ADVERTISEMENT

$25k a year soccer academy coming to South Bend

Hoosierhawkeye

HB King
Sep 16, 2008
54,726
53,922
113
42
Of course this does nothing to help with the fact that only the wealthy can afford to play top level youth soccer.


MISHAWAKA — A Mishawaka native is betting big on youth soccer with plans to open a single-sport private high school catering to talented domestic and international players who hope to get college scholarships or go pro.
Founder Ethan Hunt, a 23-year-old graduate of Marian High School and Bethel University, says he expects the International Soccer Academy of America to open for classes this fall in the former Edison Lakes YMCA building.
Hunt modeled the school on European-style football academies, affiliated with professional clubs, where students go to school while developing as soccer prospects. He said the United States has soccer development academies linked with pro teams, but there are few, if any, that combine academics and soccer under one roof.

Hunt “has known for a long time that the American soccer system is not aligned with the rest of the world,” according to the school’s website, “and he has made it his goal to fix it.”
Hunt, who started developing the idea as a master’s thesis, said there are full-time schools that use similar models, but none that focus exclusively on soccer.
“I said, why don’t we just do soccer only,” Hunt said, “and then we can bring a huge draw of soccer-specific players to our area that probably wouldn’t have come here otherwise.”
Hunt said at least 50 families from the South Bend-Mishawaka area and surrounding region have inquired about applying to the school, along with 25 from abroad, in the week since he publicly announced the plans.
He said students will start class at 9:30 a.m. and finish at 4:05 p.m., followed by an hour-long study hall and two hours of soccer practice. The school will focus on in-class projects to lessen the amount of homework, and will include “mindfulness” exercises such as meditation and yoga.
“In the Midwest, you’ll never find something like this,” said James Ortega, who will be running his Futboleros academy for kids 7 to 14 at the school. “It’s very European-minded.”
For the first year, Hunt said, he will cap enrollment at 100 because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Students, who would range from 14 to 18 years old, will live off-campus with their guardians’ permission, or with host families.
The school, which is structured as a for-profit corporation, will come with an elite price tag: $25,000 a year between tuition and soccer-related costs, not including room and board.
“It is a lot of money,” Hunt said, “but we crunched the numbers to be able to pay our teachers, to travel to all these tournaments and have hotels included. Our fee is just about what other private schools plus club soccer would be.”
He pointed out students would also have access to private tutoring for college-entrance tests, plus round-the-clock access to athletic facilities. Some students also will be eligible for tuition assistance of up to $7,500.
Some details about the school’s academic and athletic plans have yet to fully take shape.
The school will not be part of the Indiana High School Athletic Association, so Hunt is working to determine how and where its team will compete. He said the team will likely compete in a regional “travel” league. Examples could include the Great Lakes Conference and Midwest Conference under US Youth Soccer.

Although the school will occupy a 35,000-square-foot building, it does not yet have an outdoor practice space. Hunt has had an early discussion with the city of Mishawaka about converting a city field for use by the school.
Ken Prince, Mishawaka’s city planner, said a preliminary talk several months ago centered on the baseball field at Henry Frank Park, off Day Road, as the best option. But he said the details of the idea, including potential improvements to the field and a financial arrangement, would still have to be worked out.
“We’re supportive,” Prince said of the school. “It’s a great concept if they can pull it off.”
Academically, Hunt is working on filling out the school’s planned staff of six full-time teachers. He said there are three open teaching positions for science, social studies and Spanish, which will be the school’s sole foreign language offering.
The school would not be accredited for its first year, but will seek accreditation, likely through the state of Indiana, for the 2022-2023 year, Hunt said. He said the school will teach to the state’s “Core 40” curriculum standards.
Private schools are not required to have accreditation. But a private school can choose to seek full accreditation from the state by participating in the same requirements that apply to public schools, including the ILEARN test and the state’s letter-grade rating system for schools.
“We would prefer the state come in and look at us to make sure we meet state standards,” Hunt said. “We want to give (students) the best education possible, and that really starts with the accreditation during year one.”
Because the school is structured as an S-corporation, it is required to have a board of directors. But because Hunt is the sole owner, he said, he will have the exclusive right to appoint the board members.
The International Soccer Academy of America is just Hunt’s latest big dream. In 2015, while still in high school, he ran for Mishawaka City Council.
As a city council candidate, he said, he took exception to the focus on his age. Now, he still hopes people will judge him by his qualifications.
After high school, he was an assistant coach for Marian’s top-ranked soccer team, and went on to be a manager for Bethel soccer. He earned a bachelor’s degree in sport management at Bethel, and this year got a master’s through an online program from the Autonomous University of Barcelona, in Spain. He also has a coaching diploma from United Soccer Coaches and took courses on soccer management, scouting and analytics from a company called Sports Management Worldwide.
Hunt has a lot at stake. He signed a six-year lease with the YMCA of Michiana for the 35,000-square-foot building, and he said he has invested a six-figure sum of money in the school, though he did not specify the amount.
But Hunt said he believes he has the market research showing the school’s appeal, and he welcomes the responsibility of determining its fate.
“I wouldn’t have done this if I didn’t feel confident in the project,” he said. “If it succeeds, great. If not, that’s on me.”
 
Interesting, although I’m a bit skeptical a 23-year old, with likely little to no school experience can pull it off. If you are only doing 2 hours of soccer a day after school, why not just go to a good private school and play on the local elite team or the academy actually associated with an MLS team?
 
The only way this works in Europe is the initial clubs getting a piece of the transfer fees when one of their players make it big. That way the talent is identified not the country club mentality of someone being the club champion but in reality kind of sucks.

The good news is the US soccer federation has finally wised up and allowed transfer fees to be paid to clubs. I'm sure they will still screw it up with some stupid rules but academies in the US can finally start getting paid for identifying and developing talent.

The Ajax academy is probably the best in the world at doing this. They have some ridiculously high success rate that if you are 17 and still playing for them there is something like an 80 percent likelihood you will sign a pro contract. Ajax gets paid when you do...not 25k a year while you are there
 
Yeah, this is for some gullible parents. If your kid is good, and they're playing for some team, going to tryouts, going to an open MLS Academy tryout, they're going to get found pretty quickly if they're good enough.

No different than CRSA or any youth club claiming that playing for them will give you the best chance to be a college player.

No dude it won't. Stop down and play in the mexican league locally....if you can't hang you aren't good enough and probably won't be good enough
 
Yeah, this is for some gullible parents. If your kid is good, and they're playing for some team, going to tryouts, going to an open MLS Academy tryout, they're going to get found pretty quickly if they're good enough.
Yup. Basically just a cash grab to suck money from upper class parents who think their kids are the next big stars.....
 
Interesting, although I’m a bit skeptical a 23-year old, with likely little to no school experience can pull it off. If you are only doing 2 hours of soccer a day after school, why not just go to a good private school and play on the local elite team or the academy actually associated with an MLS team?

I'm not sure how much practice they do on the weekends but 2 hours a day sounds kind of light.

I also was curious about how a 23 year old came up with the cash to do this sort of thing.

I mean I'd like to see it succeed because I presume it would be good for the area but I strongly question it.
 
My kids play club soccer and there are three things that I’ve noticed separate young players

1. speed and quickness - something you really can’t teach either. Some kids just have natural bursts and quick hips, other have to learn to use their bodies to try and overcome this

2. footwork - this just takes dedication, you can tell the kids that just do nothing but kick the ball nonstop at home, in their basement, garage, wherever.

3. Toughness - soccer is a rough sport with a lot of falls and elbows to the face. Mental and physical toughness is really hard some young players and those that can take a pounding usually excel
 
The while idea is so ridiculous we haven't even commented on location. South bend indiana? Really?

As a business model you might be able to make it work somewhere like LA. Maybe but probably not even there.

The problem with US soccer isn't a lack of places where people can pay money to play soccer. It is the opposite problem. Some poor mexican kid doesn't even make the varsity team at the high school because club players (rich kids) take the spots.
 
  • Like
Reactions: onlyTheObvious
I'm not sure how much practice they do on the weekends but 2 hours a day sounds kind of light.

I also was curious about how a 23 year old came up with the cash to do this sort of thing.

I mean I'd like to see it succeed because I presume it would be good for the area but I strongly question it.

If they are 23 and aren't already playing pro they aren't good enough.
 
My kids play club soccer and there are three things that I’ve noticed separate young players

1. speed and quickness - something you really can’t teach either. Some kids just have natural bursts and quick hips, other have to learn to use their bodies to try and overcome this

2. footwork - this just takes dedication, you can tell the kids that just do nothing but kick the ball nonstop at home, in their basement, garage, wherever.

3. Toughness - soccer is a rough sport with a lot of falls and elbows to the face. Mental and physical toughness is really hard some young players and those that can take a pounding usually excel

I would add especially for boys....thinking a kid is going to be great at 17 because they are better than everyone when they are 12.

Funny thing happens between those ages for boys
 
Although I am fuzzy on the details, as I have not asked real specific questions, I do know a well to do family that has their 15'ish year old son in a program like this...only for hockey, not soccer. I was pretty surprised to learn that they essentially shipped their son off to an academy for youth hockey...but they did.

So...there may well be some soccer minded folks that would ante up to get their kids the best soccer instruction, etc. Sounds kind of crazy to me.

Come to think of it...one of my sons was doing pretty well as a youth soccer player 15'ish years ago and we were encouraged to send him to some sort of Olympic development camp for additional, specialized training, etc.

It felt like a money grab to me and I really didn't think about it too long before declining the invitation. After all, who was going to mow the lawn for me if our son was living elsewhere? :) But I think there is a market there for wealthy parents who want to "give their kid every opportunity for success", etc.
 
My kids play club soccer and there are three things that I’ve noticed separate young players

1. speed and quickness - something you really can’t teach either. Some kids just have natural bursts and quick hips, other have to learn to use their bodies to try and overcome this

2. footwork - this just takes dedication, you can tell the kids that just do nothing but kick the ball nonstop at home, in their basement, garage, wherever.

3. Toughness - soccer is a rough sport with a lot of falls and elbows to the face. Mental and physical toughness is really hard some young players and those that can take a pounding usually excel
You mean your kids aren't going to eventually be Iowa football players that help us win a national championship!?!?
 
  • Like
Reactions: naturalbornhawk
If they are 23 and aren't already playing pro they aren't good enough.

No the guy running the academy is 23. That doesn't mean that they couldn't coach up a few pros.

But again if I had all that money I don't see why I wouldn't send my kid to someplace with people who have actually coached up pros before.

I mean ideally I would want to get my kid into Dortmund's academy in Germany. They seem to be turning out young stars like it's nothing.
 
Although I am fuzzy on the details, as I have not asked real specific questions, I do know a well to do family that has their 15'ish year old son in a program like this...only for hockey, not soccer. I was pretty surprised to learn that they essentially shipped their son off to an academy for youth hockey...but they did.

So...there may well be some soccer minded folks that would ante up to get their kids the best soccer instruction, etc. Sounds kind of crazy to me.

Come to think of it...one of my sons was doing pretty well as a youth soccer player 15'ish years ago and we were encouraged to send him to some sort of Olympic development camp for additional, specialized training, etc.

It felt like a money grab to me and I really didn't think about it too long before declining the invitation. After all, who was going to mow the lawn for me if our son was living elsewhere? :) But I think there is a market there for wealthy parents who want to "give their kid every opportunity for success", etc.

I was in the olympic development program when I was 17. At that time it wasn't a cash grab but a way to identify a pool of players for the national team. I made it to the regional pool level but didn't ever make it to the national pool.

In reality it was stupid because the national team was mostly from the same few clubs and the selection was influenced by coaches that had worked for those clubs. Very insular and explain why we have sucked at developing talent in soccer from everywhere in this country. We face some of the same problems now even with mls academies because it is still so insular.
 
Although I am fuzzy on the details, as I have not asked real specific questions, I do know a well to do family that has their 15'ish year old son in a program like this...only for hockey, not soccer. I was pretty surprised to learn that they essentially shipped their son off to an academy for youth hockey...but they did.

So...there may well be some soccer minded folks that would ante up to get their kids the best soccer instruction, etc. Sounds kind of crazy to me.

Come to think of it...one of my sons was doing pretty well as a youth soccer player 15'ish years ago and we were encouraged to send him to some sort of Olympic development camp for additional, specialized training, etc.

It felt like a money grab to me and I really didn't think about it too long before declining the invitation. After all, who was going to mow the lawn for me if our son was living elsewhere? :) But I think there is a market there for wealthy parents who want to "give their kid every opportunity for success", etc.

I think there are a lot better options if you have that kind of money. The ideal option IMO is to try to get your kid into one of the academies in Europe. Dortmund's academy in particular seems to churn out young talent like crazy.

The second best option would probably be an MLS academy.
 
No the guy running the academy is 23. That doesn't mean that they couldn't coach up a few pros.

But again if I had all that money I don't see why I wouldn't send my kid to someplace with people who have actually coached up pros before.

I mean ideally I would want to get my kid into Dortmund's academy in Germany. They seem to be turning out young stars like it's nothing.

If your kid is good enough you wouldn't pay for them to go to Dortmund. They would pay
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jackie Treehorn
My kids play club soccer and there are three things that I’ve noticed separate young players

1. speed and quickness - something you really can’t teach either. Some kids just have natural bursts and quick hips, other have to learn to use their bodies to try and overcome this

2. footwork - this just takes dedication, you can tell the kids that just do nothing but kick the ball nonstop at home, in their basement, garage, wherever.

3. Toughness - soccer is a rough sport with a lot of falls and elbows to the face. Mental and physical toughness is really hard some young players and those that can take a pounding usually excel

My daughter is a 2012 on a competitive club and I would add that being able to find space and create space is number 4. One thing that has helped a lot of American born soccer players is being able to watch soccer on TV, high level soccer. I watch Premier league with her and she gets positioning, the offense and defense strategy, why they are passing here or there.

When I go to her games the only stat I track is completed passes, which IMO is the most important stat since team rankings don't begin till U11.
 
I think there are a lot better options if you have that kind of money. The ideal option IMO is to try to get your kid into one of the academies in Europe. Dortmund's academy in particular seems to churn out young talent like crazy.

The second best option would probably be an MLS academy.
I'm not sure that an MLS Academy isn't THE best choice looking at the world soccer scene recently....

Alphonso Davies - Vancouver Whitecaps - Bayern Munich (FIFA World Best XI at his position, Champions League Winner)
Zach Steffen - Philadelphia Union (studying under Andre Blake) -> New #1 in goal at Manchester City.
Tyler Adams - NY Red Bulls -> RB Leipzig regular
Matthew Hoppe - LA Galaxy -> Schalke (hat-trick debut last weekend)
Gio Reyna - NYCFC -> Borussia Dortmund regular
Weston McKennie - FC Dallas -> Juventus regular
DeAndre Yedlin - Seattle Sounders -> Newcastle regular
Reggie Cannon - FC Dallas -> Boavista regular
Chris Richards - FC Dallas -> Bayern Munich substitute
Erik Palmer-Brown - KC Sporting -> Manchester City (on loan in Austria)
Brendon Aaronson - Philadelphia Union -> Red Bull Salzburg
Damian Las - Chicago Fire -> Fulham
Chituru Odunze - Vancouver Whitecaps -> Leicester City

And this list is only growing...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: hawkedoff
I'm sure the core education they'll receive will be top notch.🤣

Oh well, the world needs ditch diggers who can kick a round ball good too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ghost80
My kids play club soccer and there are three things that I’ve noticed separate young players

1. speed and quickness - something you really can’t teach either. Some kids just have natural bursts and quick hips, other have to learn to use their bodies to try and overcome this

2. footwork - this just takes dedication, you can tell the kids that just do nothing but kick the ball nonstop at home, in their basement, garage, wherever.

3. Toughness - soccer is a rough sport with a lot of falls and elbows to the face. Mental and physical toughness is really hard some young players and those that can take a pounding usually excel

For young kids the most important thing is touches. Getting in as many touches as possible. In general I think American programs often focus too much on matches.
The problem with this is that the best method for being successful in winning matches isn't always the best way to develop players. Particularly developing technical skills. Match focused clubs have a tendency to discourage players taking chances. The only way to get better at taking on players is to do it over and over and to fail many times. A lot of the developmental academies focus extensively on small sided games. Up to age 12 Ajax only has 3 practices and 1 game per week. They encourage their players to play outside the academy in pick up games and other sports.
 
My daughter is a 2012 on a competitive club and I would add that being able to find space and create space is number 4. One thing that has helped a lot of American born soccer players is being able to watch soccer on TV, high level soccer. I watch Premier league with her and she gets positioning, the offense and defense strategy, why they are passing here or there.

When I go to her games the only stat I track is completed passes, which IMO is the most important stat since team rankings don't begin till U11.

That is a terrible stat to track at such a young age. All that does is teach a young player to receive the ball and give it up. They will win a lot of games that way of course but have very few players realize their true potential because they haven't taken any risk or learned how to handle pressure. Young players need to lose the ball a lot by taking other kids on. They need compressed space so they can't just kick and run and they cant hide from the ball.

Youth clubs like to do this passing thing because they will absolutely best other youth teams and that is a wonderful selling point to parents.
 
I'm not sure that an MLS Academy isn't THE best choice looking at the world soccer scene recently....

Alphonso Davies (FIFA World Best XI at his position, Champions League Winner)
Zach Steffen - Philadelphia Union (studying under Andre Blake) -> New #1 in goal at Manchester City.
Tyler Adams - NY Red Bulls -> RB Leipzig regular
Matthew Hoppe - LA Galaxy -> Schalke (hat-trick debut last weekend)
Gio Reyna - NYCFC -> Borussia Dortmund regular
Weston McKennie - FC Dallas -> Juventus regular
DeAndre Yedlin - Seattle Sounders -> Newcastle regular
Reggie Cannon - FC Dallas -> Boavista regular
Chris Richards - FC Dallas -> Bayern Munich substitute
Erik Palmer-Brown - KC Sporting -> Manchester City (on loan in Austria)
Brendon Aaronson - Philadelphia Union -> Red Bull Salzburg
Damian Las - Chicago Fire -> Fulham
Chituru Odunze - Vancouver Whitecaps -> Leicester City

And this list is only growing...

Reyna was also a part of Dortmund's academy before his career took off.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menace Sockeyes
Reyna was also a part of Dortmund's academy before his career took off.
Yeah, it helps when your father is a Bundesliga veteran and a former World Cup Best XI too. The best on this list is Alphonso Davies, and he went from academy, to playing in a senior MLS squad for three years (sub, then starter, then star over those years), and straight into Bayern Munich with hardly missing a beat. Now he's considered the best left back in the world, with zero European academy training.
 
Yeah, it helps when your father is a Bundesliga veteran and a former World Cup Best XI too. The best on this list is Alphonso Davies, and he went from academy, to playing in a senior MLS squad for three years (sub, then starter, then star over those years), and straight into Bayern Munich with hardly missing a beat. Now he's considered the best left back in the world, with zero European academy training.

Was wondering why I hadn't heard about him. . . because he's Canadian dang it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menace Sockeyes
Was wondering why I hadn't heard about him. . . because he's Canadian dang it.
Yeah. And that actually helped him immensely. His breakout into stardom was the 2017 Gold Cup, where he won the Golden Boot as a 16 year old left winger for Canada. Doubtful he would have had that opportunity on the USMNT.
 
The while idea is so ridiculous we haven't even commented on location. South bend indiana? Really?

As a business model you might be able to make it work somewhere like LA. Maybe but probably not even there.

The problem with US soccer isn't a lack of places where people can pay money to play soccer. It is the opposite problem. Some poor mexican kid doesn't even make the varsity team at the high school because club players (rich kids) take the spots.

Just curious as I never played growing up and my kids are super young, but why would the poor Mexican kid not make the varsity HS team if he was better? Or are you saying the rich kids are now better since they’ve had so much training?
 
Just curious as I never played growing up and my kids are super young, but why would the poor Mexican kid not make the varsity HS team if he was better? Or are you saying the rich kids are now better since they’ve had so much training?
I'll let him answer, but as a youth coach on both ends of this (a private pay-to-play club head coaching job, and an urban public school head coaching job), it's going to be the level of coaching they've received for years vs the kid only playing pick-up soccer. If its high level pick-up soccer, that can do some good, but more than likely its not going to give them the coaching/experience they'd need to keep pace of the club players.

The best player is going to be the one that has a blend of both worlds. The years of pick-up games, without coaching, where they have to figure some things out on their own and develop their strengths through their own motivation, and the structured world of youth soccer where they learn nuances and are challenged in ways that make them a more well-rounded player.
 
Just curious as I never played growing up and my kids are super young, but why would the poor Mexican kid not make the varsity HS team if he was better? Or are you saying the rich kids are now better since they’ve had so much training?

I would disagree with him but mostly because that poor immigrant is probably not going to the same high school as the rich kids who all played on costly traveling teams when they where in their middle school/late elementary school years.

But development can start pretty early in soccer, that's helped by the fact that it's a relatively simple game to teach the rules of. Also skill on the ball is a huge deal, something that being bigger, faster, and stronger can't fully make up for.

Athletic ability really can't make up for being able to dribble the ball well nor can it make up for being able to perform a perfect cross or long pass into the box. That's stuff that takes lots and lots of work and practice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menace Sockeyes
They need compressed space so they can't just kick and run and they cant hide from the ball.

I am talking 2012, you are talking 2015. That is 4v4 development strategy as they force the kids into compressed space due to field size. 7v7 you have to be able to complete passes as you are playing on a bigger field. 4v4 has the smaller field, they learn how to beat people and take people on. The expectation is that behavior is already learnt by the next level. Not perfect, but learnt.

If kids still can't take on other kids at 7v7 level, then I don't know what to tell them other than this sport is not for you.
 
Just curious as I never played growing up and my kids are super young, but why would the poor Mexican kid not make the varsity HS team if he was better? Or are you saying the rich kids are now better since they’ve had so much training?

I am not sure what states the other posters are in, I assume Iowa and the Midwest in general. For a "poor Mexican kid" they would likely grow up playing in the "Mexican leagues" through their youth years and if they were a very high level player they would go to a top club/academy no different than a wealthy white player.

Very few top players down here play high school soccer, most play club year round. The players who are playing high school soccer tend to be the weaker club players. Some high level players will play freshman year, but the high school programs in general have been struggling to keep good players.
 
Interesting idea. But, they don’t have a field yet. Which will be very expensive to maintain. And, it’s in a northern climate, which will limit their training.

I’d think an MLS Academy or a top regional club would be a better option.
Isn’t Shattuck in MN somewhat of a boarding school/soccer academy?
 
Travel ball and pay to play sports academies have really diluted the talent levels of soccer and baseball in America. Probably why you’re seeing a huge infusion of Latin American players in MLB over the past few years. Same with soccer and all the suburban white kids playing.

There’s no substitute for natural athleticism. Lot of highly trained but physically limited athletes out there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkedoff
Interesting idea. But, they don’t have a field yet. Which will be very expensive to maintain. And, it’s in a northern climate, which will limit their training.

I’d think an MLS Academy or a top regional club would be a better option.
Isn’t Shattuck in MN somewhat of a boarding school/soccer academy?

It’s a prep hockey school but has all the other sports too. A lot of these kids aren’t paying to play like others are. Sidney Crosby played at SSM.
 
Just curious as I never played growing up and my kids are super young, but why would the poor Mexican kid not make the varsity HS team if he was better? Or are you saying the rich kids are now better since they’ve had so much training?

Because they the club players are system players and would have played with each other a lot. The new guy gets frozen out because he doesn't come from the system they play within. You see with a lot of these club players and attitude towards high school soccer and the coaches that their club knows better because it plays at a higher level against better competition. What those players leave out is that they have for the most part only played within that system. They are robots.

The mexican kid will likely be technically better with the ball but will not fit with the club players game philosophy. In other words what to do with the ball when is much more scripted within a lot of clubs and to be on the field you follow the script. The mexican guys I used to play with are just as disciplined but don't follow the script the clubs have laid out. They okay a much quicker short pass type of game that has individual flair. That pisses off the club players because it doesn't follow the script.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SalAunese
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT