ADVERTISEMENT

Intermat top50

jrod65

HB All-American
Jan 21, 2019
2,892
10,967
113
Intermat running a top 50 college wrestlers. Releasing one each day, leading up to the start of the season. Kaleb Young just came in at 47. Anyone want to take a stab at who/where other Hawkeyes will come in?

Spencer
Eierman
Kemerer
Desanto
Warner
Cassioppi
Bull

 
Intermat running a top 50 college wrestlers. Releasing one each day, leading up to the start of the season. Kaleb Young just came in at 47. Anyone want to take a stab at who/where other Hawkeyes will come in?

Spencer 1
Eierman 9
Kemerer 8
Desanto 35
Warner 40
Cassioppi 25
Bull 15

 
Tough to overlook Spencer’s 3 titles, 1 additional Hodge, and absolute dominance in terms of bonus %.
My heart agrees with you. If the list was top NCAA tournament wrestlers then Spence is #1. But when the whole season is taken into account, I think Gable edges him a bit. Spences record is 64-5. Gable is 68-2. Getting stuck by Picc in the first period doesn’t help his case nor does a loss to Ronnie Bresser. Gable lost twice to multiple NCAA Cassar by one point. There is certainly not a close third however. It’s Gable, Spence then everyone else IMHO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: War Hawkeye
My heart agrees with you. If the list was top NCAA tournament wrestlers then Spence is #1. But when the whole season is taken into account, I think Gable edges him a bit. Spences record is 64-5. Gable is 68-2. Getting stuck by Picc in the first period doesn’t help his case nor does a loss to Ronnie Bresser. Gable lost twice to multiple NCAA Cassar by one point. There is certainly not a close third however. It’s Gable, Spence then everyone else IMHO.
I don't believe this is for the GOAT - but where they are at as a college wrestler right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torg
This has the potential to be a great idea, but pound for pound lists always come with a great deal of controversy. I’m willing to bet that most of Iowa’s lineup will be represented. I’m wondering how many we get in the top 20. I would think Kem, Bull, Big Cass, and ADS have a solid chance at making the top 25. I’m biased, but you could make an argument for each. Good idea by Intermat, they’ll be getting at least 46 clicks out of me!
 
  • Like
Reactions: rider57
Cassar was a one time NCAA qualifier.
Indeed he was. Big Ten and NCAA Champion that season, beating Steveson at both events.

In fairness he would have been at minimum a 2x NCAA qualifier if healthy when he was granted a 6th year or whatever it was. He got better as he went along, that's for sure. I was surprised he beat Steveson to end his undefeated record, then did it again.
 
Indeed he was. Big Ten and NCAA Champion that season, beating Steveson at both events.

In fairness he would have been at minimum a 2x NCAA qualifier if healthy when he was granted a 6th year or whatever it was. He got better as he went along, that's for sure. I was surprised he beat Steveson to end his undefeated record, then did it again.
Not true. He was a backup and injury granted him extra years. He wouldn’t have started in his injuries years!!!
 
y'all make some good points - pros and cons.

what's even crazier is that both of them went right from the jump as TR Freshmen. Spencer's gonna be a 4xer and Gable gonna have a loss to only 1 person + an OLY Gold while still in college. it's unreal.
 
We are talking about college wrestler so what happened in the freestyle season is irrelevant although hard to ignore. Not to diminish what GS did, I would add that Spencer is better at freestyle than folk and if he was healthy would have brought home gold in Japan also.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Jrjt0518
Right now my vote would be Gable #1. Olympic Gold Medalist to add to his dominant NCAA year. There simply has never been a heavy like GS. Second point is that Spencer is injured. As they claim..No ACls. If he wrestlers, it won’t be the same guy we saw the first 2 years. He may not be as dominant and you need to take that into account. Going for number 4 is a great storyline but he is injured. Could not do worlds, could not do the Olympics and I believe close to tapping out at the NCAAs. I believe the knee injuries knocks him down on the pound for pound also.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TNTwrestle
Right now my vote would be Gable #1. Olympic Gold Medalist to add to his dominant NCAA year. There simply has never been a heavy like GS. Second point is that Spencer is injured. As they claim..No ACls. If he wrestlers, it won’t be the same guy we saw the first 2 years. He may not be as dominant and you need to take that into account. Going for number 4 is a great storyline but he is injured. Could not do worlds, could not do the Olympics and I believe close to tapping out at the NCAAs. I believe the knee injuries knocks him down on the pound for pound also.
I don't care about Intermat's ranking, but you do realize he won NCAA'S last year after he tore his ACL right? And was 1 point away from bonus in every match when Courtney ran from him, and shut him out to boot. He did that 8 days after he had no ACL's, and he'll have 8 months to recover before he starts again. I don't know what we'll get from Spencer Lee in 2022, but I'm betting it will be pretty darn good. Nobody is going to lay down for him, IF he wins a 4th Title, he'll have earned it the hard way, that's for damn sure.

By the time NCAA's rolls around, maybe he'll be part of "The Field" again...........
 
My heart agrees with you. If the list was top NCAA tournament wrestlers then Spence is #1. But when the whole season is taken into account, I think Gable edges him a bit. Spences record is 64-5. Gable is 68-2. Getting stuck by Picc in the first period doesn’t help his case nor does a loss to Ronnie Bresser. Gable lost twice to multiple NCAA Cassar by one point. There is certainly not a close third however. It’s Gable, Spence then everyone else IMHO.
Where would a guy with a 66-1 record fit in, then? Not close to 64-5 or 68-2?
 
Right now my vote would be Gable #1. Olympic Gold Medalist to add to his dominant NCAA year. There simply has never been a heavy like GS. Second point is that Spencer is injured. As they claim..No ACls. If he wrestlers, it won’t be the same guy we saw the first 2 years. He may not be as dominant and you need to take that into account. Going for number 4 is a great storyline but he is injured. Could not do worlds, could not do the Olympics and I believe close to tapping out at the NCAAs. I believe the knee injuries knocks him down on the pound for pound also.
Of course psu James. Name says enough!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grip220
Where would a guy with a 66-1 record fit in, then? Not close to 64-5 or 68-2?
Of course Yianni is great, but he wins a lot of close matches. In his two NCAA titles he’s gotten bonus points in just two matches out of 10. Spence and Gable are just a few notches above him at this point. He doesn’t wrestle the strength of schedule that Spencer and Gable get in the B10, so that hurts him as well. He’d b my number 3 though.
 
Again my post says it all!! If Spencer isn’t number 1 it will be click bait for willie!!! Willie is in the middle now and debating what he is gonna do to get a response. I know people that know him. He likes contraversy!! That’s facts!!!
 
Of course Yianni is great, but he wins a lot of close matches. In his two NCAA titles he’s gotten bonus points in just two matches out of 10. Spence and Gable are just a few notches above him at this point. He doesn’t wrestle the strength of schedule that Spencer and Gable get in the B10, so that hurts him as well. He’d b my number 3 though.
He wins close matches, but the emphasis should be on "wins," right? You compared the w/l records of Lee and Gable, so that must count for something.

As for NCAAs: as a true freshman, he beat the #1 seed Meredith (NCAA 2/4/2) for the second time, the #2 seed Eierman (5/4/3/2) revenging his only college loss, and the #8 seed Heil (4/1/1/R12 (thanks to Yianni)), and you think he should have gotten more bonus wins in that run? As a sophomore, he beat the #11 seed Red (7/8/-/6), the #5 seed Demas (4), the #2 seed Eierman (for the third straight time), and the #3 seed McKenna (3/-/3/2), and he should have gotten more bonus wins in that run, as well?

Just for grins, I added up the AA status of everyone Lee and Yianni faced in their NCAA runs:

Lee: 2021 (3xAA), 2019 (5xAA), 2018 (8xAA)
Yianni: 2019 (11xAA), 2018 (10xAA)

Who had by far the toughest NCAA schedule?

Strength of schedule: Yianni's RPI scores were .711 and .733; Lee's were .741, .707, and .708; Gable's were .704, .700, and .718. Of course, the B1G is the toughest conference, but that doesn't mean that nobody outside the B1G has a tough schedule as well. (BTW, Yianni's record against B1G opponents is 10-0)

"There is certainly not a close third however." Let's give credit where credit is due, is all.
 
Last edited:
He wins close matches, but the emphasis should be on "wins," right? You compared the w/l records of Lee and Gable, so that must count for something.

As for NCAAs: as a true freshman, he beat the #1 seed Meredith (NCAA 2/4/2) for the second time, the #2 seed Eierman (5/4/3/2) revenging his only college loss, and the #8 seed Heil (4/1/1/R12 (thanks to Yianni)), and you think he should have gotten more bonus wins in that run? As a sophomore, he beat the #11 seed Red (7/8/-/6), the #5 seed Demas (4), the #2 seed Eierman (for the third straight time), and the #3 seed McKenna (3/-/3/2), and he should have gotten more bonus wins in that run, as well?

Just for grins, I added up the AA status of everyone Lee and Yianni faced in their NCAA runs:

Lee: 2021 (3xAA), 2019 (5xAA), 2018 (8xAA)
Yianni: 2019 (11xAA), 2018 (10xAA)

Who had by far the toughest NCAA schedule?

Strength of schedule: Yianni's RPI scores were .711 and .733; Lee's were .741, .707, and .708; Gable's were .704, .700, and .718. Of course, the B1G is the toughest conference, but that doesn't mean that nobody outside the B1G has a tough schedule as well. (BTW, Yianni's record against B1G opponents is 11-1)

"There is certainly not a close third however." Let's give credit where credit is due, is all.
Spencer stuck National Champion Tomasello, then manhandled future National Champion up a weight Suriano. Then the weight class cleared out. What else ya got.
 
Spencer stuck National Champion Tomasello, then manhandled future National Champion up a weight Suriano. Then the weight class cleared out. What else ya got.
The difference here is that nobody (including me) is disputing Lee's bona fides, but Yianni is said to be a distant third behind Lee and Steveson. No respect.
 
The difference here is that nobody (including me) is disputing Lee's bona fides, but Yianni is said to be a distant third behind Lee and Steveson. No respect.
Yeah, because there's a large gap between lee/steveson and Yianni.

People can argue whether Lee or Steveson get the 1 or 2 (personally I think it's clearly Lee if you're going off college results, he has 1 extra hodge and 1 extra national title) but nobody in their right mind is arguing Yianni as 1st or 2nd, because he's a DISTANT THIRD behind them.
 
Yeah, because there's a large gap between lee/steveson and Yianni.

People can argue whether Lee or Steveson get the 1 or 2 (personally I think it's clearly Lee if you're going off college results, he has 1 extra hodge and 1 extra national title) but nobody in their right mind is arguing Yianni as 1st or 2nd, because he's a DISTANT THIRD behind them.

I'm not saying I would put Yianni at 2 (or 1), but I think the case could be made.

Spencer - 3 for 3 national titles, 5 career losses, 2x Hodge
Yianni - 2 for 2 national titles, 1 career loss
Gable - 1 for 2 national titles, 2 career losses, Hodge

For me, the Hodge is what elevates Gable over Yianni. But other people may value more the fact that Yianni is "perfect" at NCAAs
 
The difference here is that nobody (including me) is disputing Lee's bona fides, but Yianni is said to be a distant third behind Lee and Steveson. No respect.
You gave it to him. Good job. He's also out of sight out of mind because he didn't go last year, thru no fault of his own other than he chose to attend an Ivy League school. And yeah, he's very good, as most 2x National Champions are.

But bonus points do matter, ask the Hodge winners and Teams that win National Titles or Team Trophies.

Yianni seems like a great kid too, and he's likely smart enough to be thankful that Spencer Lee is a lifetime 125 lber., two ACL's, one ACL or no ACL's.
 
Big fan of both but this can’t be anyone but Spencer at number one. He should already be a four timer. He has two more titles, one more Hodge. Just going off college it’s not to hard.

So we have Lee, Gable, Yianni then who? Brooks, Cstar, Griffith, Ferrari?
 
  • Like
Reactions: War Hawkeye
It will be interesting to see how they rank the younger 1 time NCs vs the *earned* 4 time AA's:

Carr, Brooks, Starocci, Ferrari, Griffith

Eierman, Amine
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT