I have done a complete 180 on this. At first I thought there was no way he would be healthy enough to wrestle, and if he was it would make the most sense to redshirt and bulk up and Iowa as a team will be down this year.
There are a lot of other factors though. An injury can happen, and we have seen it happen, in another year and cost a guy a season (Stoll). Would be nice to have that redshirt available then so you can actually compete at 4 national championships.
I also know from my own experience, that 4 years for some guys is enough. By my senior year I was glad I did not redshirt as I was ready for a change. 4 years of the same thing can mentally wear on people as well.
If Spencer and his family want to wrestle, then I'm looking forward to watch him this year.