Rank 'em: Taylor Sheridan TV Shows

[alaskanseminole]

How would you rank his shows?

1. 1883 | My favorite so far 9/10 (docked 1 point for Elsa's voice)
2. Lawmen: Bass Reeves | 9/10
3. Yellowstone | 8/10 (rating first 3 seasons only...goes downhill from there)
4. Mayor of Kingstown | 8/10
5. Tulsa King | 7/10
6. 1923 | 7/10

7. Special Ops: Lioness | Haven't watched yet

 

[HawkMachine]

 

[Formerly Rockymtnole]

Haven’t seen any of those shows. From the YT clips I’ve seen Yellowstone looks like soap-opera dogshit.

Sicario was really good.

 

[Moral]

It's weird that I could never get into Yellowstone but really liked 1883, 1923, and Lawmen Bass Reeves. 1883 being my favorite of those 3.

I would probably copy your list but flip Yellowstone and 1923. I also have not seen Special Ops.

 

[DropitlikeitsHawk]

Haven’t seen any of those shows. From the YT clips I’ve seen Yellowstone looks like soap-opera dogshit.

Sicario was really good.

Sicario was awesome.

 

[alaskanseminole]

Haven’t seen any of those shows. From the YT clips I’ve seen Yellowstone looks like soap-opera dogshit.

Sicario was really good.

Ya, I'll have to do another list with his feature films. Hell or High Water wasn't bad either.

 

[McLovin32]

I've only seen 1883 and Mayor of Kingstown and loved them both. I'd probably have to rank Mayor of Kingstown over 1883.

The fiance no pics and I tried to get into Yellowstone but just couldn't. Watched the first 4 episodes and were not impressed and just couldn't stick w/ it.

I do want to watch Tulsa King and 1923 though. That's on my to-do list.

 

[BelemNole]

Haven't watched any

 

[TJ8869]

Haven’t seen any of those shows. From the YT clips I’ve seen Yellowstone looks like soap-opera dogshit.

I know this comparison has been made many times, but it's basically Sons of Anarchy on real horses instead of iron horses.

 

[TylerJ23]

1883 is one of the best shows ever, IMO.

 

[ping72]

Haven't watched any

+1

 

[TennNole17]

Yellowstone is a great show. Its does get a bit of the soap opera vibes, buts it’s still tops.
1923 (it picked up for me towards the end)
1883 (very very close- both were good)
Tulsa King (campy but fun)
Bass Reeves (haven’t finished)
Mayor of Kingstown (didn’t really get into it)

 

[TennNole17]

 

[TennNole17]

Yellowstone is a great show. Its does get a bit of the soap opera vibes, buts it’s still tops.
1923 (it picked up for me towards the end)
1883 (very very close- both were good)
Tulsa King (campy but fun)
Bass Reeves (haven’t finished)
Mayor of Kingstown (didn’t really get into it)

Rewatching 1883 while I’m on the paramount app waiting for tip offs, gd what a good show. McGraw was fantastic