Then name them. Name all the trans women destroying women's records.
Transgender track runner wins 2 women's events in which race times would've been last place among men
- Thread starter NorthernHawkeye
- Start date
Take a break, Huey. Decompress.
Your justification for biological males competing against women is that the numbers are nominal. It’s a ridiculous argument. It would be like a MAGA saying, “Well, Trump probably only grabbed a pussy once or twice, so stop making an issue out of something nonexistent.”
There’s either a justification for a male competing against women or there’s not. Period.
I've stated my stance. This isn't a real problem. Rs use it as a wedge issues to cover for their inability to govern. And that individual athletic organizers should be the ones to decide how to handle this not state or federal governments.
It is a way to pretend there isn't a problem. Lol when the libs tried to tell us border crossings weren't effecting us. Lol. I call it whistling by the graveyard.
The Democratic Party is making it a wedge by pushing back against common sense.
Prediction -
Future women’s records and championships being broken by men transitioning to women? Eventually all of them.
Future men’s records and championships being broken by women transitioning to men? None.
Future women’s records and championships being broken by men transitioning to women? Eventually all of them.
Future men’s records and championships being broken by women transitioning to men? None.
Egad. Commonsense.
Nonsense. Dems aren't doing anything here. This is pure Republican horsecrap and you know it.
You are wildly flailing here, Huey.
At this point, you should probably chill on accusing others of embarrassing themselves and find a mirror.
Again, either it’s acceptable for males to compete against females or it’s not. Until you can come up with a cogent and compelling rebuttal that is actually relevant to that question, your absurd and ridiculous deflections to obfuscate the undermining of Title IX reflect poorly on you and you alone.
There are non-Republicans in this very thread who are against it. The majority of Americans are against biological males competing in women’s sports.
Seventy percent actually…
Most Americans oppose including trans athletes in sports, poll finds
Nearly 70% of U.S. adults say transgender athletes should be allowed to compete only on sports teams that correspond with the sexes they were assigned at birth, Gallup found.
www.nbcnews.com
It's up to each individual organization to set the rules. If you don't like those rules don't compete.
Okay.
Now I get it. You are completely detached from reality and want the rest of us to join you in Mr. Roger’s Neighborhood to hop on the trolley to the Land of Make-Believe.
Good night, Huey.
Name just “one” female transitioned to male who has won anything in male athletics. I’ll wait…
Dems aren't the ones passing laws here. If you can't accept this then you're right. It's pointless to keep arguing with you.
The Biden administration just made changes to Title IX that go into effect August 1st.
You’re a liar, Huey. And a bad one at that.
You’re right, this is a waste of time. I don’t indulge liars.
Good night.
Please explain what you object to here?
"
The proposed regulation would recognize that differences in grade and education level, level of competition, and sports must be taken into account for any eligibility criteria that would restrict transgender students from participating on teams consistent with their gender identity.
One-size-fits-all policies that categorically ban transgender students from participating in athletics consistent with their gender identity across all sports, age groups, and levels of competition would not satisfy the proposed regulation. Such bans fail to account for differences among students across grade and education levels. They also fail to account for different levels of competition—including no-cut teams that let all students participate—and different types of sports.
Taking those considerations into account, the Department expects that, under its proposed regulation, elementary school students would generally be able to participate on school sports teams consistent with their gender identity and that it would be particularly difficult for a school to justify excluding students immediately following elementary school from participating consistent with their gender identity. For older students, especially at the high school and college level, the Department expects that sex-related criteria that limit participation of some transgender students may be permitted, in some cases, when they enable the school to achieve an important educational objective, such as fairness in competition, and meet the proposed regulation's other requirements."
What do polls have to do with the fact that Republican lead states like Iowa are passing one anti trans law after another?
70 percent of Americans are not all Republicans. There are Dems in there too. My original comment in this thread is stating that basically this gives Republicans a point that 70% of Americans agree with. The Republicans are taking it to their advantage…
Did you read my above post? Even the Biden administration agrees that athletics has to be fair. That if you can demonstrate unfair advantage those athletes can be prohibited. So what is the exact complaint by the right here? Because it sure seems like it's crying just to cry.
So not one rational person thinks men should play against women in sports. That was easy.
Moral of the story is it is common sense and shouldn't happen once. The Justification game show is hilarious though.
"Based off population the percentage is low but not one individual should experience police brutality period and we need police reform"
Somehow that same person-
"We need more data that biological men shouldn't compete against women. It doesn't happen that often"
"Based off population the percentage is low but not one individual should experience police brutality period and we need police reform"
Somehow that same person-
"We need more data that biological men shouldn't compete against women. It doesn't happen that often"
Do you consider laws that ensure an 18 year old male cannot shower with a 14 year old female to be "anti-trans law". Because that seems to be the goal of a lot of them.
Also, why does the trans community accept that trans men are not put into men's prisons but fight for trans women to be put in women's prisons? It's pretty obviously what people really believe when they make these arguments.
The NCAA has always lagged behind in things. They allowed Semi Pro teams to dominate football and basketball. It’s a clique. Same with the high schools that let trans girls compete. Assume they are from mostly suburban liberal areas.
Eventually it will work its way out. And they’ll move onto something else.
In either case it involves someone participating in a sport of the other sex. Why is one worse than the other?
Oh yeah it’s because women don’t win in male sports competing against males born as males, do they?
All the hand wringing over female NCAA non revenue sports. Honestly this is more attention they have gotten ever. I’m sure the participants that win also are the highest NIL earners correct. This will all pass. Both sides will get tired and move onto something else that excites them.
Trans athletes have an unfair athletic advantage over female athletes,.. Let them compete with men.
Go back to your self-hating victim corner - grab a new box of Kleenex - and stop spewing your sad little white lies.
