ADVERTISEMENT

Definition of insanity

3, 2,1, here come all the same guys saying M* is such a great recruiter. Time to bring in new coaches with far bigger names than M*, Telford and Dennis. And move Terry over to run the HWC. Or, we can keep getting stomped in recruiting and on the mat.
 
Telford...gone or reassigned.
Star...recruiting only, if that's allowed.
Bring in somebody like Ware from Oklahoma. J Den, if available.
Something needs to change. Unless fans are happy with second place.
I get what you're saying.
I wish we could do it by keeping the staff and adding some "big names" to the HWC. J Den would be a great start. I honestly think we have an excellent staff and could help ourselves a lot with quality additions to the HWC.
 
There is something to high end prehab/rehab I'm no D1 wrestler and I'm 59 but I can say this stuff has kept me lifting heavy for 45 years.
And relatively injury free. The injuries I've had ( biggest one was a ruptured patella tendon at age 51. Ten months later I was lifting more than my injury date.

No one gives a single shit about your weightlifting. Please stop.
 
the facts don’t support the style criticism. iowa has scored pretty much as many bonus points and more back points than psu over the past few years. success has a funny way of changing perceptions because guys like rby, starroci, and brooks have all not been huge point scorers for the most part. starroci was a lot better this past year though.

Everyone is disappointed that the 133 slot wasn't filled. 184/197 with True was a given.

However, I don't think this is an "insanity" definition of doing the same thing over and over again expecting different results. Iowa has made changes to get better, and I believe will continue to. A kid merely selected PSU because God told him to do it. That's between him and the almighty.

Iowa carries on, and I do believe will have 2 more guys join by next semester. And, good HS prospects to sign and along with transfers in the future.

The playing field is level....but no one wins every game, not even that team back East.
Bob - first of thanks for all that you have done for Iowa wrestling. My frustration is that we may have changed things in the past, it seems like our style has stayed the same, our staff is still the same and all Iowa ties, we are still not getting enough recruits, and if anything it seems like we have doubled down. It wasn't just that Iowa missed on Nagao, it was that they finished a distant 2nd at NCAA's, then missed on Truax, Nagao, and had PSU have a much better recruiting class.

I would love to see a staff shakeup, as as good as our staff is, I would say the results have not been there for some of our guys. We also need to re-examine training, strength, etc.. You may say we have just been unlucky with injuries, but having as many as we have compared to PSU, I would say it is not just luck at this point. Bring in the outside critics to see what they believe and truly be open to new ideas.

Finally the perception that is out there, real or not, is not helping us. PSU is the place you go to have fun, train smartly, and peak at Nationals. We need to learn to self promote, change the narrative, and I realize that is not what the Brands are probably comfortable doing.
 
The craziest thing about all of this… is how much everyone still hates Iowa but loves PSU. Maybe it’s just my bias but it feels like Iowa gets the biggest cheers against and PSU gets the biggest cheers for from the collective fans at Big Tens and Nationals. Like, PSU is beating the brakes off of everybody but everyone holds a hatred so deep for Iowa that they can’t see past it and just love bowing to their new master.
 
The craziest thing about all of this… is how much everyone still hates Iowa but loves PSU. Maybe it’s just my bias but it feels like Iowa gets the biggest cheers against and PSU gets the biggest cheers for from the collective fans at Big Tens and Nationals. Like, PSU is beating the brakes off of everybody but everyone holds a hatred so deep for Iowa that they can’t see past it and just love bowing to their new master.
Good points. I experienced similar in St. Louis 2015 when tOSU won.

Why do you think this is?

Lots of older original B10 alum with long-lasting memories of suffering decades of dominance?

Ok State traveling well while hoping to preserve its historical place as the university with the most championships?

In St Louis, PSU and tOSU traveling well could explain both Iowa jeers and PSU cheers.
 
Good points. I experienced similar in St. Louis 2015 when tOSU won.

Why do you think this is?

Lots of older original B10 alum with long-lasting memories of suffering decades of dominance?

Ok State traveling well while hoping to preserve its historical place as the university with the most championships?

In St Louis, PSU and tOSU traveling well could explain both Iowa jeers and PSU cheers.
I think there may be an older contingent that still dislikes Iowa and their fans, with some of that being passed along through generations. I also think that a lot of the younger folk look up to National Champions, and that’s a large amount of PSU wrestlers from their formative years.
 
The single biggest problem Iowa has had, compared to Penn St, is RECRUITING. Iowa got a consensus elite recruit in Spencer Lee, and he produced, right out of the gate.

PSU gets boatloads of them on a fairly regular basis. Until that disparity gets corrected, Iowa will struggle to win another team title.
 
At this point no coach iowa could get would come close to Cael. Idk how you change the staff to make iowa more appealing to recruits and transfers… until Cael is done all other teams can only hope to get a few titles if everything goes right for them. It’s just facts at this point.
TnT are our best option for the next few years at least
 
  • Sad
Reactions: TNTwrestle
Iowa should hire the Flexibility Maestro that AJ Ferrari has been working with to train the entire team. Flexibility training is great for injury prevention. Take some of the "250K" offered to Truax and put it toward a specialized 6 month program specifically tailored to each guy. AJ started back in January and he's at a full front splits and and I'd say 90-95% or more of the way to a full side splits. Need to try to find unique ways to gain an edge. Nutrition/Strength/Conditioning/Recovery/Flexibility/Training all need to be evaluated (and I'm not saying they already aren't constantly evaluated).

I'd also be interested in seeing the strength and conditioning program Yianni used in his comeback from his ACL repair. That guy was always putting his knees in precarious positions sitting the corner, shin whizzers, rubber knee defense and he still seemed just as gumby after his injury as before. Austin O'Connor too for that matter, looked better than ever after his ACL repair.

I don't want to feed into the stereotype that is clearly being used against Iowa - that we overtrain and grind our guys down. That being said, the optics of us always having high profile guys being injured the past handful of years has definitely negatively affected the perception of us, right or wrong, justified or not. Just read through wrestling social media on twitter/facebook/instagram and other forums. I can't help but feel like this played a small part in tipping the scales towards PSU in the portal sweepstakes so far this off season. Most of the freak injuries we've had have happened in matches (Eierman/Lee/Kemerer/Marinelli) but still it's worth looking at every angle.
To expand on this. Take a look at the Treigning Lab instagram page if you're so inclined. It's filled with PSU wrestlers and MMA fighters. The connection has long been known, but I'm guessing it plays a major factor in staying healthy and all of the things mentioned above. Aaron Pico, Helen Maroulis, Cassar, Brooks, Starocci, Nickal, Yianni D, Gilman, Dake, Snyder. Basically every NLWC athlete and PSU stud wrestler plus others.

We need to have our own "treigning lab". A true specialist who is an expert on weight management, bulking/cutting, and has it down to a science. When you take the guesswork out of making weight, I'm sure that's just one less stressor on the mind of PSU athletes.

Here is an example of their sales pitch - it's a picture of Cassar at 240 lbs and a pic of Cassar making weight at 206 lbs for MMA side by side.

"A solid 240 lbs of rock hard muscle down to a lean, mean fighting machine. @ant_thechamp_cassar made weight at 206 lbs for his pro MMA debut without missing a beat. Or a meal.

-Weight management is what we do!

-Bulk or cut - we run the numbers and take the guesswork out of weight management!

-You do your part; we'll do ours!

-We call it Success through Science!

-Because numbers don't lie!"

So get Mr. Flexibility Maestro, and Mr. Treigning Lab or someone like him both on the payroll. Please and thank you @bnicolls 😇

 
Last edited:
I just finished off a dinner plate full of Morel Mushrooms. My whole outlook and confidence in the Iowa Hawkeye Wrestling Program is sky high.
I did some morels once and saw the trunk of a tree on fire. I think psu practices a more holistic approach. Either way one of the coaches has a dead eye for talent. For sure.
 
The single biggest problem Iowa has had, compared to Penn St, is RECRUITING. Iowa got a consensus elite recruit in Spencer Lee, and he produced, right out of the gate.

PSU gets boatloads of them on a fairly regular basis. Until that disparity gets corrected, Iowa will struggle to win another team title.
It is 83% this. We get kem, psu gets nolf. We get marinelli, psu gets mark hall and Joseph. No knock on kem or the bull as they were top tier studs themselves but…hall pinned marinelli in their last high school match and Joseph beat kem, as I recall. And nolf was Nolf. Outside of Spencer, kem and bull were our highest recruits in how long? Psu has had recruits of that caliber riding the pine or transferring. It has only gotten worse as far as I can tell and will continue trending in that direction. Unfortunately.
 
It is 83% this. We get kem, psu gets nolf. We get marinelli, psu gets mark hall and Joseph. No knock on kem or the bull as they were top tier studs themselves but…hall pinned marinelli in their last high school match and Joseph beat kem, as I recall. And nolf was Nolf. Outside of Spencer, kem and bull were our highest recruits in how long? Psu has had recruits of that caliber riding the pine or transferring. It has only gotten worse as far as I can tell and will continue trending in that direction. Unfortunately.
It seems like success for in-state recruits is very high-look at where the top rated Iowa kids in the class of 2023 are all going. But the success for top rated out-of-state recruits is much lower. Not sure why that’s the case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Iowabandwagon
I just started reading this thread so don't know what all has been discussed, but thought I'd give my two cents worth. Whether it be an individual person or a large organization/corporation, when they decide to make a major change, the starting point HAS to be to draw up a PLAN! Not just in your head, in your thoughts, but actually write the plan down, with very specific details of how to accomplish your goals, how to arrive where you want to go.

My suggestion to Tom would be to gather together the HWC board, valued confidants, major donors, and certain current and former wrestlers (ones from outside the program would be especially valuable). Have a two day retreat, and make it clear that you don't want the participants to simply tell Tom what they think he wants to hear - the conversation needs to be very direct, even confrontational if needed.

Someone needs to document the discussions and decisions, and then put together a cohesive plan that can be implemented. Follow-up and periodic status meetings would be crucial, to review the progress made and to make adjustments.
 
the facts don’t support the style criticism. iowa has scored pretty much as many bonus points and more back points than psu over the past few years. success has a funny way of changing perceptions because guys like rby, starroci, and brooks have all not been huge point scorers for the most part. starroci was a lot better this past year though.
The results are facts, right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: bourbon n blues
We have to do 2 things. Period.

1. Recruit better. It's fairly obvious what kind of guys TNT recruit. and it's just sad. This whole "if they want to come to Iowa, they'll come to Iowa" HAS TO END. And it can't just be in the portal. Take a look at what TNT can do with "athletes" - Henry, Spencer, Kem. But this prideful BS that the staff can't be bothered to actually go after someone is unreal.

edit - It's going to take recruits who have a ton of motivation to take down PSU. That should be an easy enough sell.

2. The training has to change. I do know that the training has changed a good bit from Tom's early days and the Metcalf era. But it's not enough. Clearly. It's still too consistently hard for no other reason than just to be hard. It IS ok to come in and get better at wrestling without having to worry about whether your intense enough. And for good lord's sake - reduce the practice time as the season wears on.
 
Last edited:
We have to do 2 things. Period.

1. Recruit better. It's fairly obvious what kind of guys TNT recruit. and it's just sad. This whole "if they want to come to Iowa, they'll come to Iowa" HAS TO END. And it can't just be in the portal. Take a look at what TNT can do with "athletes" - Henry, Spencer, Kem. But this prideful BS that the staff can't be bothered to actually go after someone is unreal.

2. The training has to change. I do know that the training has changed a good bit from Tom's early days and the Metcalf era. But it's not enough. Clearly. It's still too consistently hard for no other reason than just to be hard. It IS ok to come in and get better at wrestling without having to worry about whether your intense enough. And for good lord's sake - reduce the practice time as the season wears on.
It goes back to the days PSU marketed themselves as ***State complete with dodge ball games, imo. Iowa fans laughed until PSU was consistently laughing on the podium.

Then it appears we ratcheted up the intensity to keep up. But that doesn’t appear to be the solution. (Never did to me.)
 
It goes back to the days PSU marketed themselves as ***State complete with dodge ball games, imo. Iowa fans laughed until PSU was consistently laughing on the podium.

Then it appears we ratcheted up the intensity to keep up. But that doesn’t appear to be the solution. (Never did to me.)
Spot on sir.
 
  • Like
Reactions: el dub
It goes back to the days PSU marketed themselves as ***State complete with dodge ball games, imo. Iowa fans laughed until PSU was consistently laughing on the podium.

Then it appears we ratcheted up the intensity to keep up. But that doesn’t appear to be the solution. (Never did to me.)
Rest is as important as training hard, using methods to recover are also needed. There's been a huge shift from back in the days of say the 60s and 70s.
 
  • Like
Reactions: el dub
What was your training regimen? Sounds useful.
giphy.gif
 
What was your training regimen? Sounds useful.
I'm 59 now so I've dialed it way back. When I lifted heavy it was 3-4 days a week with every 4th week a deload, app 60% weight and volume. Weirdly you noticed the weights were light but you felt it. Regular stretching static wise, because I don't have any professional near by to do that. I also go to get soft tissue work done regularly, see a chiropractor, and try to walk 10,000 or more steps a day.
I also do some soft tissue work on my own using these stainless steel tools that look like butter knives.
 
I'm 59 now so I've dialed it way back. When I lifted heavy it was 3-4 days a week with every 4th week a deload, app 60% weight and volume. Weirdly you noticed the weights were light but you felt it. Regular stretching static wise, because I don't have any professional near by to do that. I also go to get soft tissue work done regularly, see a chiropractor, and try to walk 10,000 or more steps a day.
I also do some soft tissue work on my own using these stainless steel tools that look like butter knives.

FFS, can you not take a hint?!
 
The single biggest problem Iowa has had, compared to Penn St, is RECRUITING. Iowa got a consensus elite recruit in Spencer Lee, and he produced, right out of the gate.

PSU gets boatloads of them on a fairly regular basis. Until that disparity gets corrected, Iowa will struggle to win another team title.
it's been an issue for a long time. Too long. Forget about PSU if you can, I don't think they are even recruiting up to the Iowa level.

I really only follow Iowa recruiting. Over and over I hear posters talking about these blue chip hammers in HS that Iowa are in on. They never end up committing. over and over and over.


IMO, there is no reason why a program like Iowa can't recruit more than one blue chip recruit every few years.

Is one a year too much to ask at Iowa? I don't know. It's frustrating as he'll. It's frustrating, for me, without even considering PSU.
 
it's been an issue for a long time. Too long. Forget about PSU if you can, I don't think they are even recruiting up to the Iowa level.

I really only follow Iowa recruiting. Over and over I hear posters talking about these blue chip hammers in HS that Iowa are in on. They never end up committing. over and over and over.


IMO, there is no reason why a program like Iowa can't recruit more than one blue chip recruit every few years.

Is one a year too much to ask at Iowa? I don't know. It's frustrating as he'll. It's frustrating, for me, without even considering PSU.
Agreed. And pointing fingers at team on top of podium isn't helping, imo. We might need a bit of a culture change in the room to attract top talent, imo.
 
We have to do 2 things. Period.

1. Recruit better. It's fairly obvious what kind of guys TNT recruit. and it's just sad. This whole "if they want to come to Iowa, they'll come to Iowa" HAS TO END. And it can't just be in the portal. Take a look at what TNT can do with "athletes" - Henry, Spencer, Kem. But this prideful BS that the staff can't be bothered to actually go after someone is unreal.

edit - It's going to take recruits who have a ton of motivation to take down PSU. That should be an easy enough sell.

2. The training has to change. I do know that the training has changed a good bit from Tom's early days and the Metcalf era. But it's not enough. Clearly. It's still too consistently hard for no other reason than just to be hard. It IS ok to come in and get better at wrestling without having to worry about whether your intense enough. And for good lord's sake - reduce the practice time as the season wears on.

Leave him alone, I want to hear about the butter knives.
All this talk about buttah is making me a little ferklempt
 
  • Like
Reactions: el dub
it's been an issue for a long time. Too long. Forget about PSU if you can, I don't think they are even recruiting up to the Iowa level.

I really only follow Iowa recruiting. Over and over I hear posters talking about these blue chip hammers in HS that Iowa are in on. They never end up committing. over and over and over.


IMO, there is no reason why a program like Iowa can't recruit more than one blue chip recruit every few years.

Is one a year too much to ask at Iowa? I don't know. It's frustrating as he'll. It's frustrating, for me, without even considering PSU.
Let's not forget the boys walking into campus next fall (but some really there now): BK #1 PFP, CC #1 pfp, Arnold very high, and likely should be higher, RB mid level, but rising star. That's a solid group of HS guys.

And too, the portal is not done. Could be a fair amount enter after this weekend.

Forgot: Anthony F committed and not sure how he'd be categorized, but with 4 yrs of eligibility and a RS year to boot.

The above is a good group, and it ain't soup yet. I'm not a patient guy, but let's take Yogi's advice.
 
it's been an issue for a long time. Too long. Forget about PSU if you can, I don't think they are even recruiting up to the Iowa level.

I really only follow Iowa recruiting. Over and over I hear posters talking about these blue chip hammers in HS that Iowa are in on. They never end up committing. over and over and over.


IMO, there is no reason why a program like Iowa can't recruit more than one blue chip recruit every few years.

Is one a year too much to ask at Iowa? I don't know. It's frustrating as he'll. It's frustrating, for me, without even considering PSU.
We are not even #2 when it comes to recruiting. fosu is better. Cornell does well. Even Dresser is better at identifying and pursuing talent. Nebraska does well. NC State does well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fan In Black
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT