ADVERTISEMENT

Do you agree with Tucker Carlson about replacement theory and voting rights?

Only one with an agenda would go so far as to say this is defending white replacement theory. I think it is quite obvious that when a party seems to be very open to migrants coming across illegally and doesn't seem to care about the legal process of doing so and then at the same time are trying to grant all of the people citizenship despite illegally entering the country, the intended reason for doing so is to increase the amount of voters that feel in debt to a specific political party. That is all he is saying.
 
Only one with an agenda would go so far as to say this is defending white replacement theory. I think it is quite obvious that when a party seems to be very open to migrants coming across illegally and doesn't seem to care about the legal process of doing so and then at the same time are trying to grant all of the people citizenship despite illegally entering the country, the intended reason for doing so is to increase the amount of voters that feel in debt to a specific political party. That is all he is saying.

Well, he says the left gets hysterical and calls it replacement and then says that's exactly what happens so I don't think it's a stretch for somebody else to make that claim.

You think when he makes this claim he only means the people that come here illegally? Asylum seekers aren't illegals. You think he isn't in favor of shutting down virtually all immigration of brown people?
 
  • Like
Reactions: seam and torbee
It's a shame that this theory - and similar concepts - are seemingly getting normalized via Fox News rather than ostracized to anonymous online groups or far right organizations.

Hopefully it's limited to this Tucker segment and it doesn't become a popular flavor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lucas80
Only one with an agenda would go so far as to say this is defending white replacement theory. I think it is quite obvious that when a party seems to be very open to migrants coming across illegally and doesn't seem to care about the legal process of doing so and then at the same time are trying to grant all of the people citizenship despite illegally entering the country, the intended reason for doing so is to increase the amount of voters that feel in debt to a specific political party. That is all he is saying.
fallacy-in-logic-straw-man.jpg
 
I agree with him. And also people need to stop having kids. As a current voter, every time someone has a kid that's just 18 years until I have less political power because they are adding to the population and diluting my vote.
 
Well, he says the left gets hysterical and calls it replacement and then says that's exactly what happens so I don't think it's a stretch for somebody else to make that claim.

You think when he makes this claim he only means the people that come here illegally? Asylum seekers aren't illegals. You think he isn't in favor of shutting down virtually all immigration of brown people?
The vast majority of asylum seekers aren't legitimately in need of asylum. So don't go there.

Also, it actually doesn't have anything to do with skin color. He doesn't argue that.

I think he makes a couple leaps here, but they aren't unforeseeable. First off, he assumes that opening the borders to illegals is a precursor to giving them the right to vote. He's also assuming that the right to vote is going to be opened to noncitizens.

He's not entirely wrong, but we are not yet where he seems to believe we are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jamesvanderwulf
The vast majority of asylum seekers aren't legitimately in need of asylum. So don't go there.

Also, it actually doesn't have anything to do with skin color. He doesn't argue that.

I think he makes a couple leaps here, but they aren't unforeseeable. First off, he assumes that opening the borders to illegals is a precursor to giving them the right to vote. He's also assuming that the right to vote is going to be opened to noncitizens.

He's not entirely wrong, but we are not yet where he seems to believe we are.
Someone needs to watch the Jon Oliver segment.
 
The vast majority of asylum seekers aren't legitimately in need of asylum. So don't go there.

Also, it actually doesn't have anything to do with skin color. He doesn't argue that.

I think he makes a couple leaps here, but they aren't unforeseeable. First off, he assumes that opening the borders to illegals is a precursor to giving them the right to vote. He's also assuming that the right to vote is going to be opened to noncitizens.

He's not entirely wrong, but we are not yet where he seems to believe we are.

He's smart enough not to add brown in front of immigrants. But nobody believes he is talking about somebody coming from England when he makes the case they are destroying our heritage and making the country dirty.

Yes, he has nailed it if you assume the worst of the people you don't agree with and just assume they will eventually do what you think they will do. So as long as his assumptions hold, nailed it.
 
He's smart enough not to add brown in front of immigrants. But nobody believes he is talking about somebody coming from England when he makes the case they are destroying our heritage and making the country dirty.

Yes, he has nailed it if you assume the worst of the people you don't agree with and just assume they will eventually do what you think they will do. So as long as his assumptions hold, nailed it.
They aren't destroying our heritage. He's wrong about that.

Do you deny that the reason Dems have flipped so hard left on the border is that they see a major advantage to making immigrants voters? It's not about race. It's about votes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jamesvanderwulf
They aren't destroying our heritage. He's wrong about that.

Do you deny that the reason Dems have flipped so hard left on the border is that they see a major advantage to making immigrants voters? It's not about race. It's about votes.
That's just stupid.
The dems don't need more voters. They just need to stop the republicans from suppressing the vote. It's the republicans that need to find more voters.
Where do you people come up with these ideas?
 
That's just stupid.
The dems don't need more voters. They just need to stop the republicans from suppressing the vote. It's the republicans that need to find more voters.
Where do you people come up with these ideas?
And making DC a state isn't about adding 2 senators either right?
 
It's a shame that this theory - and similar concepts - are seemingly getting normalized via Fox News rather than ostracized to anonymous online groups or far right organizations.

Hopefully it's limited to this Tucker segment and it doesn't become a popular flavor.
Are you upset that he is letting your secret out?
 
The vast majority of asylum seekers aren't legitimately in need of asylum. So don't go there.

Also, it actually doesn't have anything to do with skin color. He doesn't argue that.

I think he makes a couple leaps here, but they aren't unforeseeable. First off, he assumes that opening the borders to illegals is a precursor to giving them the right to vote. He's also assuming that the right to vote is going to be opened to noncitizens.

He's not entirely wrong, but we are not yet where he seems to believe we are.

Not about color? Are there a lot of white people coming into the US illegally from third world countries at our southern border?
 
Immigration = voter disenfranchisement is not a theory I have heard before, though I am not surprised that the first time I heard such a theory it came from Tucker.
 
They aren't destroying our heritage. He's wrong about that.

Do you deny that the reason Dems have flipped so hard left on the border is that they see a major advantage to making immigrants voters? It's not about race. It's about votes.

Yes, I deny it.

It's pretty telling that Republicans don't even see expanding their popularity to attract new voters as a strategy. Oh no, DC could be a state and brown people may come here, what should we do? Should we promote policies that are popular with more voters? No, let's call those people dirty, lazy, rapists, free loaders and try to restrict voting and gerrymandering as much as we possibly can so we can stay in power as the minority power.
 
They aren't destroying our heritage. He's wrong about that.

Do you deny that the reason Dems have flipped so hard left on the border is that they see a major advantage to making immigrants voters? It's not about race. It's about votes.
BS, its about being a decent human being while also understanding many parts of the US are experiencing a labor crisis due to a shortage of able and willing workers.

GQP'ers make these ridiculous claims that the lefts stance on the border is about harvesting future votes when again, its just about being decent human beings and doing the right thing that is in line with our countries founding principles.

The GQP has become a racist and fear mongering political party, there is no denying it.
 
The crazy thing about this issue is that in another 20 years or so, countries will be actively competing for immigrants. Every advanced economy is in or headed for population collapse, and needs an influx of young workers/taxpayers to support their mushroom population pyramid.

We could get a jump start on the rest of the world, but instead big chunks of America are reacting like "brown skin and speaking Spanish, eew!"
 
Someone needs to watch the Jon Oliver segment.
Are lot of people complaining when doctors and engineers come to United States from India?

has nothing to do with color. It’s about poor uneducated people flooding the country and nuking local schools and social services.

sone teacher in Iowa gave to prepare lesson plans in three languages. You think that sounds like a great education? Kids don’t learn near as much as they could because of the time wasted.
 
Are lot of people complaining when doctors and engineers come to United States from India?

has nothing to do with color. It’s about poor uneducated people flooding the country and nuking local schools and social services.

sone teacher in Iowa gave to prepare lesson plans in three languages. You think that sounds like a great education? Kids don’t learn near as much as they could because of the time wasted.
Wow, that sounds terrible!!! Good thing this country wasn’t made of immigrants- that would have been a disaster!
 
Are lot of people complaining when doctors and engineers come to United States from India?

has nothing to do with color. It’s about poor uneducated people flooding the country and nuking local schools and social services.

sone teacher in Iowa gave to prepare lesson plans in three languages. You think that sounds like a great education? Kids don’t learn near as much as they could because of the time wasted.
you're drunk and stupid

Poor and disadvantaged people can and will be some of the smartest and most beautiful people in the world. Give people a chance...isn't that the right thing to do? Doesn't that make our country better? Is there not a labor crisis with a lack of willing and able workers in many parts of our country?

Kids in Iowa(i'm guessing you're from Iowa) could only be so lucky to be exposed to three different languages in classrooms... you're such a dolt
 
It would be interesting to see who tucker hires to handle all of the things he doesn’t do for himself....
 
Well, he says the left gets hysterical and calls it replacement and then says that's exactly what happens so I don't think it's a stretch for somebody else to make that claim.

You think when he makes this claim he only means the people that come here illegally? Asylum seekers aren't illegals. You think he isn't in favor of shutting down virtually all immigration of brown people?
Do you feel those coming from Mexico justify asylum?
 
BS, its about being a decent human being while also understanding many parts of the US are experiencing a labor crisis due to a shortage of able and willing workers.

GQP'ers make these ridiculous claims that the lefts stance on the border is about harvesting future votes when again, its just about being decent human beings and doing the right thing that is in line with our countries founding principles.

The GQP has become a racist and fear mongering political party, there is no denying it.

You know why I know your opinion is bullshit? Look at who visits the border and cries for the misery these people are suffering through.

Now it’s republicans with no sign of Biden, Harris, or any other Democrats.

When this was happening under Trumps watch, the Democrats were down there daily crying for these immigrants, with no sign of republicans.

So human decency? Bullshit. Political positioning, yes
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT