Tim Lester on what we saw last night. That was a game of circling the wagons and taking advantage of a break or two that comes your way, and leaning on your stud to win the game. That was a Kirk Ferentz game, not a Tim Lester résumé game.
Totally agree - good analysis
 
Total offense ranking last year 132
This year 114

70 yds more a game.

Pts per game way up to 28….15 last year

Not as much improvement as we would like but improvement nonetheless.

I think the jury is still out. He took over a train wreck offense.

I wonder how much the yardage fell off after the UCLA game. Playing 2.5 games with a 3rd string walk on qb and no healthy backup had to kill the average
 
  • Like
Reactions: binsfeldcyhawk2
just a fyi: Oklahoma fired their OC late October and Kevin Johns (interviewed for Lester's job) who was an offensive analyst was promoted to co-OC and QB coach. Venables said Johns wasn't given the full OC job b/c he wasn't involved in game planning prior to Littrell's firing.

Official: Oklahoma Has Fired OC Seth Littrell (link)
 
It's impossible to judge this mess right now. The offensive line coach needs to be replaced. We need a massive upgrade there. We need some WRs to stretch the field and run longer than 5 yard routes to get open. We have to at least throw the ball long every now and then because no defense respects the pass, at all. With no change, why should they?
 
It's impossible to judge this mess right now. The offensive line coach needs to be replaced. We need a massive upgrade there. We need some WRs to stretch the field and run longer than 5 yard routes to get open. We have to at least throw the ball long every now and then because no defense respects the pass, at all. With no change, why should they?
Iowa needs a QB that can throw to WR's who can stretch the field. Hell, ISU has two 1000 yd receivers this year. ISU. I don't think Iowa has thrown for 2000 yards in the last 3 seasons combined.
 
It's impossible to judge this mess right now. The offensive line coach needs to be replaced. We need a massive upgrade there. We need some WRs to stretch the field and run longer than 5 yard routes to get open. We have to at least throw the ball long every now and then because no defense respects the pass, at all. With no change, why should they?
I think the OL improved greatly this year - they're not Joe Moore Award semifinalists for nothing.

If nothing else, he bought himself another year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WaterlooChazz
Iowa needs a QB that can throw to WR's who can stretch the field. Hell, ISU has two 1000 yd receivers this year. ISU. I don't think Iowa has thrown for 2000 yards in the last 3 seasons combined.
We did in 2022, alone.

Only got to 1661 in 2023, 1580 so far in 2024.
 
I think the OL improved greatly this year - they're not Joe Moore Award semifinalists for nothing.

If nothing else, he bought himself another year.

I understand and they were better but I'm not sure why we are Joe Moore semifinalists.

Run blocking seemed improved. However, watching the various replays at Kinnick it was clear how many blocks we missed. Pass blocking was also not great.

I feel the O line has had ample time to get better and simply hasn't. I respect your opinion but this is one spot that I feel we are simply not good enough.
 
I understand and they were better but I'm not sure why we are Joe Moore semifinalists.

Run blocking seemed improved. However, watching the various replays at Kinnick it was clear how many blocks we missed. Pass blocking was also not great.

I feel the O line has had ample time to get better and simply hasn't. I respect your opinion but this is one spot that I feel we are simply not good enough.
I mean, they were good enough to open big holes for a Doak Award finalist - pass blocking I think was okay; not great, but not terrible. Didn't help that Cade couldn't/wouldn't move in the pocket to help them out; and vs Nebby things were very tough on them because Stratton couldn't make them pay for how aggressive they were.

Like I said, I think the OL showed enough improvement that Barnett got another year - and we'll see how much improvement we have from the younger guys and whoever we pursue in the portal.

Last couple years I've had a hard time truly forming an opinion on the OL - the scheme/QB play was so horrible they had to be perfect and if they weren't the play was dead before the QB even took a step back. IMO Lester did a much better job scheming the offense so that players had a chance to, well, make plays.
 
The OL improved on run blocking. KJ is a special talent and was a home run every game. We didn’t see the same type of production when the other backs were in there (Tho they had some nice runs too). KJ made them look a lot better

The pass blocking was horrible. Again. Maybe a handful of times during the year the QB had more than 2 seconds to scan the field ??? Cade took a beating again. Sullivan would have too if not for his mobility. Shaggy never had to throw haha

Friday nights game, #9 for NE was in the backfield every single snap.

You wonder if it really is more the scheme than the players. When Iowa went to their Kirk offense, it’s impossible for 5 players to block 9. When we saw Lester offense and motion, the guys looked to have a chance

Who’s even coming back from this years OL ? And did any underclassmen play ?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: HawkOn15
Total offense ranking last year 132
This year 114

70 yds more a game.

Pts per game way up to 28….15 last year

Not as much improvement as we would like but improvement nonetheless.

I think the jury is still out. He took over a train wreck offense.
How much of that improvement was KJ and for a couple games at least a mobile quarterback? Those slightly improved numbers and an 8-4 record mask inherent weaknesses in Kirk’s offense and his inability to recruit better athletes at offensive skill positions. Those issues are still there.

Can Lester make a difference? Remains to be seen. I’m not optimistic about next year.
 
Hard to evaluate an OC when you have this sh** show of a passing offense. Our QB’s and WR’s are not B10 starting caliber. I think year 3 will be the year to properly evaluate his job. And we always have to remember that every OC still has to report to ultra conservative KF
 
How much of that improvement was KJ and for a couple games at least a mobile quarterback? Those slightly improved numbers and an 8-4 record mask inherent weaknesses in Kirk’s offense and his inability to recruit better athletes at offensive skill positions. Those issues are still there.

Can Lester make a difference? Remains to be seen. I’m not optimistic about next year.
KJ was on the team last year.
 
I postulated that in another thread. The only problem is that he would not announce his retirement until after the bowl game, and if we don't have a coaching vacancy until January, BG would probably be stuck making Wallace interim HC for a season, and I'm not sure if that is the best thing for the program. Would have been awesome for him to have one more win right now, announce his retirement, and leave it up to the team whether or not he walks away with the record tied or outright.
Kirk would never step-down mid-season if he broke Woody's record.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hendy hawk
Fire George Barnett, hire a real O-line coach, and Lester will look much better.
That is a good start and an absolute must if the offense wants to move forward. Barnett's OL's have been objectively horrible. How a former OL coach like KF could tolerate this is befuddling. I really want to believe that KF wants to win and will hold his assistants accountable, but if he gives the 'ole "our OL has really improved and GB is doing an excellent job" after the season and brings him back, he'll have a hard time convincing me and a lot of other fans that he hasn't become complacent and just wanting to go through the motions until he physically can't coach anymore.
 
That is a good start and an absolute must if the offense wants to move forward. Barnett's OL's have been objectively horrible. How a former OL coach like KF could tolerate this is befuddling. I really want to believe that KF wants to win and will hold his assistants accountable, but if he gives the 'ole "our OL has really improved and GB is doing an excellent job" after the season and brings him back, he'll have a hard time convincing me and a lot of other fans that he hasn't become complacent and just wanting to go through the motions until he physically can't coach anymore.
At least for this year - this is a false narrative. I don't see how you can say the OL has been horrible this year...they weren't semifinalists for the joe moore award for nothing.

While I won't say they've been great the past few years - they obviously weren't, I have and will continue to argue that that had as much to do with the poor scheme and playcalling by BF as well as the atrocious QB play as well. We change OCs who does much better at putting players in good spots to succeed, and look what happens...YPC jumps to over 5, the starting RB breaks the rush TD record and for a time threatened the single-season yardage mark.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkeyemark18
At least for this year - this is a false narrative. I don't see how you can say the OL has been horrible this year...they weren't semifinalists for the joe moore award for nothing.

While I won't say they've been great the past few years - they obviously weren't, I have and will continue to argue that that had as much to do with the poor scheme and playcalling by BF as well as the atrocious QB play as well. We change OCs who does much better at putting players in good spots to succeed, and look what happens...YPC jumps to over 5, the starting RB breaks the rush TD record and for a time threatened the single-season yardage mark.
Ok, so in his 4th year, with all his guys in place and one of the most experienced OL in the country, Iowa finally fielded what almost looked like a serviceable B1G OL. Sorry I’m not impressed.

Certainly BF crippled the offense for years, no arguing that. But not sure he’s totally to blame. It looks like GB failed to develop an NFL OLineman after Linderbaum fell in his lap.

And GMAFB with the Joe Moore award thing. We both know that’s a joke.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT