ADVERTISEMENT

Our new QB Gronowski is having surgery and will be back prepping for season in June

All I have gathered from reputable sources is He cannot throw till June which could be from Hernia or Shoulder so If He is in a sling soon - shoulder, If He is walking around looking like He is wearing depends that got filled by an elephant- hernia, and that based on reading thru this thread there are a few severely vax injured Hawk fans or in advanced Syphilis mental decline. You choose.
 
All I have gathered from reputable sources is He cannot throw till June which could be from Hernia or Shoulder so If He is in a sling soon - shoulder, If He is walking around looking like He is wearing depends that got filled by an elephant- hernia, and that based on reading thru this thread there are a few severely vax injured Hawk fans or in advanced Syphilis mental decline. You choose.
Ryan Reynolds Fun GIF by Apple TV+
 
Per Google AI:
Recovery time after labrum surgery depends on several factors, including the tear's severity and location, and the quality of the repair. It typically takes 6–9 months for a labrum tear to fully heal.
I’m hopeful it’s not a full tear and it’s mostly a “touch up” but yikes…
 
Petras took a full year off. Wasn’t even close at 6 months. Every situation is different but…🤷‍♂️. Sully gonna play alot barring injury for him.
 
Petras took a full year off. Wasn’t even close at 6 months. Every situation is different but…🤷‍♂️. Sully gonna play alot barring injury for him.
Petras tore his Rotator Cuff too which is a much longer recovery. I think this is the best case scenario after hearing that he was having surgery. It still sucks that we all got excited about getting a top shelf quarterback only to find out that he fell off the top shelf and is actually a scratch and dent in the bargain bin.
 
eric all the TE who came here with cade recovered from a much worse injury and even got drafted...so perhaps it will work out.
that said if necessary is it possible for G to take a medical redshirt and compete for 2026 instead?
 
You guys are fvcking hilarious. Sorry I mentioned my son having possibly the same surgery as our newest QB. 🤣
Well if you weren’t so thin skinned you might have been able to understand that the fact your son had this surgery had nothing to do with my thoughts about Gronowski being able to be ready in time because of the care HE was going to receive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarnelThomas
Wrong - it is a protection of health information and medical issues for all individuals.
From the university standpoint, it’s more likely FERPA that protects the personal information of students.

But yes, HIPAA* protects the privacy of all individuals. But it more governs what medical information doctors and medical institutions can disclose.

* Edited to use the correct abbreviation. Shoutout to @MeetTheFerentzes for the correction! ;)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MeetTheFerentzes
From the university standpoint, it’s more likely FERPA that protects the personal information of students.

But yes, HIPPA protects the privacy of all individuals. But it more governs what medical information doctors and medical institutions can disclose.
Finally someone said something right about this (except used HIPPA instead of HIPAA, like most people).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Max_Rebo
So, obviously, the situation with Gronowski's surgery and recovery time is disappointing. It may end up being OK, but you can't argue that missing spring reps means we are missing valuable opportunities for the offense to gel.

That said, I think it's worth thinking about what the coaching staff could have, or should have, done, once they learned that Gronowski would need the surgery. Here are the options, as I see them:
  1. Stop the recruitment of MG and stand pat with the guys you have -- Sullivan, Brown, Stratton, Sullivan, and Fitzgerald. Not a terrible QB room at all, and you cross your fingers that Sully improves or someone else steps up.
  2. Stop the recruitment of MG and look for another portal QB. The problem with this is that there's not much left. We already missed on Pribula. I suppose Devin Brown is still out there as a possibility, but he's unproven, and it's anyone's guess as to whether or not he would consider Iowa. (And it's entirely possible the Iowa staff already gauged interest from Brown and/or others and learned that it wasn't likely.)
  3. Stop the recruitment of MG and wait for the spring transfer portal to see what other QBs might be available. Pretty big gamble with this one. Who knows if any decent QBs would be available, or if they'd even be interested in Iowa.
  4. Stick with MG, and hope that the doctors are correct in that a full recovery will be possible by June. If not, you're no worse off than you would be if you went with option #1. In the meantime, you can use the spring for MG to get comfortable with his teammates, his coaches, and the playbook; and have more reps available for the rest of the QBs during spring practice, which should help strengthen depth and build for future development.
All things considered, I think option #4 is the smartest way to go. Far from ideal, obviously. But the best of the available options, as I see it.
 
Almost NO surgery makes things as good as it was before the injury. KF isn't stupid. This was by design. He wants a game manager of the running game who can make basic throws and move if need be. No Stanzi, Banks, or Tate need apply.

He's brought in 2 now with injuries.

Still, I wonder about the stats he had against Iowa. BAD against a real defense which he will face and without the RB, I doubt Iowa's O to be better than SDSUs
 
So, obviously, the situation with Gronowski's surgery and recovery time is disappointing. It may end up being OK, but you can't argue that missing spring reps means we are missing valuable opportunities for the offense to gel.

That said, I think it's worth thinking about what the coaching staff could have, or should have, done, once they learned that Gronowski would need the surgery. Here are the options, as I see them:
  1. Stop the recruitment of MG and stand pat with the guys you have -- Sullivan, Brown, Stratton, Sullivan, and Fitzgerald. Not a terrible QB room at all, and you cross your fingers that Sully improves or someone else steps up.
  2. Stop the recruitment of MG and look for another portal QB. The problem with this is that there's not much left. We already missed on Pribula. I suppose Devin Brown is still out there as a possibility, but he's unproven, and it's anyone's guess as to whether or not he would consider Iowa. (And it's entirely possible the Iowa staff already gauged interest from Brown and/or others and learned that it wasn't likely.)
  3. Stop the recruitment of MG and wait for the spring transfer portal to see what other QBs might be available. Pretty big gamble with this one. Who knows if any decent QBs would be available, or if they'd even be interested in Iowa.
  4. Stick with MG, and hope that the doctors are correct in that a full recovery will be possible by June. If not, you're no worse off than you would be if you went with option #1. In the meantime, you can use the spring for MG to get comfortable with his teammates, his coaches, and the playbook; and have more reps available for the rest of the QBs during spring practice, which should help strengthen depth and build for future development.
All things considered, I think option #4 is the smartest way to go. Far from ideal, obviously. But the best of the available options, as I see it.
Do you think Iowa is really going to report what the actual medical report is?
 
So, obviously, the situation with Gronowski's surgery and recovery time is disappointing. It may end up being OK, but you can't argue that missing spring reps means we are missing valuable opportunities for the offense to gel.

That said, I think it's worth thinking about what the coaching staff could have, or should have, done, once they learned that Gronowski would need the surgery. Here are the options, as I see them:
  1. Stop the recruitment of MG and stand pat with the guys you have -- Sullivan, Brown, Stratton, Sullivan, and Fitzgerald. Not a terrible QB room at all, and you cross your fingers that Sully improves or someone else steps up.
  2. Stop the recruitment of MG and look for another portal QB. The problem with this is that there's not much left. We already missed on Pribula. I suppose Devin Brown is still out there as a possibility, but he's unproven, and it's anyone's guess as to whether or not he would consider Iowa. (And it's entirely possible the Iowa staff already gauged interest from Brown and/or others and learned that it wasn't likely.)
  3. Stop the recruitment of MG and wait for the spring transfer portal to see what other QBs might be available. Pretty big gamble with this one. Who knows if any decent QBs would be available, or if they'd even be interested in Iowa.
  4. Stick with MG, and hope that the doctors are correct in that a full recovery will be possible by June. If not, you're no worse off than you would be if you went with option #1. In the meantime, you can use the spring for MG to get comfortable with his teammates, his coaches, and the playbook; and have more reps available for the rest of the QBs during spring practice, which should help strengthen depth and build for future development.
All things considered, I think option #4 is the smartest way to go. Far from ideal, obviously. But the best of the available options, as I see it.
Good assessment and they’re obviously putting a lot of faith in the whole medical team. To me, the only issue I have is the use of resources. I hope they didn’t completely break the bank for him. Missing out on Spring practice and the unknown of the recovery make it a much more risky acquisition.

The only thing that bothers me is it sounded as though MG’s camp was leveraging the NFL option to get as much as they could, when that wasn’t an option. I don’t begrudge him or his camp for giving that appearance but if I’m in a negotiation and the terms become less favorable I’m negotiating a cost reduction. I’m not sure if that did or didn’t happen.
 
All I have gathered from reputable sources is He cannot throw till June which could be from Hernia or Shoulder so If He is in a sling soon - shoulder, If He is walking around looking like He is wearing depends that got filled by an elephant- hernia, and that based on reading thru this thread there are a few severely vax injured Hawk fans or in advanced Syphilis mental decline. You choose.
What?? I've had two hernia surgeries, and your comment makes zero sense. Thats not something you can tell by looking at someone...
 
All I have gathered from reputable sources is He cannot throw till June which could be from Hernia or Shoulder so If He is in a sling soon - shoulder, If He is walking around looking like He is wearing depends that got filled by an elephant- hernia, and that based on reading thru this thread there are a few severely vax injured Hawk fans or in advanced Syphilis mental decline. You choose.
Shoulder - sounds like a debriding of the shoulder (slight labrum cleanup as well).

"Labrum tears / shoulder instability: Your physician may choose shoulder arthroscopy to fix a tear in the labrum — the cartilage that surrounds the shoulder socket — that can cause shoulder instability or regular dislocation. This is also known as a superior labrum, anterior to posterior (SLAP) tear. The tear may involve a shoulder dislocation. In that case, the surgeon will suture the torn labrum to the glenoid bone and could put anchors into the bone so it stays put. They may use debridement when fixing a tear, which removes frayed tissue or scar tissue."

Labrum is a sensitive little piece of the shoulder, they say 6mths but with MG being in great shape prior to surgery and having the full gambit of UI Sports Med at his disposal, he could be back sooner.
 
Almost NO surgery makes things as good as it was before the injury. KF isn't stupid. This was by design. He wants a game manager of the running game who can make basic throws and move if need be. No Stanzi, Banks, or Tate need apply.

He's brought in 2 now with injuries.

Still, I wonder about the stats he had against Iowa. BAD against a real defense which he will face and without the RB, I doubt Iowa's O to be better than SDSUs
Well I'll give MG a bit of a pass...we had a pretty salty D and were at home that game. IIRC too, the stud SDSU TE was dinged early so another pass catcher was unavailable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IIowaFarmBoy
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT