ADVERTISEMENT

Mayo vs. Mustard

If you had to pick one or the other (or both)which condiment do you prefer on your sandwich?


  • Total voters
    81

Skidlt

HB MVP
Gold Member
Aug 13, 2003
2,027
304
83
Favorite kinds also appreciated in a response. Also - maybe you hate both, what would you use instead?
 
Mayo on peanut butter and jelly.
giphy.gif
 
Mayo works on most sandwiches. Not so for mustard.

If I had to do without one, I would do without mayo, but that doesn't change the fact that it is more versatile.

And, of course, by "mayo" I mean Miracle Whip.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bagdropper
Ohh... Totally forgot about the miracle whip vs. "regular" mayo debate. Poll for another day. I actually like both. Please use them interchangeably for the poll.

BAB - were you joking or serious? Always willing to try new things, but you are pushing me out of my comfort zone!
 
I like mayo and I love mustard(s). I have 4 or 5 different mustards at any one time from Bright yellow to very grainy brown. Actually not a huge fan of honey mustard. I can also roll with horse radish and mustard / mayo combo.
It does vary widely based on a the meats or fish I am having as to which combo of condiments I use. I use very little ketchup but am not a hater.
 
Ohh... Totally forgot about the miracle whip vs. "regular" mayo debate. Poll for another day. I actually like both. Please use them interchangeably for the poll.

BAB - were you joking or serious? Always willing to try new things, but you are pushing me out of my comfort zone!

I'm joking, but I bet PB and J with mayo would be good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skidlt
On my Subway Cold Cut Combo I often get after work I'll get Mayo x2. Along with Veggies, Salt n' Peppa and Olive oil. Delicious and Great Value for the Price. My vote was Both.
 
1 type of mustard is boring. I usually have 3-4 most of the time.

Mayo is nasty. Miracle whip on a sandwich is ok.
 
The only thing I put mustard on is a brat and it’s the spicy mustard. Mayo is more versatile—I use it when I make grilled cheese sandwiches. Also better on cold cut sandwiches.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT