Like every NIL recipient, he got paid on what he projected to offer the program, not what he has brought to the program. This is the inherent problem with NIL, and why it cannot be sustained for most schools/fanbases. You can only be asked to invest in some blue sky start up company so many times before you say, Pass.
Can't blame him if he's offered a ton of money to come here. No one would say, Let me prove myself first to be worthy, and then I'll take the money. Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't recall a big pushback at the time when he announced he was coming to Iowa that fans were skeptical or concerned that he was being paid a huge sum of money before he produced anything for Iowa. After 3 years of Petrus, most were very happy about him coming to Iowa, regardless of what he was being paid. But, this experience (and that of the guy who took the NIL for a sum before going back to a school down south) will certainly cause skepticism going forward. I imagine other fanbases feel the same way.
Thank Cade for the effort, but he's not entitled to anything other than a shot. He took it. It wasn't working. I do suspect we'll see him again, and we may (emphasis on "may") be glad he's around if Sullivan gets banged up. The QB room is pretty thin right now (which is a whole different topic).