I like this.
Like you, I'm willing to accept the killer terrorists at their word when they claim to be killing for Allah.
Here's the difference. If star wars superfans kill those who disagree with them about star wars, no one says all star wars fans are terrorists and that they and anyone near them deserve to die. No one even says we have to lock up all star wars fans, or ban them, or tap their phones, or put them in a database....
Yet that's the sort of logic most on the GOP dais want us to buy. Call it what you want: scapegoating, racism, fascism, delusional, stupid ... it's going way too far.