ADVERTISEMENT

Federal judge hands Musk’s DOGE a win on data access at 3 agencies

Obama created it via executive order. It was the USDS (US Digital Service). The term DOGE is being used but it's officially the USDS.
At the very least, DOGE is every bit the agency USAID is. I don't understand how people can continue to claim otherwise.

The United States Agency for International Development (USAID) was created by President John F. Kennedy on November 3, 1961, through Executive Order 10973.
 
I thought only Congress could create executive branch agencies.

I look forward to all the Constitutional scholars educating me this afternoon.
FWIW, I’m pretty sure the issue is statutory rather than constitutional. And as I think otherwise noted, I think the doge predecessor usds has some authorization.
 
At the very least, DOGE is every bit the agency USAID is. I don't understand how people can continue to claim otherwise.

The United States Agency for International Development (USAID) was created by President John F. Kennedy on November 3, 1961, through Executive Order 10973.
Except USAID's activities are explicitly controlled by acts of Congress.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bcherod and Moral
Except USAID's activities are explicitly controlled by acts of Congress.
True, but Congress clearly has failed in the oversite of USAID when our taxpayer money is going to things such as the $1.5 million they sent to advance DEI in Serbian workplaces. That is insane & wrong no matter how you look at it, and I am glad they are stopping some of this rediculous spending when we have so many Americans who are in need. And, the chances are hight that at some point Congress will take this over too.
 
Last edited:
If you think there is any REAL oversight going on with USAID

And this is WHY Congress appropriates those funds:



IN 2008, I DEPLOYED TO AFGHANISTAN for the first time on a Provincial Reconstruction Team. Our group included active-duty airmen and soldiers as well as reservists and guardsmen. But the linchpin of our team was our USAID embed, David. He may not have been lethal with a weapon, but without him we would have failed catastrophically.

David had been to Iraq before he volunteered in Afghanistan. He not only went outside the wire in some of Afghanistan’s most dangerous, insurgent-infested regions, but also showed the ropes to newbies like myself.


In 2008, most of America’s military might was focused on Iraq, so those of us fighting the “good war” in Afghanistan had to make do with what we could get. For most of my deployment, we had fewer than 300 personnel (my small squad from the PRT and a company of the 101st) to hold down most of Kapisa, a province of 700 square miles and half a million people. We did not have the military might to clear and hold terrain. David and the USAID were the only way we could get into hard-to-reach places.

USAID helped us make friends and allies in Afghanistan that no number of soldiers, diplomats, or intelligence officers could. Food and medicine and infrastructure buy good will, good will translates to conversations, and conversations turn into intelligence and partnerships, which were vital not only to our mission but to keeping us safe.

David wasn’t the only USAID representative I served with. Through my career, I proudly served alongside hundreds of USAID personnel.
Some, like my friend Jody, served for years in Afghanistan. USAID frequently sends its employees—armed only with humanitarian aid—into areas the military deems too dangerous for conventional forces. It should come as no surprise that these American heroes sometimes make the ultimate sacrifice.
 
N
And this is WHY Congress appropriates those funds:



IN 2008, I DEPLOYED TO AFGHANISTAN for the first time on a Provincial Reconstruction Team. Our group included active-duty airmen and soldiers as well as reservists and guardsmen. But the linchpin of our team was our USAID embed, David. He may not have been lethal with a weapon, but without him we would have failed catastrophically.

David had been to Iraq before he volunteered in Afghanistan. He not only went outside the wire in some of Afghanistan’s most dangerous, insurgent-infested regions, but also showed the ropes to newbies like myself.


In 2008, most of America’s military might was focused on Iraq, so those of us fighting the “good war” in Afghanistan had to make do with what we could get. For most of my deployment, we had fewer than 300 personnel (my small squad from the PRT and a company of the 101st) to hold down most of Kapisa, a province of 700 square miles and half a million people. We did not have the military might to clear and hold terrain. David and the USAID were the only way we could get into hard-to-reach places.

USAID helped us make friends and allies in Afghanistan that no number of soldiers, diplomats, or intelligence officers could. Food and medicine and infrastructure buy good will, good will translates to conversations, and conversations turn into intelligence and partnerships, which were vital not only to our mission but to keeping us safe.

David wasn’t the only USAID representative I served with. Through my career, I proudly served alongside hundreds of USAID personnel.
Some, like my friend Jody, served for years in Afghanistan. USAID frequently sends its employees—armed only with humanitarian aid—into areas the military deems too dangerous for conventional forces. It should come as no surprise that these American heroes sometimes make the ultimate sacrifice.
Every time I read someone saying stupid shit about foreign aid, I’m reminded of this.

 
  • Like
Reactions: WadeLookingbill
If you think there is any REAL oversight going on with USAID then you are the clueless one. No disrespect intended
And whose fault is that Hawk? This “USAid” fund is no secret department ..it is funded by Congress and can be audited at the request of any one member of Congress…Congress is notorious for failure of oversight….renember tge mortgage/insurance collapse during Junior’s presidency? Lack of congressional oversight….
The border /immigration “crisis” of the past 20 years?? Lack of Congress oversight/action…
 
  • Like
Reactions: KFsdisciple
You are clueless when you claim Congress isn't overseeing USAID.
Any idea on that process? Need it posted for you?
Somehow, "Things I don't like" became "fraud" in the minds of MAGA. A very dangerous precedent to do. They are putting a lot of faith in the idea that Democrats won't turn around and use these new interpretations of power on them when they get in power again. In fairness, it's not like Democrats have given them a whole lot of reasons to fear them.
 
And this is WHY Congress appropriates those funds:



IN 2008, I DEPLOYED TO AFGHANISTAN for the first time on a Provincial Reconstruction Team. Our group included active-duty airmen and soldiers as well as reservists and guardsmen. But the linchpin of our team was our USAID embed, David. He may not have been lethal with a weapon, but without him we would have failed catastrophically.

David had been to Iraq before he volunteered in Afghanistan. He not only went outside the wire in some of Afghanistan’s most dangerous, insurgent-infested regions, but also showed the ropes to newbies like myself.


In 2008, most of America’s military might was focused on Iraq, so those of us fighting the “good war” in Afghanistan had to make do with what we could get. For most of my deployment, we had fewer than 300 personnel (my small squad from the PRT and a company of the 101st) to hold down most of Kapisa, a province of 700 square miles and half a million people. We did not have the military might to clear and hold terrain. David and the USAID were the only way we could get into hard-to-reach places.

USAID helped us make friends and allies in Afghanistan that no number of soldiers, diplomats, or intelligence officers could. Food and medicine and infrastructure buy good will, good will translates to conversations, and conversations turn into intelligence and partnerships, which were vital not only to our mission but to keeping us safe.

David wasn’t the only USAID representative I served with. Through my career, I proudly served alongside hundreds of USAID personnel.
Some, like my friend Jody, served for years in Afghanistan. USAID frequently sends its employees—armed only with humanitarian aid—into areas the military deems too dangerous for conventional forces. It should come as no surprise that these American heroes sometimes make the ultimate sacrifice.
I can show you TONS of wonderful things that Congress funds. By using your logic, that would mean that congress never allocates anything that should NOT be funded. You don't want to die on that hill do you?
 
And whose fault is that Hawk? This “USAid” fund is no secret department ..it is funded by Congress and can be audited at the request of any one member of Congress…Congress is notorious for failure of oversight….renember tge mortgage/insurance collapse during Junior’s presidency? Lack of congressional oversight….
The border /immigration “crisis” of the past 20 years?? Lack of Congress oversight/action…
Joel, it is the fault of Congress for sure. That is the whole point. I don't blame Dems anymore then I blame Republicans. That is why Trump was elected and why the RHINOS are sticking with the Dems on this stuff. They all want status quo and the Amercian people are tired of it. And thus, we have an actual audit of these bloated agencies going on right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: libbity bibbity
Joel, it is the fault of Congress for sure. That is the whole point. I don't blame Dems anymore then I blame Republicans. That is why Trump was elected and why the RHINOS are sticking with the Dems on this stuff. They all want status quo and the Amercian people are tired of it. And thus, we have an actual audit of these bloated agencies going on right now.
A lot of the “headlines” will turn out to Bev bullshit and lies… how in the hell can a kid walk into someone’s books and declare billions of $$$ of waste after looking at the books for a couple of days? There is no reputable accountant/biokkeeper/auditor that works that way…only those folks with an agenda. This, like everything Trump is nothing more than theatrics and diversion. Trump will make up some numbers to ram through a tax cut that will greatly serve his billionaire friends and cohearts. He will phuque every American he has to and every American ally he can to accomplish his ends.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bcherod
True, but Congress clearly has failed in the oversite of USAID when our taxpayer money is going to things such as the $1.5 million they sent to advance DEI in Serbian workplaces. That is insane & wrong no matter how you look at it, and I am glad they are stopping some of this rediculous spending when we have so many Americans who are in need. And, the chances are hight that at some point Congress will take this over too.
That doesn’t matter. Congress needs to fix it. You can’t skirt the constitution. Which is what they are doing. This isn’t a difficult concept to grasp. It’s why you can’t go shoot someone while they are awaiting trial.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT