Honestly it’s ten years from now. On what was the best movie in a given year. If a piece of art still holds up after multiple viewings and years then we know which is better. Saving Private Ryan or Shakespeare in Love? Pulp Fiction , Shawshank Redemption, or Forrest Gump.
First one was a good example. The second not so much because I would consider them all classics on par with each other.
The worst snubs for best picture in my opinion are:
2022 Top Gun Maverick losing to Everything Everywhere All At Once (and I say that as a huge SciFi and Fantasy Fan who did love EEAAO but realizes that Top Gun Maverick wasn’t just the best picture that year, but the best one since Mad Max Fury Road in 2015 and arguably since 2012 Django Unchained)
2021 Dune instead of Coda (I mean come on! Dune was considered “unfilmable” by countless famous directors and it was turned into a masterpiece on par with the Lord of the Rings)
2015 Mad Max Fury Road instead of Spotlight
2012 Django Unchained instead of Argo
2009 Inglorious Bastards instead of The Hurt Locker
2004 Sideways instead of Million Dollar Baby
1999 The Matrix or Green Mile instead of American Beauty
1998 Saving Private Ryan or Big Lebowski instead of Shakespeare in Love
1989 Dead Poets Society instead of Driving Miss Daisy
1985 Goonies or The Color Purple or Back to the Future or The Breakfast Club or Fletch or St Elmo’s Fire or Flesh and Blood or Pee Wee’s Big Adventure or Clue or Legend or Brazil or Ran or Enemy Mine instead of Out of Africa
1980 Caddyshack or Empire Strikes Back or 9 to 5 or The Blues Brothers or The Gods Must Be Crazy or Airplane or Raging Bull or Fame instead of Ordinary People
I’m not going past the 80s because I don’t know enough of the oldies to consider myself informed on the subject.
I was very tempted to add 2000 as it has O Brother Where Art Thou which is probably my favorite movie of all time. But Gladiator is also excellent so it’s tough to say it was a “snub”.