ADVERTISEMENT

What is more important? Recruiting or Development?

I can agree to a point. Those 8 guys are wired to win. However, the partners from the RTC wouldn't be the same, nor would the coaches in the room nor the emphasis on S&C that Cael may put into his program. I get what you are saying, but the raw material still needs a catalyst most of the time.

Oh, and the fun wouldn't be the same. ;)
It didn't hurt Kanen Storr. Some guys are going to win no matter what. Every program has some of them, but I do think it's fair to say that Penn State has more than anyone else.
 
If you gave those 8 guys to KJ, what's the result their freshman year?

Probably not as good as being with Cael and Penn State. However, maybe not by much?.....as long as they have each other to roll around with?....and as long as JR is not around either?.....these fine wrestlers also seem to operate at a high level outside of wrestling.
 
Earl Hall was ranked 83 and I don't if Weatherspoon was ranked at all. Both were AAs at one point.
 
Explain Earl Hall and LeLand witherspoon...
Hall started to regress already last year. He wasn't strong enough for 133. Spoon and Hall get a pass from me for this year. That KJ let Downey and the old man influence the room was the beginning of the end. If KJ wasn't so desperate... Downey wouldn't even have been on campus.

And I don't want this to come across wrong, but Jackson got many of the kids to campus because of his race, imo. And I don't blame the parents/guardians one bit for that. There are not very many black HCs in D-1 wrestling. I think the parents may have felt the social adaptation to college might be easier with KJ as the program leader. Unfortunately, he just never developed any consistent results. His choice of asst coaches early on was very suspect.
 
Disclaimer first I never wrestled in my life.
I am a Penn State grad who saw his first wrestling match as a freshman in 1955.
Fell in love with the sport.
To develop them you have to be able to recruit them. Watching your coaches at a meet and watching Carl at a meet if you were an up and coming wrestler who would you choose to develop your talent?
 
Disclaimer first I never wrestled in my life.
I am a Penn State grad who saw his first wrestling match as a freshman in 1955.
Fell in love with the sport.
To develop them you have to be able to recruit them. Watching your coaches at a meet and watching Carl at a meet if you were an up and coming wrestler who would you choose to develop your talent?
Another Penn State fan that literally knows nothing about Iowa. Tell the rest of your board to come over and act like pricks
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_0pi0cv8t1ggvb
Penn St does both better than anybody else. They are getting the right guys in the door and the development really separates them. The hardest thing to do is get guys into that 'elite' class. Right now they are doing it better than anyone else.
 
Disclaimer first I never wrestled in my life.
I am a Penn State grad who saw his first wrestling match as a freshman in 1955.
Fell in love with the sport.
To develop them you have to be able to recruit them. Watching your coaches at a meet and watching Carl at a meet if you were an up and coming wrestler who would you choose to develop your talent?

What are you thinking they see?
 
C'mon man...when you have true frosh come in and win it or AA, they were pretty damn good to start. That's why a Mark Hall or Spencer Lee is so coveted. You all are starting on third base pretending you hit a triple..
LOL, you come up with some of the BEST metaphors. :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dagboi
I think the regional & national tournament circuits, plus all the elite clubs, have really changed the answer to this question in the last 10-20 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jaybird319
I think the regional & national tournament circuits, plus all the elite clubs, have really changed the answer to this question in the last 10-20 years.

This...Kolat said it today on Twitter in advocating getting rid of the shirt. These kids are coming ready to wrestle.
 
Guilbon and the Altons. Evans was a 3X AA but never won a title. However, we were getting one top ten every four years. Easier to have a Guilbon when 8 of your other guys are top ten. Less likely you'll miss on one.

Asked it another thread but it bears repeating in here: What if we had 9 Kemerers? Kemerer came to us already being very good (person and wrestler). At this point, it's how you manage the kid vs developing them depending on their character and motivation levels. For example:

Level 1-Needs micromanaged in the room and academics; Needs to be taught good habits. May have talent but lacks the physical and mental maturity to exploit

Level 2-Understands basic concepts about the sport, program and life. Is able to manage self on campus but still needs work in the room maintaining weight, conditioning etc

Level 3-Shows self discipline, works hard etc but still needs a little bit of push mentally. Has good grades outside of the room and no behavioral problems

Level 4-Needs very little guidance. Is a team leader. If left alone, can work with self and others to improve self. Performs at one of the higher levels in the room and on the mat. Now just fine tuning.

This is just crude example of evaluation criteria. Obviously, you want kids that are in the 3 & 4 range. Not every kid coming in is going to start out at 1 or 2 because their parents, prior coaches and self have already taught this part. The hard part is not treating everyone the same but recognizing that you may have some building to do with one while showing respect to the others.

Met a 3X State Champion and a D-1 kid the other night...some of you might recognize his name. Was very good in a non traditional state but then chose a high academic but smaller school. After speaking to him for five minutes, knew he was a mess. Bragged about beating this guy or that etc in high school and about how he wanted to transfer schools...he knew it all. We didn't ask...he volunteered this info to complete strangers. I vaguely remembered his name and googled it and sure enough...found out he had been arrested for various issues.

I guess the key would be to identify those kids like a Nolf, Kemerer, etc who are already at 3 and 4 to begin with...get as many as you can so you can spend the time on the 1s and 2s without it being a deficit to your program. Sometimes they bear fruit big time. One can posit that a guy like Cenzo was at a 2 when he got to PSU. He missed weight a couple of times during his RS year for whatever reason but then took a year to develop and you know the result. With year around wrestling and their talent already pretty much known, the biggest issue to early success IMO would be getting them on campus and off to a good start with the guys and academics.
Hey Chief - I copied the good parts. I'm coaching a 13 PONY team in baseball and everything there applies especially to kids that think they want to play High School baseball - It is all mandatory to be a level 3 or 4 if college is in the thought process. Thanks - man - I'm sending this to the parents right now
 
This is the classic question of psychology, nature v. nurture. The answer is almost always both are equally as important.
You really can't use that analogy when you are not talking about getting along and excelling in society in a general sense. Here it is about athletic ability. I can't be, coundn't be...lol..., a division one basketball player based on my height and lack of quickness. No amount of nuture was going to alter that fact. Was all about nature. Could I improve, make the most of my skills??? Of course. Be an NCAA champion? No way.
 
Of course it's both, but look at Bael's recruits:

DT - 2nd as a Frosh
Ruth - 3rd as a Frosh (likely bc of injury in the QF)
Zain - 5th as a True Frosh (could have possibly been 1st with a shirt)
Nickal - 2nd as a Frosh
Nico - 2nd as a Frosh
Joseph - 1st as a Frosh
Hall - 1st as a True "Frosh"
Nolf - 2nd as a Frosh

That's not development. That's just talent.
----

Exactly.

Suppose my grandmother got hired as a d1 coach, and got Aaron Pico to join the team. They wrestle PSU, and Pico throttles Retherford (as he has in the past).... does that make her a great coach? Or does it mean she benefitted from pulling in a great recruit?

Cael has recruited like no one in d1 wrestling history. Cael's success at development is hard to measure, since most every PSU recruit is the best in their weight class, coming out of HS.
 
----

Exactly.

Suppose my grandmother got hired as a d1 coach, and got Aaron Pico to join the team. They wrestle PSU, and Pico throttles Retherford (as he has in the past).... does that make her a great coach? Or does it mean she benefitted from pulling in a great recruit?

Cael has recruited like no one in d1 wrestling history. Cael's success at development is hard to measure, since most every PSU recruit is the best in their weight class, coming out of HS.
spot on - not sure what is in the water jugs at PSU or under the table for the parents
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dagboi
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT