ADVERTISEMENT

Back from the Rose Bowl....my thoughts on the trip....

I was surprised they threw the long pass, but generally agree with the perspective that if we don't want them to do that to us then stop the play. However, after they threw that pass it really pissed me off when their fans then booed because we called timeout to try to score again. Fine, you can try to score a meaningless TD, but don't boo when we try.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BDJHawk
One question I have for you or anyone in the know is WHY did Stanford look so much better prepared than Iowa?

That is a GREAT question. If I truly knew the answer, I'd apply immediately to join the coaching staff ; )

My thoughts (mind you, these are not excuses!) as to what may have played a role:
1) Stanford's experience with the stadium environment and grass surface (2 games in 2012, 1 game 2013, 1 game 2014). My kid mentioned that the grass surface required him to put a lot of pressure down on his plant foot in order to get a good grip, more so than usual. The Hawks practiced on the soccer fields adjacent to the LA galaxy field, where the grass was much longer and had a sandy base. It's been 25 yrs since the Hawks played, so none of the current team had any experience with this particular stadium's atmosphere.
2) stanford had far fewer bowl-prep practices than the Hawks, so perhaps they were more fresh? I wonder whether this affected the play of our O/D-lines, cuz they got manhandled. This, more than anything else, was what shocked me the most about the game. I was certain we'd control the line of scrimmage. : (
3) coaching staff (and players) did not truly appreciate McAffrey's (sp) speed, prior to the game. As a ST coach, I routinely advocate for a coffin-corner punt against dangerous returners that our team faces. For whatever reason, this type of punt is no longer seen in the college or pro games. Not sure why. I'd have advocated its use in the RB.
4) it didn't seem like we adjusted to the DL pressure CJB was facing in the game

I'm a ST coach, and have no experience in offensive or defensive play-calling. That being said, my thoughts on solutions to these problems:
1) request that the team be supplied with a practice field that has a surface identical to the game surface (I know, I know, that would be likely $$$$)
2) I know that KF occasionally visits other team's facilities/programs in the off-season. I specifically think it would be worth it for them to visit with former Stanford coaches (or coaches familiar with Stanford's program) in the off-season, to pick their brains about bowl prep. I think our regular season prep is great, but with all the additional intangibles prior to bowl games, they may require a different approach.
3) consider coffin-corner punting when facing dangerous returners
4) consider incorporating analytics into pre-game scouting, to objectively analyze opponent trends, and scheme accordingly. This can be applied in-game as well, of course. For example, once it became apparent our OL couldn't contain the rush, consider a screen pass, draw, etc, to exploit their aggression against them (Sun Tzu philosophy).

Disclaimer: these are my thoughts, not anyone else's. Also, I have no idea how the UI coaching staff preps the team for games. For all I know, they may have already considered these things, or discarded them as junk, lol.
 
That is a GREAT question. If I truly knew the answer, I'd apply immediately to join the coaching staff ; )

My thoughts (mind you, these are not excuses!) as to what may have played a role:
1) Stanford's experience with the stadium environment and grass surface (2 games in 2012, 1 game 2013, 1 game 2014). My kid mentioned that the grass surface required him to put a lot of pressure down on his plant foot in order to get a good grip, more so than usual. The Hawks practiced on the soccer fields adjacent to the LA galaxy field, where the grass was much longer and had a sandy base. It's been 25 yrs since the Hawks played, so none of the current team had any experience with this particular stadium's atmosphere.
2) stanford had far fewer bowl-prep practices than the Hawks, so perhaps they were more fresh? I wonder whether this affected the play of our O/D-lines, cuz they got manhandled. This, more than anything else, was what shocked me the most about the game. I was certain we'd control the line of scrimmage. : (
3) coaching staff (and players) did not truly appreciate McAffrey's (sp) speed, prior to the game. As a ST coach, I routinely advocate for a coffin-corner punt against dangerous returners that our team faces. For whatever reason, this type of punt is no longer seen in the college or pro games. Not sure why. I'd have advocated its use in the RB.
4) it didn't seem like we adjusted to the DL pressure CJB was facing in the game

I'm a ST coach, and have no experience in offensive or defensive play-calling. That being said, my thoughts on solutions to these problems:
1) request that the team be supplied with a practice field that has a surface identical to the game surface (I know, I know, that would be likely $$$$)
2) I know that KF occasionally visits other team's facilities/programs in the off-season. I specifically think it would be worth it for them to visit with former Stanford coaches (or coaches familiar with Stanford's program) in the off-season, to pick their brains about bowl prep. I think our regular season prep is great, but with all the additional intangibles prior to bowl games, they may require a different approach.
3) consider coffin-corner punting when facing dangerous returners
4) consider incorporating analytics into pre-game scouting, to objectively analyze opponent trends, and scheme accordingly. This can be applied in-game as well, of course. For example, once it became apparent our OL couldn't contain the rush, consider a screen pass, draw, etc, to exploit their aggression against them (Sun Tzu philosophy).

Disclaimer: these are my thoughts, not anyone else's. Also, I have no idea how the UI coaching staff preps the team for games. For all I know, they may have already considered these things, or discarded them as junk, lol.
Thank you very kindly, and also thanks to ALL the players and coaches for a truly wonderful season. One game shouldn't define this years team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rivercityjazzman
83, the players cared.... ALOT. They, and not the fans, were the ones that won 12 games in 2015. Not saying this to be antagonistic, but they didn't get this far by not caring or being apathetic. They overcame many obstacles to get to that point. They felt absolutely terrible about letting their fans down in that manner, and it really hurt having to send off the seniors in that way. These words were paraphrased from my conversation with my kid (who is a Hawk player).

I do think they ran into an opponent that was clearly better than them, and they were outplayed and out coached. This is nothing to hang their head about in the long run - as long as they use this to help them refocus for 2016, and carry on the turnaround started in 2015. With continued good play on the field, improved recruiting, and tweaking of bowl game coaching/game prep, the program will undoubtedly improve. This is the key, IMO. Go Hawks!!

Thank your kid for me, too...it was an incredible season, and those players gave their all week after week. This is the 3rd Rose Bowl in my lifetime for the Hawks and I hope we never go to another one in my lifetime - we're cursed. Hope the non-senior players get after it in the offseason and use the Rose Bowl as a motivator to push themselves to be the best they can be...on the field, and in what comes after.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rivercityjazzman
Thank you very kindly, and also thanks to ALL the players and coaches for a truly wonderful season. One game shouldn't define this years team.

It doesnt. This was a 12 win football team and nobody can take that from them.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT